Closed Bug 117503 Opened 23 years ago Closed 23 years ago

sometimes does not work with junkbuster proxy

Categories

(Core :: Networking: HTTP, defect)

x86
Windows 2000
defect
Not set
trivial

Tracking

()

VERIFIED DUPLICATE of bug 38488

People

(Reporter: seanc, Assigned: darin.moz)

Details

Attachments

(2 files)

From Bugzilla Helper:
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.0; en-US; rv:0.9.7) Gecko/20011221
BuildID:    2001122106

Fetching pages through junkbuster sometimes results in blocked ads being
fetched. If a rule is set blocking the whole doubleclick.net domain, Mozilla
will correctly get the blocked notice from the proxy when trying to display
www.doubleclick.net. After going to www.infoworld.com ( crawling with
doubleclick ads) the browser gets the blocked notice on some ads but not others.
Pressing reload makes the problem worse (all ads are displayed). Going to
www.doubleclick.net then results in the site being displayed.
I suspect this is a Mozilla bug since the following browsers produce expected
output:
Netscape 4.78 (Win 2000)
IE 5.00 (Win 2000)
Konquorer 2.2.1 (OpenBSD 3.0-CURRENT)
Netscape 4.75 (BSDI version, on OpenBSD 3.0-CURRENT)



Reproducible: Always
Steps to Reproduce:
1. set up internet junk buster with config as specified in attached files
2. set up mozilla to use junkbuster
3. go to http://www.doubleclick.net
4. go to http://www.infoworld.com
5. click reload
6. go to http://www.doubleclick.net

Actual Results:  Doubleclick's website was inappropriately displayed.

junkbuster output ("debug 1" specified in config)
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/adi/idg.infoworld.com/pageone;sz=468x60;ptile=1;ord=030600311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/google.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/line_red_small.jpg
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/adi/idg.infoworld-fixedhome.com/pageone;sz=120x60;ptile=3;ord=030600311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/adi/idg.infoworld-pmedallions.com/pageone;sz=120x90;ptile=4;ord=030600311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/adi/idg.infoworld-skyscraper.com/pageone;sz=120x600;ptile=5;ord=030600311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/adi/idg.infoworld-amedallions.com/pageone;sz=120x90;ptile=6;ord=030600311201?
crunch!


Expected Results:  The site should not be displayed.

junkbuster (as above) from Netscape loading the page (note there are more
requests through the proxy)

junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/script/text.css
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/script/text.js
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/ad/idg.pixel.global/idgpixel7.18.00;sz=1x1;ord=063500311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/ad/idg.pixel.usa.infoworld/usainfw11.7.00;sz=1x1;ord=063500311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/ad/idg.infoworld-fixedhousead.com/pageone;sz=60x60;ptile=3;ord=515515021101?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC 64.124.72.13/images/bullet_subject_index.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC 64.124.72.13/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC 64.124.72.13/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC 64.124.72.13/images/submit_button.gif
junkbuster: GPC 64.124.72.13/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/google.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/line_red_small.jpg
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/line_red_small.jpg
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/ad/idg.us.ifw.textlink/verisign;sz=1x1;tile=53;ord=2001123102222?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/ad/idg.infoworld.com/pageone;sz=468x60;ptile=1;ord=063500311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/ad/idg.infoworld-fixedhome.com/pageone;sz=120x60;ptile=3;ord=063500311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/ad/idg.infoworld-skyscraper.com/pageone;sz=120x600;ptile=5;ord=063500311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC 64.124.72.13/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/red_space.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/ad/idg.us.ifw.textlink/oracle9i;sz=1x1;tile=55;ord=2001123102222?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/ad/idg.infoworld-amedallions.com/pageone;sz=120x90;ptile=6;ord=063500311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/cto_zone.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/ad/idg.us.ifw.textlink/verisign;sz=1x1;tile=52;ord=2001123102222?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/ad/idg.infoworld-pmedallions.com/pageone;sz=120x90;ptile=4;ord=063500311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/cto/01/12/03/011203fecto.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/ad/idg.us.ifw.textlink/sprint;sz=1x1;tile=51;ord=2001123102222?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC 64.124.72.13/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/ad/idg.infoworld-middlebanner.com/pageone;sz=468x60;ptile=2;ord=063500311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/line_red_small.jpg
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/ad/idg.us.ifw.textlink/hpbpn;sz=1x1;tile=54;ord=2001123102222?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/continue.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC www.infoworld.com/images/space.gif
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/adl/idg.infoworld.com/pageone;sz=468x60;ptile=1;ord=063500311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/adl/idg.infoworld-middlebanner.com/pageone;sz=468x60;ptile=2;ord=063500311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/adl/idg.infoworld.com/pageone;sz=468x60;ptile=1;ord=063500311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/adl/idg.infoworld-fixedhome.com/pageone;sz=120x60;ptile=3;ord=063500311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/adl/idg.infoworld-pmedallions.com/pageone;sz=120x90;ptile=4;ord=063500311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/adl/idg.infoworld-skyscraper.com/pageone;sz=120x600;ptile=5;ord=063500311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC
ad.doubleclick.net/adl/idg.infoworld-amedallions.com/pageone;sz=120x90;ptile=6;ord=063500311201?
crunch!
junkbuster: GPC www.digitalresearch.com/rgr/rgr0383.js

configuration information:
proxy server:
OpenBSD 3.0-STABLE
junkbuster 2.0.2 (installed from ports) 
squid 2.3 (installed from ports) -- junkbuster is forwarded to squid

client:
all client browsers (windows and OpenBSD) are set to use the junkbuster proxy
Attached file junkbuster config file
Attached file junkbuster blockfile
junkbuster is broken !
This is not a Mozilla bug because junkbuster has problems with Http/1.1

Netscape 4.78 (Win 2000)                             :NS4.7x can only Http/1.0
IE 5.00 (Win 2000)                                   :IE use Http/1.0 with Proxys
Konquorer 2.2.1 (OpenBSD 3.0-CURRENT)                :I dunno
Netscape 4.75 (BSDI version, on OpenBSD 3.0-CURRENT) :NS4.7x can only Http/1.0

This bug is easy to find : QA/known bugs/#4 on the list

Please set edit\preferences\debug\Networking\Http = 1.0 (from 1.1) to get around
this junkbuster problem.


*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of 38488 ***
Status: UNCONFIRMED → RESOLVED
Closed: 23 years ago
Resolution: --- → DUPLICATE
Verified dupe.
Status: RESOLVED → VERIFIED
QA Contact: tever → junruh
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.

Attachment

General

Creator:
Created:
Updated:
Size: