Bug 1757219 Comment 0 Edit History

Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.

Original comment by
on 
**User Story**
As a user who set OS-level text size or display scaling larger than the default, I want my choice to be respected in the PiP window captions. 


**Acceptance Criteria**
**Windows**
1. PiP captions inherit the min font size set in Settings > Accessibility > Text size.

**macOS**
2. We'll need to investigate whether we can do the following: 
PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Display - Scaled Resolution - Larger Text. 

PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Accessibility - Captions - Large Text. 

**Linux**
3. PiP captions inherit the font size set in Activities - Accessibility - Seeing - Large Text. 

*Scaling**
4. PiP window caption uses the user OS setting as minimum font size and follows the [same scaling guidelines on PiP window resizing](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1S7P9gsCwX1CB0C846Hm0k5X3IQDlSjzojeCSXCMndeU/edit#).
Revision 1 by
on 
**User Story**
As a user who set OS-level text size or display scaling larger than the default, I want my choice to be respected in the PiP window captions. 


**Acceptance Criteria**
**Windows**

1. PiP captions inherit the min font size set in Settings > Accessibility > Text size.

**macOS**
2. We'll need to investigate whether we can do the following: 
PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Display - Scaled Resolution - Larger Text. 

PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Accessibility - Captions - Large Text. 

**Linux**
3. PiP captions inherit the font size set in Activities - Accessibility - Seeing - Large Text. 

*Scaling**
4. PiP window caption uses the user OS setting as minimum font size and follows the [same scaling guidelines on PiP window resizing](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1S7P9gsCwX1CB0C846Hm0k5X3IQDlSjzojeCSXCMndeU/edit#).
Revision 2 by
on 
**User Story**
As a user who set OS-level text size or display scaling larger than the default, I want my choice to be respected in the PiP window captions. 


**Acceptance Criteria**

**Windows**

1. PiP captions inherit the min font size set in Settings > Accessibility > Text size.

**macOS**
2. We'll need to investigate whether we can do the following: 
PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Display - Scaled Resolution - Larger Text. 

PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Accessibility - Captions - Large Text. 

**Linux**
3. PiP captions inherit the font size set in Activities - Accessibility - Seeing - Large Text. 

*Scaling**
4. PiP window caption uses the user OS setting as minimum font size and follows the [same scaling guidelines on PiP window resizing](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1S7P9gsCwX1CB0C846Hm0k5X3IQDlSjzojeCSXCMndeU/edit#).
Revision 3 by
on 
**User Story**
As a user who set OS-level text size or display scaling larger than the default, I want my choice to be respected in the PiP window captions. 


**Acceptance Criteria**

**Windows**

1. PiP captions inherit the min font size set in Settings > Accessibility > Text size.

**macOS**
2. We'll need to investigate whether we can do the following: 
PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Display - Scaled Resolution - Larger Text. 

PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Accessibility - Captions - Large Text. 

**Linux**
3. PiP captions inherit the font size set in Activities - Accessibility - Seeing - Large Text. 

**Scaling**
4. PiP window caption uses the user OS setting as minimum font size and follows the [same scaling guidelines on PiP window resizing](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1S7P9gsCwX1CB0C846Hm0k5X3IQDlSjzojeCSXCMndeU/edit#).
Revision 4 by
on 
**User Story**
As a user who set OS-level text size or display scaling larger than the default, I want my choice to be respected in the PiP window captions. 


**Acceptance Criteria**

**Windows**

1. PiP captions inherit the min font size set in Settings > Accessibility > Text size.

**macOS**
1. We'll need to investigate whether we can do the following: 
PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Display - Scaled Resolution - Larger Text. 

2. PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Accessibility - Captions - Large Text. 

**Linux**
3. PiP captions inherit the font size set in Activities - Accessibility - Seeing - Large Text. 

**Scaling**
4. PiP window caption uses the user OS setting as minimum font size and follows the [same scaling guidelines on PiP window resizing](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1S7P9gsCwX1CB0C846Hm0k5X3IQDlSjzojeCSXCMndeU/edit#).
Revision 5 by
on 
**User Story**
As a user who sets OS-level larger text size or display scaling larger than the default, I want my choice to be respected in the PiP window captions. 


**Acceptance Criteria**

**Windows**

1. PiP captions inherit the size set in Settings > Accessibility > Text size as a min font size.
We decided to do this even though we normally only respect this setting for UI. 

2. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger scale in Settings - Display - Scale and Layout - Scale. 
This already works in Nightly 99 on Win 10.

**macOS**
1. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger scale in System Preferences - Display - Scaled Resolution - Large (r) Text. 

This already works in Nightly 99 on macOS 11.6.

2. PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Accessibility - Captions - Large Text. 

**Linux**
1. PiP captions inherit the font size set in Activities - Accessibility - Seeing - Large Text. 

2. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger scale in

**Behavior on PiP window resizing**
4. PiP window caption uses the user OS setting as minimum font size and follows the [same scaling guidelines on PiP window resizing](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1S7P9gsCwX1CB0C846Hm0k5X3IQDlSjzojeCSXCMndeU/edit#).
Revision 6 by
on 
**User Story**
As a user who sets OS-level larger text size or display scaling larger than the default, I want my choice to be respected in the PiP window captions size. 


**Acceptance Criteria**

**Windows**

1. PiP captions inherit the size set in Settings > Accessibility > Text size as a min font size.
We decided to do this even though we normally only respect this setting for UI. 

2. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger scale in Settings - Display - Scale and Layout - Scale. 
This already works in Nightly 99 on Win 10.

**macOS**
1. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger scale in System Preferences - Display - Scaled Resolution - Large (r) Text. 

This already works in Nightly 99 on macOS 11.6.

2. PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Accessibility - Captions - Large Text. 

**Linux**
1. PiP captions inherit the font size set in Activities - Accessibility - Seeing - Large Text. 

2. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger display/resolutions scale in GUI settings. 

**Behavior on PiP window resizing**
4. PiP window caption uses the user OS setting as minimum font size and follows the [same scaling guidelines on PiP window resizing](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1S7P9gsCwX1CB0C846Hm0k5X3IQDlSjzojeCSXCMndeU/edit#).
Revision 7 by
on 
**User Story**
As a user who sets OS-level larger text size or display scaling larger than the default, I want my choice to be respected in the PiP window captions size. 


**Acceptance Criteria**

**Windows**

1. PiP captions inherit the size set in Settings > Accessibility > Text size as a min font size.
We decided to do this even though we normally only respect this setting for UI. 

2. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger scale in Settings - Display - Scale and Layout - Scale. 
This already works in Nightly 99 on Win 10.

**macOS**
1. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger scale in System Preferences - Display - Scaled Resolution - Large (r) Text. 

This already works in Nightly 99 on macOS 11.6.

2. PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Accessibility - Captions - Large Text. 

**Linux**
1. PiP captions inherit the font size set in Activities - Accessibility - Seeing - Large Text. 

2. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger display/resolutions scale in GUI settings. 

**Behavior on PiP window resizing**
1. PiP window caption uses the user OS setting as minimum font size and follows the [same scaling guidelines on PiP window resizing](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1S7P9gsCwX1CB0C846Hm0k5X3IQDlSjzojeCSXCMndeU/edit#).
Revision 8 by
on 
**User Story 1**
As a user who sets OS-level larger text size or display scaling larger than the default, I want my choice to be respected in the PiP window captions size. 


**Acceptance Criteria**

**Windows**

1. PiP captions inherit the size set in Settings > Accessibility > Text size as a min font size.
We decided to do this even though we normally only respect this setting for UI. 

In this scenario, about:config setting for subtitles font size defaults to "large". 

2. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger scale in Settings - Display - Scale and Layout - Scale. 
This already works in Nightly 99 on Win 10.

**macOS**
1. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger scale in System Preferences - Display - Scaled Resolution - Large (r) Text. 

This already works in Nightly 99 on macOS 11.6.

**Linux**
1. PiP captions inherit the font size set in Activities - Accessibility - Seeing - Large Text. 

2. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger display/resolutions scale in GUI settings. 

**Behavior on PiP window resizing**
1. PiP window caption uses the user OS setting as minimum font size and follows the [same scaling guidelines on PiP window resizing](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1S7P9gsCwX1CB0C846Hm0k5X3IQDlSjzojeCSXCMndeU/edit#).

**User Story 2**
As user, who wants to customize their font size in PiP, I want to be able to switch between "small", "medium", and "large" values in about:config pref.

**Acceptance Criteria**
1. media.videocontrols.picture-in-picture.display-text-tracks.font-size allows for three values: "small", "medium", and "large".
2. This pref defaults to medium in all use cases aside from when OS-level settings are set to a large font option. 


We will not support these cases for now: 
macOS: PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Accessibility - Captions - Large Text.
Revision 9 by
on 
**User Story 1**
As a user who sets OS-level larger text size or display scaling larger than the default, I want my choice to be respected in the PiP window captions size. 


**Acceptance Criteria**

**Windows**

1. PiP captions inherit the size set in Settings > Accessibility > Text size as a min font size.
We decided to do this even though we normally only respect this setting for UI. 

In this scenario, about:config setting for subtitles font size defaults to "large". 

2. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger scale in Settings - Display - Scale and Layout - Scale. 
This already works in Nightly 99 on Win 10.

**macOS**
1. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger scale in System Preferences - Display - Scaled Resolution - Large (r) Text. 

This already works in Nightly 99 on macOS 11.6.

**Linux**
1. PiP captions inherit the font size set in Activities - Accessibility - Seeing - Large Text. 

2. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger display/resolutions scale in GUI settings. 

**Behavior on PiP window resizing**
1. PiP window caption uses the user OS setting as minimum font size and follows the [same scaling guidelines on PiP window resizing](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1S7P9gsCwX1CB0C846Hm0k5X3IQDlSjzojeCSXCMndeU/edit#).

**User Story 2**
As user, who wants to customize their font size in PiP, I want to be able to switch between "small", "medium", and "large" values.

**Acceptance Criteria**
1. media.videocontrols.picture-in-picture.display-text-tracks.font-size allows for three values: "small", "medium", and "large".
2. This pref defaults to medium in all use cases aside from when OS-level settings are set to a large font option. 


We will not support these cases for now: 
macOS: PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Accessibility - Captions - Large Text.
Revision 10 by
on 
**User Story 1**
As a user who sets OS-level larger text size or display scaling larger than the default, I want my choice to be respected in the PiP window captions size. 


**Acceptance Criteria**

**Windows**

2. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger scale in Settings - Display - Scale and Layout - Scale. 
This already works in Nightly 99 on Win 10.

**macOS**
1. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger scale in System Preferences - Display - Scaled Resolution - Large (r) Text. 

This already works in Nightly 99 on macOS 11.6.

**Linux**
1. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger display/resolutions scale in GUI settings. 

**Behavior on PiP window resizing**
1. PiP window caption uses the user OS setting as minimum font size and follows the [same scaling guidelines on PiP window resizing](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1S7P9gsCwX1CB0C846Hm0k5X3IQDlSjzojeCSXCMndeU/edit#).

**User Story 2**
As user, who wants to change their font size in PiP, I want to be able to switch between "small", "medium", and "large" values.

**Acceptance Criteria**
1. media.videocontrols.picture-in-picture.display-text-tracks.font-size allows for three values: "small", "medium", and "large".
2. This pref defaults to medium in all use cases aside from when OS-level settings are set to a large font option. 


Not doing: 
macOS: PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Accessibility - Captions - Large Text.

**Windows**
1. PiP captions inherit the size set in Settings > Accessibility > Text size as a min font size.
We decided to do this even though we normally only respect this setting for UI. 

In this scenario, about:config setting for subtitles font size defaults to "large". 

**Linux**
1. PiP captions inherit the font size set in Activities - Accessibility - Seeing - Large Text.
Revision 11 by
on 
**User Story 1**
As a user who sets display scaling larger than the default, I want my choice to be respected in the PiP window captions size. 

**Acceptance Criteria**

**Windows**

1. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger scale in Settings - Display - Scale and Layout - Scale. 
This already works in Nightly 99 on Win 10.

**macOS**
1. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger scale in System Preferences - Display - Scaled Resolution - Large (r) Text. 

This already works in Nightly 99 on macOS 11.6.

**Linux**
1. PiP captions size is adjusted if a user chooses a larger display/resolutions scale in GUI settings. 

**Behavior on PiP window resizing**
1. PiP window caption uses the user OS setting as minimum font size and follows the [same scaling guidelines on PiP window resizing](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1S7P9gsCwX1CB0C846Hm0k5X3IQDlSjzojeCSXCMndeU/edit#).

**User Story 2**
As user, who wants to change their font size in PiP, I want to be able to switch between "small", "medium", and "large" values.

**Acceptance Criteria**
1. media.videocontrols.picture-in-picture.display-text-tracks.font-size allows for three values: "small", "medium", and "large".
2. This pref defaults to medium in all use cases aside from when OS-level settings are set to a large font option. 


**Not doing:**
**macOS**
PiP captions inherit the font size set in System Preferences - Accessibility - Captions - Large Text.

**Windows**
1. PiP captions inherit the size set in Settings > Accessibility > Text size as a min font size.
We decided to do this even though we normally only respect this setting for UI. 

In this scenario, about:config setting for subtitles font size defaults to "large". 

**Linux**
1. PiP captions inherit the font size set in Activities - Accessibility - Seeing - Large Text.

Back to Bug 1757219 Comment 0