Bug 1752013 Comment 0 Edit History

Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.

Seen on 98.0a1 (2022-01-25) (64-bit), Win10

New AB has lost all high efficiency keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact.
- `Enter` (all OS) for default action of selected item, edit contact.
- `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) and `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) - per-OS default shortcuts to edit the properties of a selected item.

Even double-click no longer triggers the default action, edit contact.
This is a usability regression.

Editing contacts now requires much more effort and attention: 
- mouse: less convenient, needless mouse click on distant `Edit` button
- keyboard: (1x or 2x) `Tab`, `Enter`. Note: 2x Tab is required when reduced window width causes horizontal scroll bar on contact pane.

Worse, `Ctrl/Cmd+I` unexpectedly triggers `New Calendar Event`, which looks like a pretty unlikely workflow.

**STR:**
1. Open ("new") Address Book
2. Click to select contact A
3. Press keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact:
  - `Enter` (all OS)
  - `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) or
  - `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS)

**Actual results:**
- nothing for `Enter` (all OS)
- nothing for `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux)
- `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) triggers `New Event` dialog
- nothing for double-click on contact

**Expected results:**
- Restore plain vanilla `Enter` shortcut for the selected item default action, edit contact.
- Restore plain vanilla `double-click` to edit contact.
- Restore convenience shortcuts for consistency with OS default shortcuts on the respective OS to edit the properties of an item (which imo prohibits using Alt+Enter and Ctrl/Cmd+I for anything else here even if we wanted).
Seen on 98.0a1 (2022-01-25) (64-bit), Win10

New AB has lost all high efficiency keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact.
Even double-click no longer triggers the default action, edit contact.
This is an annoying usability regression, more so for the blind.

- Double-click on a contact for default action (edit contact).
- `Enter` (all OS) for default action of selected item (edit contact).
- `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) and `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) - per-OS default shortcuts to edit the properties of a selected item.

Editing contacts now requires much more effort and attention: 
- mouse: less convenient, needless mouse click on distant `Edit` button
- keyboard: (1x or 2x) `Tab`, `Enter`. Note: 2x Tab is required when reduced window width causes horizontal scroll bar on contact pane.

Worse, `Ctrl/Cmd+I` unexpectedly triggers `New Calendar Event`, which looks like a pretty unlikely workflow.

**STR:**
1. Open ("new") Address Book
2. Click to select contact A
3. Press keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact:
  - `Enter` (all OS)
  - `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) or
  - `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS)

**Actual results:**
- nothing for `Enter` (all OS)
- nothing for `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux)
- `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) triggers `New Event` dialog
- nothing for double-click on contact

**Expected results:**
- Restore plain vanilla `Enter` shortcut for the selected item default action, edit contact.
- Restore plain vanilla `double-click` to edit contact.
- Restore convenience shortcuts for consistency with OS default shortcuts on the respective OS to edit the properties of an item (which imo prohibits using Alt+Enter and Ctrl/Cmd+I for anything else here even if we wanted).
Seen on 98.0a1 (2022-01-25) (64-bit), Win10

New AB has lost all high efficiency keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact (default action).
Even double-click no longer triggers the default action (edit contact).
This is an annoying usability regression, more so for the blind.

- Double-click on a contact for default action (edit contact).
- `Enter` (all OS) for default action of selected item (edit contact).
- `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) and `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) - per-OS default shortcuts to edit the properties of a selected item.

Editing contacts now requires much more effort and attention: 
- mouse: less convenient, needless mouse click on distant `Edit` button
- keyboard: (1x or 2x) `Tab`, `Enter`. Note: 2x Tab is required when reduced window width causes horizontal scroll bar on contact pane.

Worse, `Ctrl/Cmd+I` unexpectedly triggers `New Calendar Event`, which looks like a pretty unlikely workflow.

**STR:**
1. Open ("new") Address Book
2. Click to select contact A
3. Press keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact:
  - `Enter` (all OS)
  - `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) or
  - `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS)

**Actual results:**
- nothing for `Enter` (all OS)
- nothing for `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux)
- `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) triggers `New Event` dialog
- nothing for double-click on contact

**Expected results:**
- Restore plain vanilla `Enter` shortcut for the selected item default action, edit contact.
- Restore plain vanilla `double-click` to edit contact.
- Restore convenience shortcuts for consistency with OS default shortcuts on the respective OS to edit the properties of an item (which imo prohibits using Alt+Enter and Ctrl/Cmd+I for anything else here even if we wanted).
Seen on 98.0a1 (2022-01-25) (64-bit), Win10

New AB has lost all high efficiency keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact (default action).
Even double-click no longer triggers the default action (edit contact).
This is an annoying usability regression, more so for the blind.

- Double-click on a contact for default action (edit contact).
- `Enter` (all OS) for default action of selected item (edit contact).
- `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) and `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) - per-OS default shortcuts to edit the properties of a selected item.

**Editing contacts now requires much more effort and attention: **
- mouse: less convenient, needless mouse click on distant `Edit` button
- keyboard: (4x or 5x) `Tab`, `Enter`. Note: 5x Tab is required when reduced window width causes horizontal scroll bar on contact pane.

Worse, `Ctrl/Cmd+I` unexpectedly triggers `New Calendar Event`, which looks like a pretty unlikely workflow.

**STR:**
1. Open ("new") Address Book
2. Click to select contact A
3. Press keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact:
  - `Enter` (all OS)
  - `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) or
  - `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS)

**Actual results:**
- nothing for `Enter` (all OS)
- nothing for `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux)
- `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) triggers `New Event` dialog
- nothing for double-click on contact

**Expected results:**
- Restore plain vanilla `Enter` shortcut for the selected item default action, edit contact.
- Restore plain vanilla `double-click` to edit contact.
- Restore convenience shortcuts for consistency with OS default shortcuts on the respective OS to edit the properties of an item (which imo prohibits using Alt+Enter and Ctrl/Cmd+I for anything else here even if we wanted).
Seen on 98.0a1 (2022-01-25) (64-bit), Win10

New AB has lost all high efficiency keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact (default action).
Even double-click no longer triggers the default action (edit contact).
This is an annoying usability regression, more so for the blind.

- Double-click on a contact for default action (edit contact).
- `Enter` (all OS) for default action of selected item (edit contact).
- `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) and `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) - per-OS default shortcuts to edit the properties of a selected item.

**Editing contacts now requires much more effort and attention:**
- mouse: less convenient, needless mouse click on distant `Edit` button
- keyboard: (4x or 5x) `Tab`, `Enter`. Note: 5x Tab is required when reduced window width causes horizontal scroll bar on contact pane.

Worse, `Ctrl/Cmd+I` unexpectedly triggers `New Calendar Event`, which looks like a pretty unlikely workflow.

**STR:**
1. Open ("new") Address Book
2. Click to select contact A
3. Press keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact:
  - `Enter` (all OS)
  - `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) or
  - `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS)

**Actual results:**
- nothing for `Enter` (all OS)
- nothing for `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux)
- `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) triggers `New Event` dialog
- nothing for double-click on contact

**Expected results:**
- Restore plain vanilla `Enter` shortcut for the selected item default action, edit contact.
- Restore plain vanilla `double-click` to edit contact.
- Restore convenience shortcuts for consistency with OS default shortcuts on the respective OS to edit the properties of an item (which imo prohibits using Alt+Enter and Ctrl/Cmd+I for anything else here even if we wanted).
Seen on 98.0a1 (2022-01-25) (64-bit), Win10

New AB has lost all high efficiency keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact (default action), especially plain `Enter`.
Even double-click no longer triggers the default action (edit contact).
**This is an annoying usability regression, more so for the blind.**

- Double-click on a contact for default action (edit contact).
- `Enter` (all OS) for default action of selected item (edit contact).
- `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) and `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) - per-OS default shortcuts to edit the properties of a selected item.

**Editing contacts now requires much more effort and attention:**
- mouse: less convenient, needless mouse click on distant `Edit` button
- keyboard: (4x or 5x) `Tab`, `Enter`. Note: 5x Tab is required when reduced window width causes horizontal scroll bar on contact pane.

Worse, `Ctrl/Cmd+I` unexpectedly triggers `New Calendar Event`, which looks like a pretty unlikely workflow.

**STR:**
1. Open ("new") Address Book
2. Click to select contact A
3. Press keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact:
  - `Enter` (all OS)
  - `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) or
  - `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS)

**Actual results:**
- nothing for `Enter` (all OS)
- nothing for `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux)
- `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) triggers `New Event` dialog
- nothing for double-click on contact

**Expected results:**
- Restore plain vanilla `Enter` shortcut for the selected item default action, edit contact.
- Restore plain vanilla `double-click` to edit contact.
- Restore convenience shortcuts for consistency with OS default shortcuts on the respective OS to edit the properties of an item (which imo prohibits using Alt+Enter and Ctrl/Cmd+I for anything else here even if we wanted).
Seen on 98.0a1 (2022-01-25) (64-bit), Win10

New AB has lost all high efficiency keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact (default action), especially plain `Enter`.
Even double-click no longer triggers the default action (edit contact).
**This is an annoying usability regression, more so for the blind.**

- Double-click on a contact for default action (edit contact).
- `Enter` (all OS) for default action of selected item (edit contact).
- `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) and `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) - per-OS default shortcuts to edit the properties of a selected item.

**Editing contacts now requires much more effort and attention:**
- mouse: less convenient, needless mouse click on distant `Edit` button
- keyboard: (4x or 5x) `Tab`, `Enter`. Note: 5x Tab is required when reduced window width causes horizontal scroll bar on contact pane.

Worse, `Ctrl/Cmd+I` unexpectedly triggers `New Calendar Event`, which looks like a pretty unlikely workflow.

**STR:**
1. Open ("new") Address Book
2. Click to select contact A
3. Press keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact:
  - `Enter` or double-click (all OS)
  - `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) or
  - `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS)

**Actual results:**
- nothing for `Enter` or double-click (all OS)
- nothing for `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux)
- `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) triggers `New Event` dialog

**Expected results:**
- Restore plain vanilla `Enter` shortcut for the selected item default action, edit contact.
- Restore plain vanilla `double-click` to edit contact.
- Restore convenience shortcuts for consistency with OS default shortcuts on the respective OS to edit the properties of an item (which imo prohibits using Alt+Enter and Ctrl/Cmd+I for anything else here even if we wanted).
Seen on 98.0a1 (2022-01-25) (64-bit), Win10

New AB has lost all high efficiency keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact (default action), especially plain `Enter`.
Even double-click no longer triggers the default action (edit contact).
**This is an annoying usability regression, more so for the blind.**

- Double-click on a contact for default action (edit contact).
- `Enter` (all OS) for default action of selected item (edit contact).
- `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) and `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) - per-OS default shortcuts to edit the properties of a selected item.

**Editing contacts now requires much more effort and attention:**
- mouse: less convenient, needless mouse click on distant `Edit` button
- keyboard: (4x or 5x) `Tab`, `Enter`. Note: 5x Tab is required when reduced window width causes horizontal scroll bar on contact pane.

Worse, `Ctrl/Cmd+I` unexpectedly triggers `New Calendar Event`, which looks like a pretty unlikely workflow.

**STR:**
1. Open ("new") Address Book
2. Click to select contact A
3. Press keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact:
  - `Enter` or double-click (all OS)
  - `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) or
  - `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS)

**Actual results:**
- nothing for `Enter` or double-click on a contact (all OS)
- nothing for `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux)
- `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) triggers `New Event` dialog

**Expected results:**
- Restore plain vanilla `Enter` shortcut for the selected item default action, edit contact.
- Restore plain vanilla `double-click` to edit contact.
- Restore convenience shortcuts for consistency with OS default shortcuts on the respective OS to edit the properties of an item (which imo prohibits using Alt+Enter and Ctrl/Cmd+I for anything else here even if we wanted).
Seen on 98.0a1 (2022-01-25) (64-bit), Win10

New AB has lost all high efficiency keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact (default action), especially plain `Enter`.
Even double-click no longer triggers the default action (edit contact).
**This is an annoying usability regression, more so for the blind.**

- `Double-click` on a contact for default action (edit contact).
- `Enter` (all OS) for default action of selected item (edit contact).
- `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) and `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) - per-OS default shortcuts to edit the properties of a selected item.

**Editing contacts now requires much more effort and attention:**
- mouse: less convenient, needless mouse click on distant `Edit` button
- keyboard: (4x or 5x) `Tab`, `Enter`. Note: 5x Tab is required when reduced window width causes horizontal scroll bar on contact pane.

Worse, `Ctrl/Cmd+I` unexpectedly triggers `New Calendar Event`, which looks like a pretty unlikely workflow.

**STR:**
1. Open ("new") Address Book
2. Click to select contact A
3. Press keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact:
  - `Enter` or double-click (all OS)
  - `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) or
  - `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS)

**Actual results:**
- nothing for `Enter` or double-click on a contact (all OS)
- nothing for `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux)
- `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) triggers `New Event` dialog

**Expected results:**
- Restore plain vanilla `Enter` shortcut for the selected item default action, edit contact.
- Restore plain vanilla `double-click` to edit contact.
- Restore convenience shortcuts for consistency with OS default shortcuts on the respective OS to edit the properties of an item (which imo prohibits using Alt+Enter and Ctrl/Cmd+I for anything else here even if we wanted).
**Regression** seen on 98.0a1 (2022-01-25) (64-bit), Win10

New AB has lost all high efficiency keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact (default action), especially plain `Enter`.
Even double-click no longer triggers the default action (edit contact).
**This is an annoying usability regression, more so for the blind.**

- `Double-click` on a contact for default action (edit contact).
- `Enter` (all OS) for default action of selected item (edit contact).
- `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) and `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) - per-OS default shortcuts to edit the properties of a selected item.

**Editing contacts now requires much more effort and attention:**
- mouse: less convenient, needless mouse click on distant `Edit` button
- keyboard: (4x or 5x) `Tab`, `Enter`. Note: 5x Tab is required when reduced window width causes horizontal scroll bar on contact pane.

Worse, `Ctrl/Cmd+I` unexpectedly triggers `New Calendar Event`, which looks like a pretty unlikely workflow.

**STR:**
1. Open ("new") Address Book
2. Click to select contact A
3. Press keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact:
  - `Enter` or double-click (all OS)
  - `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) or
  - `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS)

**Actual results:**
- nothing for `Enter` or double-click on a contact (all OS)
- nothing for `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux)
- `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) triggers `New Event` dialog

**Expected results:**
- Restore plain vanilla `Enter` shortcut for the selected item default action, edit contact.
- Restore plain vanilla `double-click` to edit contact.
- Restore convenience shortcuts for consistency with OS default shortcuts on the respective OS to edit the properties of an item (which imo prohibits using Alt+Enter and Ctrl/Cmd+I for anything else here even if we wanted).
**Regression** seen on 98.0a1 (2022-01-25) (64-bit), Win10

New AB has lost all high efficiency keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact (default action), especially plain `Enter`.
Even double-click no longer triggers the default action (edit contact).
**This is an annoying usability regression, more so for the blind.**

- `Double-click` on a contact for default action (edit contact).
- `Enter` (all OS) for default action of selected item (edit contact).
- `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) and `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) - per-OS default shortcuts to edit the properties of a selected item.

**Editing contacts now requires much more effort and attention:**
- mouse: less convenient, needless mouse click on distant `Edit` button
- keyboard: (4x or 5x) `Tab`, `Enter`. Note: 5x Tab is required when reduced window width causes horizontal scroll bar on contact pane.

Worse, `Ctrl/Cmd+I` unexpectedly triggers `New Calendar Event`, which looks like a pretty unlikely workflow.

**STR:**
1. Open ("new") Address Book
2. Click to select contact A
3. Press keyboard shortcuts to edit the selected contact:
  - `Enter` or double-click (all OS)
  - `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux) or
  - `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS)

**Actual results:**
- nothing for `Enter` or double-click on a contact (all OS)
- nothing for `Alt+Enter` (Windows/Linux)
- `Ctrl/Cmd+I` (all OS) triggers `New Event` dialog

**Expected results:**
- Restore plain vanilla `Enter` shortcut for the selected item default action, edit contact.
- Restore plain vanilla `double-click` to edit contact.
- Restore convenience shortcuts for consistency with OS default shortcuts on the respective OS to edit the properties of an item (which imo prohibits using Alt+Enter and Ctrl/Cmd+I for anything else here even if we wanted). That said, we may want to reflect a bit more on the new conflict with Ctrl/Cmd+I for creating a new calendar event, so OK to delay restoring Ctrl/Cmd+I.

Back to Bug 1752013 Comment 0