Bug 1628717 Comment 8 Edit History

Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.

(In reply to Sean Voisen (:svoisen) from comment #5)
> One maybe interesting data point is that they are all on Windows 10.0.14393, and no newer builds.

This is an interesting observation, and it's still sort-of true!!  Specifically: in my crash-report links from comment 6, **Buckets #2 and #3 are still all on this single Windows version**, which seems to be from 2016, based on
https://www.lifewire.com/windows-version-numbers-2625171

So it seems very likely that this category of crash is just an old Windows-internals print spooler bug, which has been fixed or worked around in newer versions.

Bucket #1 (the ones that involve the mysterious `brpri`/`breni` DLL) are all from a different version, Windows 10.0.19043, which I think is relatively recent.  I found a blog post about it here:
https://www.xda-developers.com/microsoft-releases-windows-10-build-19043-1165-heres-whats-new/
That one mentions that this specific version "There’s only a single highlight in this release" which "fixes a vulnerability in the Windows Print Spooler, and it’s pretty much all that’s new in this release."

That sounds like the sort of change that could have somehow-introduced a crash in `winspool.drv`; and given the involvement of these mysterious ungoogleable `br` DLLs, I wonder if maybe those DLLs are malware which manifests as a rogue print driver, which is trying to exploit the now-fixed vulnerability and is now simply crashing instead of successfully exploiting that Windows vulnerability.
(In reply to Sean Voisen (:svoisen) from comment #5)
> One maybe interesting data point is that they are all on Windows 10.0.14393, and no newer builds.

This is an interesting observation, and it's still sort-of true!!  Specifically: in my crash-report links from comment 6, **Buckets #2 and #3 are still all on this single Windows version**, which seems to be from 2016, based on
https://www.lifewire.com/windows-version-numbers-2625171

So it seems very likely that this category of crash is just an old Windows-internals print spooler bug, which has been fixed or worked around in newer versions.

Bucket #1 (the ones that involve the mysterious `brpri`/`breni` DLL) are all from a different version, Windows 10.0.19043, which I think is relatively recent (maybe the newest Windows 10 release).  I found a blog post about it here:
https://www.xda-developers.com/microsoft-releases-windows-10-build-19043-1165-heres-whats-new/
That one mentions that this specific version "There’s only a single highlight in this release" which "fixes a vulnerability in the Windows Print Spooler, and it’s pretty much all that’s new in this release."

That sounds like the sort of change that could have somehow-introduced a crash in `winspool.drv`; and given the involvement of these mysterious ungoogleable `br` DLLs, I wonder if maybe those DLLs are malware which manifests as a rogue print driver, which is trying to exploit the now-fixed vulnerability and is now simply crashing instead of successfully exploiting that Windows vulnerability.
(In reply to Sean Voisen (:svoisen) from comment #5)
> One maybe interesting data point is that they are all on Windows 10.0.14393, and no newer builds.

This is an interesting observation, and it's still sort-of true!!  Specifically: in my crash-report links from comment 6, **Buckets #2 and #3 are still all on this single Windows version**, which seems to be from 2016, based on
https://www.lifewire.com/windows-version-numbers-2625171

So it seems very likely that this category of crash is just an old Windows-internals print spooler bug, which has been fixed or worked around in newer versions.

Bucket #1 (the ones that involve the mysterious `brpri`/`breni` DLL) are all from a different version, Windows 10.0.19043, which I think is relatively recent (maybe the newest Windows 10 release).  I found a blog post about it here:
https://www.xda-developers.com/microsoft-releases-windows-10-build-19043-1165-heres-whats-new/
That one mentions that in this specific version, "There’s only a single highlight in this release" which "fixes a vulnerability in the Windows Print Spooler, and it’s pretty much all that’s new in this release."

That sounds like the sort of change that could have somehow-introduced a crash in `winspool.drv`; and given the involvement of these mysterious ungoogleable `br` DLLs, I wonder if maybe those DLLs are malware which manifests as a rogue print driver, which is trying to exploit the now-fixed vulnerability and is now simply crashing instead of successfully exploiting that Windows vulnerability.

Back to Bug 1628717 Comment 8