Magnus, you've set this as P1 due to the very exposed wrong UI state (9 duplicates). Now that it's actionable, could you assign someone? I'll add a possible starting point in code in my next comment. Thank you very much Andreas Sch. for this crystal-clear bug report in perfect shape! Let's reopen this one for a clean start to work on bug 1670243, which doesn't have a good description, but a number of fuzzy comments, currently at comment 29 while trying to figure out what's going on... Confirmed for Release 78.12.0 (32-bit), Beta 91.0b2 (64-bit), and Daily 91.0b2 (64-bit). - Happens exactly as described after previewing the testcase message of attachment 9191420 [details]. - Obviously highly irritating that TB keeps showing a stale `Sender:` header on any unrelated messages. - Priority P1 set by mkmelin on original bug 1670243, which has 8 more duplicates. **STR** 1. Copy message of minimal testcase 1 (attachment 9191420 [details], sMimeSenderHeaderTest.eml) into any TB folder (IMAP or local). - `S/MIME signed message` - `From: != signing address`, which triggers display of `Sender:` header (important) even when... - `mailnews.headers.showSender = false` (important; bug may not happen otherwise) 2. First view other messages *before* viewing the testcase (for comparison). 3. View testcase 1 (in preview pane or in a tab). 4. Then view any unrelated messages in any folder of any account *after* viewing the testcase. **Actual result** - *Before* viewing testcase, all messages will display with correct headers. - *After* viewing testcase, all messages will henceforth display with the stale `Sender:` header of testcase 1. **Expected result** - `Sender:` header must be hidden from message header display for any message which does not have a `Sender:` header which we need to show.
Bug 1680843 Comment 5 Edit History
Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.
Magnus, you've set this as P1 due to the very exposed wrong UI state (9 duplicates). Now that it's actionable, could you assign someone? I'll add a possible starting point in code in my next comment. Thank you very much Andreas Sch. for this crystal-clear bug report in perfect shape! Let's reopen this one for a clean start to work on bug 1670243, which doesn't have a good description and is currently already at comment 29 due to a worthwhile effort of trying to figure out bit by bit what's going on... Confirmed for Release 78.12.0 (32-bit), Beta 91.0b2 (64-bit), and Daily 91.0b2 (64-bit). - Happens exactly as described after previewing the testcase message of attachment 9191420 [details]. - Obviously highly irritating that TB keeps showing a stale `Sender:` header on any unrelated messages. - Priority P1 set by mkmelin on original bug 1670243, which has 8 more duplicates. **STR** 1. Copy message of minimal testcase 1 (attachment 9191420 [details], sMimeSenderHeaderTest.eml) into any TB folder (IMAP or local). - `S/MIME signed message` - `From: != signing address`, which triggers display of `Sender:` header (important) even when... - `mailnews.headers.showSender = false` (important; bug may not happen otherwise) 2. First view other messages *before* viewing the testcase (for comparison). 3. View testcase 1 (in preview pane or in a tab). 4. Then view any unrelated messages in any folder of any account *after* viewing the testcase. **Actual result** - *Before* viewing testcase, all messages will display with correct headers. - *After* viewing testcase, all messages will henceforth display with the stale `Sender:` header of testcase 1. **Expected result** - `Sender:` header must be hidden from message header display for any message which does not have a `Sender:` header which we need to show.
Magnus, you've set this as P1 due to the very exposed wrong UI state (9 duplicates). Now that it's actionable, could you assign someone? I'll add a possible starting point in code in my next comment. Thank you very much Andreas Sch. for this crystal-clear bug report in perfect shape! Let's reopen this one for a clean start to work on bug 1670243, which doesn't have a good description and is currently already at comment 29 due to a worthwhile effort of trying to figure out bit by bit what's going on... Confirmed for Release 78.12.0 (32-bit), Beta 91.0b2 (64-bit), and Daily 91.0b2 (64-bit). - Happens exactly as described after previewing the testcase message of attachment 9191420 [details]. - Obviously highly irritating that TB keeps showing a stale `Sender:` header on any unrelated messages. - Priority P1 set by mkmelin on original bug 1670243, which has 8 more duplicates. **STR** 1. Copy message of minimal testcase 1 (attachment 9191420 [details], sMimeSenderHeaderTest.eml) into any TB folder (IMAP or local). - `S/MIME signed message` - `From: != signing address`, which triggers display of `Sender:` header (important) even when... - `mailnews.headers.showSender = false` (important; bug may not happen otherwise) 2. First view other messages *before* viewing the testcase (for comparison). 3. View testcase 1 (in preview pane or in a tab). 4. Then view any unrelated messages in any folder of any account *after* viewing the testcase. **Actual result** - *Before* viewing testcase, all messages will display with correct headers. - *After* viewing testcase, all messages will henceforth display with the stale `Sender:` header of testcase 1. **Expected result** - `Sender:` header must be hidden from message header display for any message which does not have a `Sender:` header which we need to show; while still respecting `mailnews.headers.showSender` pref (see comment 7 for the current code which seems to attempt just that).
Magnus, you've set this as P1 due to the very exposed wrong UI state (9 duplicates). Now that it's actionable, could you assign someone? I'll add a possible starting point in code in my next comment. Thank you very much Andreas Sch. for this crystal-clear bug report in perfect shape! Let's reopen this one for a clean start to work on bug 1670243, which doesn't have a good description and is currently already at comment 29 due to a worthwhile effort of trying to figure out bit by bit what's going on... Confirmed for Release 78.12.0 (32-bit), Beta 91.0b2 (64-bit), and Daily 91.0b2 (64-bit). - Happens exactly as described after previewing the testcase message of attachment 9191420 [details]. - Obviously highly irritating that TB keeps showing a stale `Sender:` header on any unrelated messages. - Priority P1 set by mkmelin on original bug 1670243, which has 8 more duplicates. **STR** 1. Copy message of minimal testcase 1 (attachment 9191420 [details], sMimeSenderHeaderTest.eml) into any TB folder (IMAP or local). - `S/MIME signed message` - `From: != signing address`, which triggers display of `Sender:` header (important) even when... - `mailnews.headers.showSender = false` (important; bug may not happen otherwise) 2. First view other messages *before* viewing the testcase (for comparison). 3. View testcase 1 (in preview pane or in a tab). 4. Then view any unrelated messages in any folder of any account *after* viewing the testcase. **Actual result** - *Before* viewing testcase, all messages will display with correct headers. - *After* viewing testcase, all messages will henceforth display with the stale `Sender:` header of testcase 1. **Expected result** - `Sender:` header must be hidden from message header display for any message which does not have its own `Sender:` header which we need to show; while still respecting `mailnews.headers.showSender` pref (see comment 7 for the current code which seems to attempt just that).
Magnus, you've set this as P1 due to the very exposed wrong UI state (9 duplicates). Now that it's actionable, could you assign someone? I'll add a possible starting point in code in my next comment. Thank you very much Andreas Sch. for this crystal-clear bug report in perfect shape! Let's reopen this one for a clean start to work on bug 1670243, which doesn't have a good description and is currently already at comment 29 due to a worthwhile effort of trying to figure out bit by bit what's going on... Confirmed for Release 78.12.0 (32-bit), Beta 91.0b2 (64-bit), and Daily 91.0b2 (64-bit). - Happens exactly as described after previewing the testcase message of attachment 9191420 [details]. - Obviously highly irritating that TB keeps showing a stale `Sender:` header on any unrelated messages. - Priority P1 set by mkmelin on original bug 1670243, which has 8 more duplicates. **STR** 1. Copy message of minimal testcase 1 (attachment 9191420 [details], sMimeSenderHeaderTest.eml) into any TB folder (IMAP or local). - `S/MIME signed message` - `From: != signing address`, which triggers display of `Sender:` header (important) even when... - `mailnews.headers.showSender = false` (important; bug may not happen otherwise) 2. First view other messages *before* viewing the testcase (for comparison). 3. View testcase 1 (in preview pane or in a tab). 4. Then view any unrelated messages in any folder of any account *after* viewing the testcase. **Actual result** - *Before* viewing testcase, all messages will display with correct headers. - *After* viewing testcase, all messages will henceforth display with the stale `Sender:` header of testcase 1. **Expected result** - `Sender:` header must be hidden from message header display for any message which does not have its own `Sender:` header which we need to show; while still respecting `mailnews.headers.showSender` pref. - See comment 7 for the current code which seems to attempt just that.