Closed Bug 266001 Opened 20 years ago Closed 19 years ago

Cookie duplicated in HTTP header

Categories

(Core :: Networking: Cookies, defect)

x86
Linux
defect
Not set
normal

Tracking

()

RESOLVED EXPIRED

People

(Reporter: luislain, Assigned: darin.moz)

Details

Attachments

(1 file)

User-Agent:       Mozilla/5.0 (X11; U; Linux i686; en-US; rv:1.7.3) Gecko/20040913
Build Identifier: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; U; Linux i686; en-US; rv:1.7.3) Gecko/20040913

In one of the request the http header:
Cookie: JSESSIONID=AKJDAKJDGKJAGD
Cookie: JSESSIONID=AKJDAKJDGKJAGD
appears twice.

That makes the server receives as the JSESSIONID value:
(AKJDAKJDGKJAGD, JSESSIONID=AKJDAKJDGKJAGD)
instead of just:
(AKJDAKJDGKJAGD)

Because of that, the server puts a "Cookie-set" Header in the response with a
new value, and all the session's beans are lost.

Reproducible: Always
Steps to Reproduce:
1.Launch Apache+Tomcat
2.Launch Mozilla 1.7.3 + Java Pluging 1.5
3.

Actual Results:  
Hypertext Transfer Protocol
    GET
/visualAtcaMntg/visual/jsp/appletMenuService.jsp?idSession=716266963&path=DESTINO%3A++%5BMCAIDM%5D
HTTP/1.1\r\n
    User-Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (Linux 2.4.27-rc3) Java/1.5.0\r\n
    Host: 192.168.10.29\r\n
    Accept: text/html, image/gif, image/jpeg, *; q=.2, */*; q=.2\r\n
    Connection: keep-alive\r\n
    Content-type: application/x-www-form-urlencoded\r\n
    Cookie: JSESSIONID=79D43CC3C3830DE88019F4EBFC8AB7C5\r\n
    Cookie: JSESSIONID=79D43CC3C3830DE88019F4EBFC8AB7C5\r\n
    \r\n

Expected Results:  
Hypertext Transfer Protocol
    GET
/visualAtcaMntg/visual/jsp/appletMenuService.jsp?idSession=716266963&path=DESTINO%3A++%5BMCAIDM%5D
HTTP/1.1\r\n
    User-Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (Linux 2.4.27-rc3) Java/1.5.0\r\n
    Host: 192.168.10.29\r\n
    Accept: text/html, image/gif, image/jpeg, *; q=.2, */*; q=.2\r\n
    Connection: keep-alive\r\n
    Content-type: application/x-www-form-urlencoded\r\n
    Cookie: JSESSIONID=79D43CC3C3830DE88019F4EBFC8AB7C5\r\n
    \r\n
Perhaps related to Bug 256894 ?
Attached file Cookie log
At the end of the file you caon see the same Cookie is send twice, and then a
new value for the cookie is accepted.
I have updated the Tomcat server version from 4.0.2 to 5.0.25 and it works fine!
I was thinking Tomcat 5.x can manage duplicated cookies ignoring the second one
instead of concatenate both, but i can not find any Request wich http header has
the "Cookie:" duplicated.

I do not think building http headers for request relies on the server, but ... i
do not understand what is happening.

Status: UNCONFIRMED → RESOLVED
Closed: 20 years ago
Resolution: --- → INVALID
REOPEN:
I think this is a valid concern:

16384[8082010]: ===== COOKIE ACCEPTED =====
16384[8082010]: request URL:
http://192.168.10.29/visualAtcaMntg/visual/jsp/login.jsp
16384[8082010]: cookie string:
JSESSIONID=B6EFF42FE8403585ED780A12D0190F86;Path=/visualAtcaMntg
16384[8082010]: current time: Tue Oct 26 07:53:31 2004 GMT
16384[8082010]: ----------------
16384[8082010]: name: JSESSIONID
16384[8082010]: value: B6EFF42FE8403585ED780A12D0190F86
16384[8082010]: host: 192.168.10.29
16384[8082010]: path: /visualAtcaMntg
16384[8082010]: expires: at end of session
16384[8082010]: is secure: false
16384[8082010]: 
16384[8082010]: ===== COOKIE SENT =====
16384[8082010]: request URL:
http://192.168.10.29/visualAtcaMntg/visual/css/GENERAL.css
16384[8082010]: cookie string: JSESSIONID=B6EFF42FE8403585ED780A12D0190F86
16384[8082010]: current time: Tue Oct 26 07:53:31 2004 GMT
16384[8082010]: 
16384[8082010]: ===== COOKIE SENT =====
16384[8082010]: request URL: http://192.168.10.29/visualAtcaMntg/visual/js/util.js
16384[8082010]: cookie string: JSESSIONID=B6EFF42FE8403585ED780A12D0190F86
16384[8082010]: current time: Tue Oct 26 07:53:32 2004 GMT
16384[8082010]: 
16384[8082010]: ===== COOKIE SENT =====
16384[8082010]: request URL: http://192.168.10.29/visualAtcaMntg/visual/js/util.js
16384[8082010]: cookie string: JSESSIONID=B6EFF42FE8403585ED780A12D0190F86
16384[8082010]: current time: Tue Oct 26 07:53:32 2004 GMT

Each cookie that is sent gets a log entry, so when you look at the log, you need
to compare the request URL AND the timestamps to find the duplicate transmissions.
Status: RESOLVED → UNCONFIRMED
Resolution: INVALID → ---
OK, it's not a cookie log (there are already two of those), but here's an 400
error report from visiting http://observer.guardian.co.uk/

Note the multiple duplications of cookies... This is not the only site, google
news is broken for me right now but doesn't report back the offending line.
Removal of the cookies.txt file clears this all up for a few days. This is a
nightly build from 11/06/04 cvs.

The part that really gets me is that they're the same data (except for the last,
truncated, one)!



Bad Request
Your browser sent a request that this server could not understand.

Size of a request header field exceeds server limit.

Cookie:
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_MU=UVl6MUJjQ29AamtBQUZoTURad3xVeXZ3KzlaQXV6QVN6NjRTY3I0U053PT0%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU6IDQyLjM1OTotNzEuMDYxQDEzNDE1NDEyODM4ODY2NzE1NzIzNjE2ODMzODc1NTIyNzIyMTIxMzE2NQ%3d%3d;
GU_LOCATION=dXNhOjU6bWE6NDpib3N0b246NDo1MDY6Y2FibGU
This is an automated message, with ID "auto-resolve01".

This bug has had no comments for a long time. Statistically, we have found that
bug reports that have not been confirmed by a second user after three months are
highly unlikely to be the source of a fix to the code.

While your input is very important to us, our resources are limited and so we
are asking for your help in focussing our efforts. If you can still reproduce
this problem in the latest version of the product (see below for how to obtain a
copy) or, for feature requests, if it's not present in the latest version and
you still believe we should implement it, please visit the URL of this bug
(given at the top of this mail) and add a comment to that effect, giving more
reproduction information if you have it.

If it is not a problem any longer, you need take no action. If this bug is not
changed in any way in the next two weeks, it will be automatically resolved.
Thank you for your help in this matter.

The latest beta releases can be obtained from:
Firefox:     http://www.mozilla.org/projects/firefox/
Thunderbird: http://www.mozilla.org/products/thunderbird/releases/1.5beta1.html
Seamonkey:   http://www.mozilla.org/projects/seamonkey/
This bug has been automatically resolved after a period of inactivity (see above
comment). If anyone thinks this is incorrect, they should feel free to reopen it.
Status: UNCONFIRMED → RESOLVED
Closed: 20 years ago19 years ago
Resolution: --- → EXPIRED
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.

Attachment

General

Creator:
Created:
Updated:
Size: