Bug 1917945 Comment 0 Edit History

Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.

Steps to reproduce:

 1. Go to https://github.com/PlatformLab/NanoLog?tab=readme-ov-file or to any other vertically-scrollable page which has horizontally-scrollable subframes.
 2. Scroll down until you see the subframe. Scrolling down hides the dynamic toolbar.
 3. Horizontally scroll the subframe, moving your finger slightly diagonally downwards as you get to the end of the scroll gesture.
 4. Notice that the vertical motion of your finger caused the outer page to move vertically. Move your finger some more to cause more scrolling.
 5. Notice that the unexpected vertical scrolling is confined to a small delta.

Expected results:
When the gesture is scrolling a subframe, the outer page should not move. The dynamic toolbar should not appear during a gesture that scrolls a nested scroll frame.

Actual results:
The dynamic toolbar causes the outer page to shift, giving the impression of broken scrolling because the vertical scrolling is confined within a small cage.

This bug is pretty similar to bug 1917726, with the difference that in this bug, the finger is still in control of the outer page movement, whereas in bug 1917726 the toolbar just appears fully at the tiniest scroll-up and will not hide again during the scroll gesture.
Steps to reproduce:

 1. Go to https://github.com/PlatformLab/NanoLog?tab=readme-ov-file or to any other vertically-scrollable page which has horizontally-scrollable subframes.
 2. Scroll down until you see the subframe. Scrolling down hides the dynamic toolbar.
 3. Horizontally scroll the subframe, first to the right and then back to the left, moving your finger slightly diagonally downwards as you get to the end of the scroll gesture.
 4. Notice that the vertical motion of your finger caused the outer page to move vertically. Move your finger some more to cause more scrolling.
 5. Notice that the unexpected vertical scrolling is confined to a small delta.

Expected results:
When the gesture is scrolling a subframe, the outer page should not move. The dynamic toolbar should not appear during a gesture that scrolls a nested scroll frame.

Actual results:
The dynamic toolbar causes the outer page to shift, giving the impression of broken scrolling because the vertical scrolling is confined within a small cage.

This bug is pretty similar to bug 1917726, with the difference that in this bug, the finger is still in control of the outer page movement, whereas in bug 1917726 the toolbar just appears fully at the tiniest scroll-up and will not hide again during the scroll gesture.

Back to Bug 1917945 Comment 0