Last Comment Bug 107280 - Sorting Messages selection not remembered between sessions
: Sorting Messages selection not remembered between sessions
Product: SeaMonkey
Classification: Client Software
Component: MailNews: Message Display (show other bugs)
: Trunk
: x86 Windows 2000
: -- normal with 4 votes (vote)
: ---
Assigned To: mail
Depends on:
  Show dependency treegraph
Reported: 2001-10-28 18:16 PST by Kent
Modified: 2008-06-02 21:23 PDT (History)
8 users (show)
See Also:
Crash Signature:
QA Whiteboard:
Iteration: ---
Points: ---

Sorting error (10.94 KB, image/gif)
2001-12-27 00:31 PST, Ho KS
no flags Details
What it should be (10.68 KB, image/gif)
2001-12-27 00:35 PST, Ho KS
no flags Details
Incorrectly sorted news postings on entering newsgroup (39.24 KB, image/jpeg)
2001-12-27 01:25 PST, mail_john
no flags Details
Correctly sorted news postings after manually sorting twice (38.42 KB, image/jpeg)
2001-12-27 01:25 PST, mail_john
no flags Details
Picture of newsgroup when entering for group initially (34.06 KB, image/jpeg)
2002-04-23 02:13 PDT, john_pub_mail1
no flags Details
Picture of newsgroup messages after manually sorting (35.46 KB, image/jpeg)
2002-04-23 02:17 PDT, john_pub_mail1
no flags Details
View of Search Messages window after automatic sorting (or lack thereof), i.e. before manual re-sorting. (50.39 KB, image/jpeg)
2003-07-17 10:37 PDT, Stéphane Rousset
no flags Details
View of Search Messages window after manual re-sorting (45.50 KB, image/jpeg)
2003-07-17 10:40 PDT, Stéphane Rousset
no flags Details
No patch (2 bytes, text/plain)
2003-11-12 13:52 PST, Peter Rasmussen
no flags Details

Description Kent 2001-10-28 18:16:29 PST
When starting mail/news is a often necessary to resort the messages in a mail
folder by date-decending.  This should be a selection remembered between sessions.
Comment 1 Michael Lee Yohe 2001-10-28 22:00:31 PST
wfm - 2001101201
Comment 2 mail_john 2001-11-26 14:52:01 PST
I've also got this problem under WinMe from a few days back. Currently using
build  2001112603. As you move around the newsgroups, you often have to resort
the messages into Subject order. It seems that although the sort setting
(subject order) appears to be remembered, the headers are not sorted correctly
on loading that group.
Comment 3 Ho KS 2001-12-27 00:31:32 PST
Created attachment 62818 [details]
Sorting error

Messages set to display Unread.
Threaded is checked.
Happens when news/mail window is re-opened
Comment 4 Ho KS 2001-12-27 00:35:24 PST
Created attachment 62819 [details]
What it should be

This is the correct sorting, after I manually click the thread button on the
top left twice.
First time, it sorts in reverse order.

Note the circled thread
Comment 5 mail_john 2001-12-27 01:24:03 PST
Created two attachments. This is a group that was sorted by subject,(and
correctly remembered its state between sessions). However, upon loading the
group, the list is not sorted correctly by subject.

From mailpic1.jpg, you can see that on entering the group, News has sorted it
incorectly (M,S,O,R,S)

However, after clicking on the "subject" header twice (once to sort reverse, and
then once again to sort normally) you can see that the sort order has changed
(ie  is now correctly sorted). This is shown in newspic2.jpg

Note that this seems to happen a lot with "Re:" messages. "Re: " should be
completey ignored and sorting should be done purely on the real subject line.

Comment 6 mail_john 2001-12-27 01:25:13 PST
Created attachment 62823 [details]
Incorrectly sorted news postings on entering newsgroup
Comment 7 mail_john 2001-12-27 01:25:59 PST
Created attachment 62824 [details]
Correctly sorted news postings after manually sorting twice
Comment 8 john_pub_mail1 2002-02-06 03:28:04 PST
Any progress been made on this? I've just checked the latest nightly (2002020409
- afte the .9.8) and it still exhibits this bug as per the screen caps above.

Although it is not major, it doesn't instill confidence when trying to get
someone to move from other browsers to netscape/mozilla when mozilla can't even
sort a mailbox correctly!
Comment 9 john_pub_mail1 2002-02-16 06:35:19 PST
Just checked build 2002021503, and its still failing to sort correctly. Can a
fix be scheduled or it at least be moved to "confirmed", rather than being left
into "unconfirmed" limbo for 4 months ?
Comment 10 Peter Lockhart 2002-02-25 03:51:22 PST
this is a duplicate of bug 93655
Comment 11 john_pub_mail1 2002-02-25 04:42:16 PST
Are you sure? The 93655 bug states that mail settings do not stick. 107280
States that mail settings do stick, but that sorting does not correctly take
place, eg, my settings are for subject order, but when entering the newsgroup
messages are sorted via subject order, but not correctly.

If this is a dupe (which they don't appaer to be), can this one be properly
duped to it instead of being left in unconfirmed limbo?
Comment 12 Anders Åge Larsen 2002-04-22 23:59:20 PDT
Since this bug was reported, a newer version of Mozilla (1.0 RC1) has been
released. Reporter, please can you check to see whether this bug is still 
present in a recent build (Moz1-RC1 or a new nightly build). If
this bug does not occur please can you resolve the bugreport?
Comment 13 john_pub_mail1 2002-04-23 02:09:58 PDT
I've been running RC1 since release, and the problem is still there. On
initially starting mail/news the problem can be a little hard to find (most of
what you see is sorted correctly), but there are always some incorrectly sorted

As you leave the mail/news window up and refresh your newsgroups periodically,
it becomes more and more likely that your newly shown messages will shown sorted

I've attached two more pictures from RC1 that show the problem.
Comment 14 john_pub_mail1 2002-04-23 02:13:14 PDT
Created attachment 80554 [details]
Picture of newsgroup when entering for group initially

This is on intitially starting mail/news and selecting the newsgroup. Note that
the group has correctly remembered its "sort by subject" setting from the
previous session, but the sorting has not been done correctly on loading this
Comment 15 john_pub_mail1 2002-04-23 02:17:44 PDT
Created attachment 80555 [details]
Picture of newsgroup messages after manually sorting

This is a picture of the same list after clicking the "sort by subject" widgit
twice. Once to reverse sort by subject, and then once again to get a forward
sort by subject. The initial click to get a reverse sort does correctly resort
the messages alphabetically, but in reverse order, so it seems that the sorting
mechanism itself does work correctly, but not when you initially select that
group to read and get the first listing of the group's messages in the listing
Comment 16 john_pub_mail1 2002-05-12 03:43:47 PDT
Just checked Mozilla 1.0 RC-2. It's still showing the same faulty sorting
behaviour as described above.
Comment 17 Boris 'pi' Piwinger 2002-05-30 14:11:39 PDT

*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of 93655 ***
Comment 18 john_pub_mail1 2002-05-30 14:18:54 PDT
#17 Please check comment #11 - this is not the same behaviour as 93655.

In this bug the sorted state is remembered correctly, but the sorting is not
done correctly. In 93655 the sorted state is not remembered correctly.

Note that this is still occuring in RC-3
Comment 19 Boris 'pi' Piwinger 2002-05-30 15:02:17 PDT
Reopening by last comment and setting NEW.

Comment 20 Sebastian Redl 2003-01-30 15:15:07 PST
A bug so similar that I won't post a new report occurs to me for build 20021130
(that's the stable 1.2.1) on Win2k SP2:
I have set the sorting to subject ascending. It normally works very well, but
every now and then (every 4th or 5th time I download mail) it confuses the order
of the newly downloaded mails. The mails I download usually have the same
subject lines up to the 15th character or so.
Comment 21 Stéphane Rousset 2003-07-17 10:25:42 PDT
I have a similar problem in the Search Messages window in e-mail on Mac OS X
(10.2.6) with Mozilla build 20030624, running on an Apple iBook (500MHz). Do I
need to enter this as a new bug, since this one (107280) is for Windows 2000?

Symptoms are: 
1) previous search done then sorted on date
2) do new search
3) Mozilla still highlights the Date column to show it as the sorting column,
yet the sorting isn't in any sequence of dates - neither ascending nor descending
4) sort on any other column then sort again by date ==> all is OK now... until
the next sort.

Regards, Stephane.
Comment 22 Stéphane Rousset 2003-07-17 10:37:05 PDT
Created attachment 127956 [details]
View of Search Messages window after automatic sorting (or lack thereof), i.e. before manual re-sorting.
Comment 23 Stéphane Rousset 2003-07-17 10:40:07 PDT
Created attachment 127957 [details]
View of Search Messages window after manual re-sorting
Comment 24 john_pub_mail1 2003-07-17 10:54:32 PDT
I'm no longer seeing this behaviour since the 1.4 release (maybe since 1.4 RC
2/3, but I didn't stick with those because of other problems).  Difficult for me
to do an apples to apples comparison as my OS has now been changed to WinXP.

Comment 25 Stéphane Rousset 2003-07-17 15:13:39 PDT
Well, I too have Mozilla 1.4 (Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; U; PPC Mac OS X Mach-O;
en-US; rv:1.4) Gecko/20030624). So, maybe the Mac version still has the problem.
Comment 26 Peter Rasmussen 2003-11-12 13:52:19 PST
Created attachment 135341 [details]
No patch

This bug still exist in 1.6a on Linux and is quite annoying because I never
sort messages by Date and never Ascending.

It could however be a wider problem with Mozilla saving preferred settings
because I have sometimes seen other settings lost, eg. passwords for
site-specific logins and where to put the included message that a reply is
written for, ie. I always want the new text on top, but sometimes have found
the setting to put the new text below.
Comment 27 Janick Bernet 2003-11-14 06:23:17 PST
I have same issue with TB 0.3 and 0.4a on Windows.
There should maybe be a setting to set default sort order which applies on new
accounts and would also apply if settings got lost.
Comment 28 Wayne Mery (:wsmwk, NI for questions) 2007-08-22 13:04:36 PDT
andrew, see you seethis?
Comment 29 Andrew Schultz 2007-08-22 21:51:06 PDT
yes, the original report is WFM
Comment 30 Wayne Mery (:wsmwk, NI for questions) 2008-06-02 10:50:56 PDT
=> WFM per andrew
Comment 31 Tony Mechelynck [:tonymec] 2008-06-02 21:23:29 PDT
Mozilla/5.0 (X11; U; Linux i686; en-US; rv:1.9pre) Gecko/2008060201 SeaMonkey/2.0a1pre

FWIW, this WFM too: I sort by Order Received but upwards in some folders and downwards in others, and Sm remembers it from one session to the next.

If you want to REOPEN, include specifics of how to reproduce, actual results, expected results, (which seem to vary between comments above) as well as your UA string (similar to the one at top of this comment, and found next to "Build Identifier" at bottom of the about: page).

Note You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.