Bug 1783460 Comment 5 Edit History

Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.

Thank you for your answer!

> the QuickActions are always the 2nd result, not the first. If you type in a website repeatedly then that should always come up as the first result.

Unfortunately not (really). The first line is always a domain autocompletion that would bring me to the home page of a domain. But often I am not interested in the home pages. So I have to press the arrow down button to get the first history result. And with the quick action buttons the first history suggestion is below the quick action buttons.

Example:

I visit https://www.transfermarkt.de/hertha-bsc/news/verein/44 a few times per day. It's the first history suggestion for me if I enter "t". Without quick action buttons I have to press the arrow down key one time. With quick action buttons I have to press the arrow down key three times because there is the "manage themes" quick action as well as the "?" button with the SUMO link. So instead of three actions ("t", arrow down, Enter) I have to execute five actions ("t", arrow down, arrow down, arrow down, Enter).

> Another hope is that since quickactions are quite strongly filtered, the user needs to be typing something quite specific for them to keep appearing

At the moment that's not the case. The quick action buttons already appear after one (!) typed letter, so I see the quick action buttons very often.
Thank you for your answer!

> the QuickActions are always the 2nd result, not the first. If you type in a website repeatedly then that should always come up as the first result.

Unfortunately not (really). The first line is always a domain autocompletion that would bring me to the home page of a domain. But often I am not interested in the home pages. So I have to press the arrow down button to get the first history result. And with the quick action buttons the first history suggestion is below the quick action buttons.

Example:

I visit https://www.transfermarkt.de/hertha-bsc/news/verein/44 a few times per day. It's the first history suggestion for me if I enter "t". Without quick action buttons I have to press the arrow down key one time. With quick action buttons I have to press the arrow down key three times because there is the "manage themes" quick action as well as the "?" button with the SUMO link. So instead of three actions ("t", arrow down, Enter) I have to execute five actions ("t", arrow down, arrow down, arrow down, Enter) every time I want to open this page.

> Another hope is that since quickactions are quite strongly filtered, the user needs to be typing something quite specific for them to keep appearing

At the moment that's not the case. The quick action buttons already appear after one (!) typed letter, so I see the quick action buttons very often.
Thank you for your answer!

> the QuickActions are always the 2nd result, not the first. If you type in a website repeatedly then that should always come up as the first result.

Unfortunately not (really). The first line is always a domain autocompletion that would bring me to the home page of a domain. But often I am not interested in the home pages. So I have to press the arrow down button to get the first history result. And with the quick action buttons the first history suggestion is below the quick action buttons.

Example:

I visit https://www.transfermarkt.de/hertha-bsc/news/verein/44 a few times per day. It's the first history suggestion for me if I enter "t". Without quick action buttons I have to press the arrow down key one time. With quick action buttons I have to press the arrow down key three times because there is the "manage themes" quick action as well as the "?" button with the SUMO link. So instead of three actions ("t", arrow down, Enter) I have to execute five actions ("t", arrow down, arrow down, arrow down, Enter) every time I want to open this page.

> Another hope is that since quickactions are quite strongly filtered, the user needs to be typing something quite specific for them to keep appearing

At the moment that's not the case. The quick action buttons already appear after one (!) typed letter, so they interfere very noticeable with my regular browsing habits.
Thank you for your answer!

> the QuickActions are always the 2nd result, not the first. If you type in a website repeatedly then that should always come up as the first result.

Unfortunately not (really). The first line is always a domain autocompletion that would bring me to the home page of a domain. But often I am not interested in the home pages. So I have to press the arrow down button to get the first history result. And with the quick action buttons the first history suggestion is _below_ the quick action buttons.

Example:

I visit https://www.transfermarkt.de/hertha-bsc/news/verein/44 a few times per day. It's the first history suggestion for me if I enter "t". Without quick action buttons I have to press the arrow down key one time. With quick action buttons I have to press the arrow down key three times because there is the "manage themes" quick action as well as the "?" button with the SUMO link. So instead of three actions ("t", arrow down, Enter) I have to execute five actions ("t", arrow down, arrow down, arrow down, Enter) every time I want to open this page.

> Another hope is that since quickactions are quite strongly filtered, the user needs to be typing something quite specific for them to keep appearing

At the moment that's not the case. The quick action buttons already appear after one (!) typed letter, so they interfere very noticeable with my regular browsing habits.
Thank you for your answer!

> the QuickActions are always the 2nd result, not the first. If you type in a website repeatedly then that should always come up as the first result.

Unfortunately not (really). The first line is always a domain autocompletion that would bring me to the home page of a domain. But often I am not interested in the home pages. So I have to press the arrow down button to get the first history result. And with the quick action buttons the first history suggestion is _below_ the quick action buttons.

Example:

I visit https://www.transfermarkt.de/hertha-bsc/news/verein/44 a few times per day. It's the first history suggestion for me if I enter "t". Without quick action buttons I have to press the arrow down key one time. With quick action buttons I have to press the arrow down key three times because there is the "manage themes" quick action as well as the "?" button with the SUMO link. So instead of three actions ("t", arrow down, Enter) I have to execute five actions ("t", arrow down, arrow down, arrow down, Enter) every time I want to open this page.

> Another hope is that since quickactions are quite strongly filtered, the user needs to be typing something quite specific for them to keep appearing

At the moment the quick action buttons already appear after one (!) typed character. I don't think that one character is a "quite specific" input. Maybe they should require more typed characters to appear?

Back to Bug 1783460 Comment 5