Bug 1678921 Comment 0 Edit History

Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.

STR:

1. enable the bookmarks toolbar
2. make sure that the bookmarks toolbar is empty
3. drag an open tab to the bookmarks toolbar

Actual:

It depends on where you released the tab. With a German build and the display resolution of my MacBook Pro the new empty state text (introduced in bug 1674091) makes ~ 40 percent of the bookmarks toolbar and it's not possible to use this space for bookmarking a page. Instead of bookmarking the tab the tab will be moved to a new window. This is a completely different result and therefore an unexpected usability regression. 

Expected:

The page should be bookmarked no matter where I release the tab, even if I release the tab on the empty state text. This action should not move the tab to a new window.
STR:

1. enable the bookmarks toolbar
2. make sure that the bookmarks toolbar is empty
3. drag an open tab to the bookmarks toolbar

Actual:

It depends on where you released the tab. With a German build and the display resolution of my MacBook Pro the new empty state text (introduced in bug 1674091) makes ~ 40 percent of the bookmarks toolbar and it's not possible to use this space for bookmarking a page. Instead of bookmarking the page the tab will be moved to a new window. This is a completely different result and therefore an unexpected usability regression. 

Expected:

The page should be bookmarked no matter where I release the tab, even if I release the tab on the empty state text. This action should not move the tab to a new window.

Back to Bug 1678921 Comment 0