[reflow branch] <select> with CSS width:0 height:0 is visible This is bug 58220 that has come back. Given the styles, I think the rendering is correct per CSS 2.1, but since 58220 was an accepted bug I wanted to make you aware of the diff to trunk... (Apologies for the spam if you're aware of it)
Yeah, I did see bug 58220 in the log when I was working on this code and I did test against those testcases (as well as all other existing form control regression tests). Since I wasn't running into the _real_ issue that bug was reported on (that of the scrollbars just doing very wacky things, etc). Given that the only reason for width:0; height:0 was bug 34297, I decided this was an acceptable behavior change in return for much cleaner code. So I'm somewhat tempted to wontfix this, to be truthful.
Gecko reflow-branch and IE7: green boxes Gecko trunk, Opera9 and Webkit (2006-11-08): red boxes Could we keep the bug open until 'box-sizing:border-box' is more clearly specified, so we don't forget about the issue? http://www.w3.org/TR/2002/WD-css3-box-20021024/#the-box-width
I suppose... we should mark it dependent on whatever bug is tracking box-sizing, then.
The behavior on the reflow branch matches the Opera behavior. The trunk and Firefox 2.0 behavior matches what IE7 does.
Right, "reflow-branch"/"trunk" should be swapped in my comment 3.
10 years ago
IE8rc1 and Opera's latest weekly also render two red boxes. So everyone agrees on this case, maybe it can be wontfixed now?
Yeah, I think so.