Bug 1786916 Comment 0 Edit History

Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.

The error is "We couldn’t find any usable key matching the specified search criteria".

STR:

1. Open an email to/from the person whose public key you're trying to import into Thunderbird (for example to send them encrypted email).

2. Right-click on their email address and choose "Discover OpenPGP Key".

This always fails for me, even when I choose an email address for someone I know has (and currently uses) a gpg/pgp key.

The person whose email address I've been testing with is Gabriele Svelto. He signs his email messages to me with his gpg/pgp private key, and includes his public key in the message. When I search on https://keys.openpgp.org/ using his email address (his Mozilla email address), I get a result that exactly matches the public key in his emails. (Under the hood Thunderbird seems to use the `keys.openpgp.org` server exclusively, as reflected in the default value for `temp.openpgp.keyserver` in `about:config`.)

What I'm doing should work, at least with Gabriele Svelto. Can you tell me why it doesn't?

I get the same error when I click on the `OpenPGP` button in one of Gabriele's emails and choose `Discover`.
The error is "We couldn’t find any usable key matching the specified search criteria".

STR:

1. Open an email to/from the person whose public key you're trying to import into Thunderbird (for example to send them encrypted email).

2. Right-click on their email address and choose "Discover OpenPGP Key".

This always fails for me, even when I choose an email address for someone I know has (and currently uses) a gpg/pgp keypair.

The person whose email address I've been testing with is Gabriele Svelto. He signs his email messages to me with his gpg/pgp private key, and includes his public key in the message. When I search on https://keys.openpgp.org/ using his email address (his Mozilla email address), I get a result that exactly matches the public key in his emails. (Under the hood Thunderbird seems to use the `keys.openpgp.org` server exclusively, as reflected in the default value for `temp.openpgp.keyserver` in `about:config`.)

What I'm doing should work, at least with Gabriele Svelto. Can you tell me why it doesn't?

I get the same error when I click on the `OpenPGP` button in one of Gabriele's emails and choose `Discover`.
The error is "We couldn’t find any usable key matching the specified search criteria".

STR:

1. Open an email to/from the person whose public key you're trying to import into Thunderbird (for example to send them encrypted email).

2. Right-click on their email address and choose "Discover OpenPGP Key".

This always fails for me, even when I choose an email address for someone I know has (and currently uses) a gpg/pgp keypair.

The person whose email address I've been testing with is Gabriele Svelto. He signs his email messages to me with his gpg/pgp private key, and includes his public key in the message. When I search on https://keys.openpgp.org/ using his email address (his Mozilla email address), I get a result that exactly matches the public key in his emails. (Under the hood Thunderbird seems to use the `keys.openpgp.org` server exclusively, as reflected in the default value for `temp.openpgp.keyserver` in `about:config`.)

What I'm doing should work, at least with Gabriele Svelto. Can you tell me why it doesn't?

I get the same error when I click on the `OpenPGP` button in one of Gabriele's emails and choose `Discover`.

Edit: These tests were with several recent minor updates of Thunderbird 102 (the current release).
The error is "We couldn’t find any usable key matching the specified search criteria".

STR:

1. Open an email to/from the person whose public key you're trying to import into Thunderbird (for example to send them encrypted email).

2. Right-click on their email address and choose "Discover OpenPGP Key".

This always fails for me, even when I choose an email address for someone I know has (and currently uses) a gpg/pgp keypair.

The person whose email address I've been testing with is Gabriele Svelto. He signs his email messages to me with his gpg/pgp private key, and includes his public key in the message. When I search on https://keys.openpgp.org/ using his email address (his Mozilla email address), I get a result that exactly matches the public key in his emails. (Under the hood Thunderbird seems to use the `keys.openpgp.org` keyserver exclusively, as reflected in the default value for `temp.openpgp.keyserver` in `about:config`.)

What I'm doing should work, at least with Gabriele Svelto. Can you tell me why it doesn't?

I get the same error when I click on the `OpenPGP` button in one of Gabriele's emails and choose `Discover`.

Edit: These tests were with several recent minor updates of Thunderbird 102 (the current release).
The error is "We couldn’t find any usable key matching the specified search criteria".

STR:

1. Open an email to/from the person whose public key you're trying to import into Thunderbird (for example to send them encrypted email).

2. Right-click on their email address and choose "Discover OpenPGP Key".

This always fails for me, even when I choose an email address for someone I know has (and currently uses) a gpg/pgp keypair.

The person whose email address I've been testing with is Gabriele Svelto. He signs his email messages to me with his gpg/pgp private key, and includes his public key in the message. When I search on https://keys.openpgp.org/ using his email address (his Mozilla email address), I get a result that exactly matches the public key in his emails. (Under the hood Thunderbird seems to use the `keys.openpgp.org` keyserver exclusively, as reflected in the default value for `temp.openpgp.keyserver` in `about:config`.)

What I'm doing should work, at least with Gabriele Svelto. Can you tell me why it doesn't?

I get the same error when I click on the `OpenPGP` button in one of Gabriele's emails and choose "Discover".

Edit: These tests were with several recent minor updates of Thunderbird 102 (the current release).
The error is "We couldn’t find any usable key matching the specified search criteria".

STR:

1. Open an email to/from the person whose public key you're trying to import into Thunderbird (for example to send them encrypted email).

2. Right-click on their email address and choose "Discover OpenPGP Key".

This always fails for me, even when I choose an email address for someone I know has (and currently uses) a gpg/pgp keypair.

The person whose email address I've been testing with is Gabriele Svelto. He signs his email messages to me with his gpg/pgp private key, and includes his public key in the message. When I search on https://keys.openpgp.org/ using his email address (his Mozilla email address), I get a result that exactly matches the public key in his emails. (Under the hood Thunderbird seems to use the `keys.openpgp.org` keyserver exclusively, as reflected in the default value for `temp.openpgp.keyserver` in `about:config`.)

What I'm doing should work, at least with Gabriele Svelto. Can you tell me why it doesn't?

I get the same error when I click on the `OpenPGP` button in one of Gabriele's emails and choose "Discover".

Back to Bug 1786916 Comment 0