Bug 1689480 Comment 17 Edit History

Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.

Hi Itiel!

I looked into this respecting the above-mentioned scenarios and pages using Firefox 87.0a1 (20210219094547) .
On Windows 10x64 I tried with dark and white combined themes as well and the checkboxes and radio buttons looks as described in step1 from above. Also they are clickable above and bellow as stated in step 2. They all have the same effect on hover, disabled, clicked and disabled.

On macOS 11.2 however there are some radio button and checkboxes that I think they are not respecting the step2 rule. You have to be really close to them in order to activate them. I made a screen recording witch includes the hovered, selected and mouse-down states as well: [link](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1DguKoJ8S2QiQ1eI9pGwnav2eRbGKMyaQ/view?usp=sharing). 

At first glymse the problem with step2 rule happens on Ubuntu 18 as well, at least on below side, with certain checkboxes and radio buttons from about:welcome back page. Screen recording: [link](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1iL1iNHtlE4YVE7G1tuulxrsx6VCGaVcq/view?usp=sharing) 

Is this expected? Thank you in advance!
Hi Itiel!

I looked into this respecting the above-mentioned scenarios and pages using Firefox 87.0a1 (20210219094547) .
On Windows 10x64 I tried with dark and white combined themes as well and the checkboxes and radio buttons looks as described in step1 from above. Also they are clickable above and bellow as stated in step 2. They all have the same effect on hover, disabled, clicked and disabled. On about:addons (the report abuse dialog) -> I don't know for sure that the 3px rule is applied as well: [screenrecording](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1R6O9ghBwzhm6AIQ3wy8n7qe2n4-t6b2S/view?usp=sharing)

On macOS 11.2 however there are some radio button and checkboxes that I think they are not respecting the step2 rule. You have to be really close to them in order to activate them. I made a screen recording witch includes the hovered, selected and mouse-down states as well: [link](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1DguKoJ8S2QiQ1eI9pGwnav2eRbGKMyaQ/view?usp=sharing). 

At first glymse the problem with step2 rule happens on Ubuntu 18 as well, at least on below side, with certain checkboxes and radio buttons from about:welcome back page. Screen recording: [link](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1iL1iNHtlE4YVE7G1tuulxrsx6VCGaVcq/view?usp=sharing) 

Is this expected? Thank you in advance!
Hi Itiel!

I looked into this respecting the above-mentioned scenarios and pages using Firefox 87.0a1 (20210219094547) .
On Windows 10x64 I tried with dark and white combined themes as well and the checkboxes and radio buttons looks as described in step1 from above. Also they are clickable above and bellow as stated in step 2. They all have the same effect on hover, disabled, clicked and disabled. On about:addons (the report abuse dialog) -> I don't know for sure that the 3px rule is applied as well: [screenrecording](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1R6O9ghBwzhm6AIQ3wy8n7qe2n4-t6b2S/view?usp=sharing)

On macOS 11.2 however there are some radio button and checkboxes that I think they are not respecting the step2 rule. You have to be really close to them in order to activate them. I made a screen recording witch includes the hovered, selected and mouse-down states as well: [link](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1DguKoJ8S2QiQ1eI9pGwnav2eRbGKMyaQ/view?usp=sharing). 

At first glymse the problem with step2 rule happens on Ubuntu 18 as well, at least on below side, with certain checkboxes and radio buttons. Screen recording: [link](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1iL1iNHtlE4YVE7G1tuulxrsx6VCGaVcq/view?usp=sharing) 

Is this expected? Thank you in advance!

Back to Bug 1689480 Comment 17