Created attachment 8482596 [details] no_secondary_information.png Gaia e7d31f0e9b6b19d9b484eeec8fb980718bc40d79 Gecko https://hg.mozilla.org/mozilla-central/rev/532b5fb77ba1 BuildID 20140901160203 Version 34.0a1 Base image v123 STR: 1. Insert a SD card with a song(MP4_AAC(Audio) with secondary information under /Ringtones folder 2. Go to Settings -> Sound 3. Under the "Tones" category, select "Manage Tones" 4. Check the song Expect result: Display Filename of ringtone and secondary information based on metadata (artist/source) Actual result: Do not show secondary information
The UX spec for this shows the filenames instead of the metadata. We never planned on showing metadata for SD card ringtones, since that would require the ringtones app to understand how to read the various metadata formats, which is a lot of code for something that I don't think is super-valuable.
Created attachment 8483194 [details] [2.1] Ringtones TransferSDCard.pdf Since I found the spec on UX doc page 6, "Display Filename of ringtone and if/when possible secondary information based on metadata (artist/source)", ni? UX for checking this design.
Thanks for checking in with UX on this, for 2.1 - ringtones from SD Card will display source (SD Card) and for ringtones from music, will display artist metadata (made available from music app). Please note: we do plan to revisit this in the future.
Based on comment 4, since this behavior is intentional, I'm marking this WONTFIX. If we do decide to revisit this in the future, I expect we'll do something different altogether and file a new bug.