Closed Bug 1067901 Opened 10 years ago Closed 10 years ago

Different Behavior when user accesses to invalid url with WIFI or with data.

Categories

(Firefox OS Graveyard :: Gaia::Browser, defect)

Product:
Firefox OS Graveyard
Component:
Gaia::Browser
Platform:
ARM
Gonk (Firefox OS)
Type:
defect
Priority:
Not set
Severity:
normal

Tracking

(Not tracked)

Status:
RESOLVED DUPLICATE of bug 1023742

People

(Reporter: lolimartinezcr, Assigned: mancas)

Details

flame ENG 2.0 Gecko-5c6d9a6 Gaia-d056733 Flame 2.1 USER Gecko 3953700 Gaia 713448b STRs: 1. Data actives (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data roaming ON) 2. Tap Browser application. 3. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) 4. Tap search button --> Result: User see white page. 5. Desactive Data (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data roaming OFF) and WIFI connection actived. 6. Tap Browser application. 7. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) 8. Tap search button --> Result: User see: "Server not found" Actual result: With each connection result is different. Expecte result: Witch each connection result is same.
(In reply to Loli (:lolimartinezcr) from comment #0) > flame > ENG > 2.0 > Gecko-5c6d9a6 > Gaia-d056733 > > Flame > 2.1 > USER > Gecko 3953700 > Gaia 713448b > > STRs: > 1. Data actives (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data > roaming ON) > 2. Tap Browser application. > 3. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) > 4. Tap search button --> Result: User see white page. > 5. Desactive Data (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data > roaming OFF) and WIFI connection actived. > 6. Tap Browser application. > 7. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) > 8. Tap search button --> Result: User see: "Server not found" > > Actual result: > With each connection result is different. > > Expecte result: > Witch each connection result is same. Modify step 5: 5. Desactive Data (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection *OFF* and Data roaming OFF) and WIFI connection actived.
Assignee: nobody → b.mcb
Status: NEW → RESOLVED
Closed: 10 years ago
Resolution: --- → DUPLICATE
Reproducing again in 2.1
Status: RESOLVED → REOPENED
Resolution: DUPLICATE → ---
Tested and this bug is reproducible 2.1 flame eng Gecko-1df1af9 Gaia-de63272 STRs: 1. Data actives (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data roaming ON) 2. Tap Browser application. 3. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) 4. Tap search button --> AR1 5. Desactive Data (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data roaming OFF) and WIFI connection actived. 6. Tap Browser application. 7. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) 8. Tap search button --> Actual result AR1. User see white page. AR2: Browser doesn't nothing. Expected result ER1. Bad request (Invalid Hostname) is shown. ER2: Bad request (Invalid Hostname) is shown. Also This STRs have been tested with 2.0 it is working flame user Gecko-05f0ef5 Gaia-31d6c94 STRs: 1. Data actives (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data roaming ON) 2. Tap Browser application. 3. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) 4. Tap search button --> Result: Bad request (Invalid Hostname) is show. 5. Desactive Data (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data roaming OFF) and WIFI connection actived. 6. Tap Browser application. 7. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) 8. Tap search button --> Result: Bad request (Invalid Hostname) is shown
(In reply to Loli (:lolimartinezcr) from comment #4) > Tested and this bug is reproducible > 2.1 > flame > eng > Gecko-1df1af9 > Gaia-de63272 > > STRs: > 1. Data actives (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data > roaming ON) > 2. Tap Browser application. > 3. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) > 4. Tap search button --> AR1 > 5. Desactive Data (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data > roaming OFF) and WIFI connection actived. > 6. Tap Browser application. > 7. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) > 8. Tap search button --> AR2 > > Actual result > AR1. User see white page. > AR2: Browser doesn't nothing. > > Expected result > ER1. Bad request (Invalid Hostname) is shown. > ER2: Bad request (Invalid Hostname) is shown. > > > Also This STRs have been tested with 2.0 it is working > flame > user > Gecko-05f0ef5 > Gaia-31d6c94 > > STRs: > 1. Data actives (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data > roaming ON) > 2. Tap Browser application. > 3. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) > 4. Tap search button --> Result: Bad request (Invalid Hostname) is show. > 5. Desactive Data (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data > roaming OFF) and WIFI connection actived. > 6. Tap Browser application. > 7. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) > 8. Tap search button --> Result: Bad request (Invalid Hostname) is shown
[Blocking Requested - why for this release]:
blocking-b2g: --- → 2.1?
Clearing the nom as the Dup's marked invalid.
blocking-b2g: 2.1? → ---
[Blocking Requested - why for this release]: Well, indeed it is not a duplicate, because as you can see in comment 4, actual result is different. So asking again for being a blocker. If you prefer, we can create another bug, instead or reusing this one.
blocking-b2g: --- → 2.1?
(In reply to Marcelino Veiga Tuimil [:sonmarce] from comment #8) > [Blocking Requested - why for this release]: > > Well, indeed it is not a duplicate, because as you can see in comment 4, > actual result is different. So asking again for being a blocker. If you > prefer, we can create another bug, instead or reusing this one. Can you confirm if you see this behaviour in 2.0 as well, which would make this a regression ? Vincent can you see of this is a recent regression from WIFI or help investitigate?
Flags: needinfo?(vchang)
Flags: needinfo?(lolimartinezcr)
I have tested this bug in 2.0 and behavior is different to 2.1 (you can see https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1067901#c5) > Also This STRs have been tested with 2.0 it is working > flame > user > Gecko-05f0ef5 > Gaia-31d6c94 > > STRs: > 1. Data actives (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data > roaming ON) > 2. Tap Browser application. > 3. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) > 4. Tap search button --> Result: Bad request (Invalid Hostname) is show. > 5. Desactive Data (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data > roaming OFF) and WIFI connection actived. > 6. Tap Browser application. > 7. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) > 8. Tap search button --> Result: Bad request (Invalid Hostname) is shown
Flags: needinfo?(lolimartinezcr)
I've been trying to reproduce the issue in 2.0 and 2.1: 2.0 flame eng Gecko-5d3dbd0 Gaia-736933b2 STRs: 1. Data actives (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data roaming ON) 2. Tap Browser application. 3. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) 4. Tap search button --> AR1 5. Desactive Data (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data roaming OFF) and WIFI connection actived. 6. Tap Browser application. 7. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) 8. Tap search button --> AR2 Actual result AR1: White page due to the issue related with the telco operator (for further information see [1]). AR2: Bad request (Invalid Hostname) is shown. 2.1 flame eng Gecko-1eacba9 Gaia-230a9c53 STRs: 1. Data actives (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data roaming ON) 2. Tap Browser application. 3. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) 4. Tap search button --> AR1 5. Desactive Data (Settings > Cellular & Data > Data connection ON and Data roaming OFF) and WIFI connection actived. 6. Tap Browser application. 7. Write invalid url (for explame: www.invalidurl.es) 8. Tap search button --> AR2 Actual result AR1: White page due to the issue related with the telco operator (for further information see [1]). AR2: Bad request (Invalid Hostname) is shown. So, this is working as expected. Loli can confirm it [1] https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1023742#c19
Flags: needinfo?(lolimartinezcr)
Clear Ni per comment 11.
Flags: needinfo?(vchang)
So, setting again to be a duplicate of bug 1023742
Status: REOPENED → RESOLVED
blocking-b2g: 2.1? → ---
Closed: 10 years ago → 10 years ago
Resolution: --- → DUPLICATE
(In reply to Marcelino Veiga Tuimil [:sonmarce] from comment #13) > So, setting again to be a duplicate of bug 1023742 > > *** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of bug 1023742 *** I have tested this bug with Manu, and I have seen similar behavior in Wifi 2.0 and 2.1 and similar behavior with 3G in 2.0 and 2.1. Different behavior between Wifi and 3G but Manu said me the reason is network.
Flags: needinfo?(lolimartinezcr)
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.