896055 - Sign in from /events not signing in

Status: RESOLVED DUPLICATE of bug 971839

(Webmaker Graveyard :: Events, defect)

Description

[Replica @ModReplica]

Hi guys, was testing the [Add an Event] process for my Facebook QA today and the sign in process kept looping (3 times total) and when I entered an event, I got zero feed back on the page nor to my email address I used. ([e-mail])

I used my personal email for the second attempt since my rebeccah@mozillafoundation email didn't work at all (I could not start the [Add an Event] process while signed in - could not sign in, so filing this bug as a sign in issue, not an events issue)

I just saw an inbound email reporting the same issue from a user:


From:"kamil rextin" <[e-mail]>
Not sure if its my wifi. But the signin button doesn't seem to work ☹
 
kamil

Comment 1

[Brett Gaylor [:brett]]

Confirmed.

I'm seeing that I'm logged in, but it isn't updating the Add events button, so goes in a cycle

https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/7968133/images/eventlogin2.png

Dale, seems like a regression, as this was working earlier

Comment 2

[Brett Gaylor [:brett]]

Note that above was with [e-mail] - tried with [e-mail] and didn't hit this.

Comment 3

[Replica @ModReplica]

Here is my video link: 

https://www.dropbox.com/s/81nc5o6p7jpv0sh/login-Bug-896055%20.mp4

Most notable:

- tested in Chrome

- non ldap account worked with fewer hitches, did not test add an event

- ladap account had hitches, shows the 'signon cycle' problem I experienced on both accounts when using firefox

- ladap sequence also shows that the events platform leaves me confused about whether I got y test event added or not. No evidence to say it did. 



Will do one last test, will try to add an event using the non-ldap account that seems to sign on properly.

Comment 4

[Replica @ModReplica]

So, starting again from Chrome, newly opened browser. 

a) I had the sign-on error cycle happen again with my *non-ldap* account.

b) my test event also didn't look added to me. I'm uncertain if I should be getting a confirm email or not (because I am not, from any of my tests) but I expect to see some form of feedback on the page itself like - 'OK!' or 'Event Added!' or ...something that I think is likely missing.

so - c) I don't think people can add events right now?

Comment 5

[Brett Gaylor [:brett]]

This is also currently happening on webmaker.mofostaging.net/events

Comment 6

[Brett Gaylor [:brett]]

Dale, could you test this at slower connections?

I've personally experienced this bug,  I know there was another closed yesterday but the fact that users continue to file this suggests we shouldn't be wontfixing yet

Comment 7

[Dale Karp (:daleee)]

Sure thang!

Comment 8

[Dale Karp (:daleee)]

Alright, I've confirmed this login issue on slower connections. Will look into it!

Comment 9

[Brett Gaylor [:brett]]

Assigning to Jbuck - this is likely a larger persona / SSO issue

Comment 10

[Jon Buckley [:jbuck]]

This will *finally* be solved in bug 971839, with the implementation of the new Webmaker auth system. Hooray!