Confirming. Crystal ball stuff. After some testing, I can reliably reproduce this on 91.1.2 (64-bit) en-US, Win10 with specific circumstances. For some other scenarios it's wfm. Perhaps not fully reduced yet; I'll include some more details than required in case they might matter. Sending messages without user's consent is quite bad; we should fix this asap -> P2/S2. dkniel, fbausch, thank you for reporting this! Can you state if your steps have been similar, especially regarding the `Select Calendar` prompt after accepting the invite? STR - Create calendar event on local TB `Home` calendar of foo@gmx.de (which happens to be on DE version of 91.1.2, Win10) - add an attendee, attendeexxxxxx@gmail.com (with an email not handled by the same Thunderbird install, to prevent potential artifacts from inviting another flavor of yourself) - Send invite - Recipient's = attendee's Thunderbird must have two calendars (in my case, same associated email): - local `Home` calendar, associated email: attendeexxxxxx@gmail.com - online Google calendar, associated email: attendeexxxxxx@gmail.com - Open attendee's invite message (on attendee's Thunderbird) - Click dropdown arrow next to `Accept | v` (or Decline etc.) - Choose `Do not send a response` (!) --> `Select Calendar` prompt pops up (see screenshot below): "Which Calendar do you want to import these items to?" - Choose the *online* Google calendar (important! surprisingly, bug won't happen for the local `Home` calendar, i.e. if you change nothing in the prompt). Actual - in spite of `Do not send a response`, confirmation email gets sent to organizer anyway (privacy violation) Expected - Respect user's privacy and honor `Do not send a response` by *not* sending a response.
Bug 1733912 Comment 2 Edit History
Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.
Confirming. Crystal ball stuff. After some testing, I can reliably reproduce this on 91.1.2 (64-bit) en-US, Win10 with specific circumstances. For some other scenarios it's wfm. Perhaps not fully reduced yet; I'll include some more details than required in case they might matter. Sending messages without user's consent is quite bad; we should fix this asap -> P2/S2. dkniel, fbausch, thank you for reporting this! Can you state if your steps have been similar, especially regarding the `Select Calendar` prompt after accepting the invite? STR - Create calendar event on local TB `Home` calendar of foo-@-gmx.de (which happens to be on DE version of 91.1.2, Win10) - add an attendee, attendeexxxxxx@gmail.com (with an email not handled by the same Thunderbird install, to prevent potential artifacts from inviting another flavor of yourself) - Send invite - Recipient's = attendee's Thunderbird must have two calendars (in my case, same associated email): - local `Home` calendar, associated email: attendeexxxxxx@gmail.com - online Google calendar, associated email: attendeexxxxxx@gmail.com - Open attendee's invite message (on attendee's Thunderbird) - Click dropdown arrow next to `Accept | v` (or Decline etc.) - Choose `Do not send a response` (!) --> `Select Calendar` prompt pops up (see screenshot below): "Which Calendar do you want to import these items to?" - Choose the *online* Google calendar (important! surprisingly, bug won't happen for the local `Home` calendar, i.e. if you change nothing in the prompt). Actual - in spite of `Do not send a response`, confirmation email gets sent to organizer foo-@-gmx.de anyway (privacy violation) Expected - Respect user's privacy and honor `Do not send a response` by *not* sending a response.
Confirming. Crystal ball stuff. After some testing, I can reliably reproduce this on 91.1.2 (64-bit) en-US, Win10 with specific circumstances. For some other scenarios it's wfm. Perhaps not fully reduced yet; I'll include some more details than required in case they might matter. Sending messages without user's consent is quite bad; we should fix this asap -> P2/S2. dkniel, fbausch, thank you for reporting this! Can you state if your steps have been similar, especially regarding the `Select Calendar` prompt after accepting the invite? **STR** *Organizer* - Create calendar event on local TB `Home` calendar of foo-@-gmx.de (which happens to be on DE version of 91.1.2, Win10) - add an attendee, attendeexxxxxx@gmail.com (with an email not handled by the same Thunderbird install, to prevent potential artifacts from inviting another flavor of yourself) - Send invite --- *Attendee* - Recipient's = attendee's Thunderbird must have two calendars (in my case, same associated email): - local `Home` calendar, associated email: attendeexxxxxx@gmail.com - online Google calendar, associated email: attendeexxxxxx@gmail.com - Open attendee's invite message (on attendee's Thunderbird) - Click dropdown arrow next to `Accept | v` (or Decline etc.) - Choose `Do not send a response` (!) --> `Select Calendar` prompt pops up (see screenshot below): "Which Calendar do you want to import these items to?" - Choose the *online* Google calendar (important! surprisingly, bug won't happen for the local `Home` calendar, i.e. if you change nothing in the prompt). **Actual** - in spite of `Do not send a response`, confirmation email gets sent to organizer foo-@-gmx.de anyway (privacy violation) **Expected** - Respect user's privacy and honor `Do not send a response` by *not* sending a response.
Confirming. Crystal ball stuff. After some testing, I can reliably reproduce this on 91.1.2 (64-bit) en-US, Win10 with specific circumstances. For some other scenarios it's wfm. Perhaps not fully reduced yet; I'll include some more details than required in case they might matter. Sending messages without user's consent is quite bad; we should fix this asap -> P2/S2. dkniel, fbausch, thank you for reporting this! Can you state if your steps have been similar, especially regarding the `Select Calendar` prompt after accepting the invite? **STR** To reproduce this, you should have two installations of TB 91.1.2 in different folders with different profiles and different email addresses. *Organizer* - Create calendar event on local TB `Home` calendar of foo-@-gmx.de (which happens to be on DE version of 91.1.2, Win10) - add an attendee, attendeexxxxxx@gmail.com (with an email not handled by the same Thunderbird install, to prevent potential artifacts from inviting another flavor of yourself) - Send invite --- *Attendee* - Recipient's = attendee's Thunderbird must have two calendars (in my case, same associated email): - local `Home` calendar, associated email: attendeexxxxxx@gmail.com - online Google calendar, associated email: attendeexxxxxx@gmail.com - Open attendee's invite message (on attendee's Thunderbird) - Click dropdown arrow next to `Accept | v` (or Decline etc.) - Choose `Do not send a response` (!) --> `Select Calendar` prompt pops up (see screenshot below): "Which Calendar do you want to import these items to?" - Choose the *online* Google calendar (important! surprisingly, bug won't happen for the local `Home` calendar, i.e. if you change nothing in the prompt). **Actual** - in spite of `Do not send a response`, confirmation email gets sent to organizer foo-@-gmx.de anyway (privacy violation) **Expected** - Respect user's privacy and honor `Do not send a response` by *not* sending a response.
Confirming. Crystal ball stuff. After some testing, I can reliably reproduce this on 91.1.2 (64-bit) en-US, Win10 with specific circumstances. For some other scenarios it's wfm. Perhaps not fully reduced yet; I'll include some more details than required in case they might matter. Sending messages without user's consent is quite bad; we should fix this asap -> P2/S2. dkniel, fbausch, thank you for reporting this! Can you state if your steps have been similar, especially regarding the `Select Calendar` prompt after accepting the invite? **STR** To reproduce this, you should have two installations of TB 91.1.2 in different folders with different profiles and different email addresses. *Organizer* - Create calendar event on local TB `Home` calendar of foo-@-gmx.de (which happens to be on DE version of 91.1.2, Win10) - add an attendee, attendeexxxxxx@gmail.com (with an email not handled by the same Thunderbird install, to prevent potential artifacts from inviting another flavor of yourself) - Send invite --- *Attendee* - Recipient's = attendee's Thunderbird must have two calendars (in my case, same associated email): - local `Home` calendar, associated email: attendeexxxxxx@gmail.com - online Google calendar, associated email: attendeexxxxxx@gmail.com - Open attendee's invite message (on attendee's Thunderbird) - Click **dropdown arrow** next to `Accept | v` (or Decline etc.) - Choose `Do not send a response` (!) --> `Select Calendar` prompt pops up (see screenshot below): "Which Calendar do you want to import these items to?" - Choose the *online* Google calendar (important! surprisingly, bug won't happen for the local `Home` calendar, i.e. if you change nothing in the prompt). **Actual** - in spite of `Do not send a response`, confirmation email gets sent to organizer foo-@-gmx.de anyway (privacy violation) **Expected** - Respect user's privacy and honor `Do not send a response` by *not* sending a response.