[reflow branch] <select> with CSS width:0 height:0 is visible This is bug 58220 that has come back. Given the styles, I think the rendering is correct per CSS 2.1, but since 58220 was an accepted bug I wanted to make you aware of the diff to trunk... (Apologies for the spam if you're aware of it)
Yeah, I did see bug 58220 in the log when I was working on this code and I did test against those testcases (as well as all other existing form control regression tests). Since I wasn't running into the _real_ issue that bug was reported on (that of the scrollbars just doing very wacky things, etc). Given that the only reason for width:0; height:0 was bug 34297, I decided this was an acceptable behavior change in return for much cleaner code. So I'm somewhat tempted to wontfix this, to be truthful.
Gecko reflow-branch and IE7: green boxes Gecko trunk, Opera9 and Webkit (2006-11-08): red boxes Could we keep the bug open until 'box-sizing:border-box' is more clearly specified, so we don't forget about the issue? http://www.w3.org/TR/2002/WD-css3-box-20021024/#the-box-width
I suppose... we should mark it dependent on whatever bug is tracking box-sizing, then.
The behavior on the reflow branch matches the Opera behavior. The trunk and Firefox 2.0 behavior matches what IE7 does.
Right, "reflow-branch"/"trunk" should be swapped in my comment 3.
IE8rc1 and Opera's latest weekly also render two red boxes. So everyone agrees on this case, maybe it can be wontfixed now?
Yeah, I think so.