4113 - [PP]scrollbars never reappear after visit to frameset with no scrollbars

Status: RESOLVED WORKSFORME

(Core :: Layout: Images, Video, and HTML Frames, defect, P3)

Description

[dewb]

If you load a frameset that includes a frame with the scrolling=no attribute,
the frames on that page are rendered correctly, but any subsequent pages that
you load don't have scrollbars.

Example:
1. Visit http://CNN.com.  Looks fine.
2. Visit http://funk.mit.edu/~dewb/moztest.  Also looks fine.
3. Visit CNN again.  No scrollbars, can't navigate page.

Comment 1

[leger]

glynn, please check out for a Frames or Rendering problem here.  Thanks!

Comment 2

[karnaze (gone)]

This works on my 3/22 pm WinNT debug build. In viewer, I visited the pages
mentioned. Glynn, can you please determine if this is a problem in an optimized
build.

Comment 3

[glynn]

I visited above URL from home but am unable to do so now....site is not being
found on net, by Seamonkey or 4.51.   Will need to try later but I suspect this
will remain a WFM.

Comment 4

[glynn]

still cannot access above URL.  CNN site works fine, I tried cisiting some of my
frametest pages involving scroll yes, no and auto and returned to cnn and no
problems found.  Verified as WFM til reporter can provide reproducible and
accesible test case.

Comment 5

[glynn]

ok, this was bugging me in the back of my mind so after some more work, I
reproduced this on Mac and Linux using March 23 and another test page, 100%.
Reopening.

March 23 build, optimized apprunner and viewer on Mac and Linux.
Win98 appears to work properly.

1.  Launch Seamonkey and go to this test page:
http://slip/projects/marvin/html/frameset_rows_pixel.html
2.  Note scroll bars are not present.  Now go to another page like
http://www.apple.com

•  Scroll bars are not displayed and only way to get them to come back is to quit
and relaunch the app.  Scrolling is default to auto on test page first visited so
adjusting summary from scrolling=no to general issue of frames and if scrollbars
are present due to page size and content when frameset loads, (not the attribute
specific setting for scrolling)

Comment 6

[Kevin Berkheiser]

*** Bug 4120 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

Comment 7

[sujay]

Hi Beth, assigning a couple of Greg's open bugs to you. Frame related.

Comment 8

[karnaze (gone)]

I fixed this bug last week on WinNT Viewer and it still looks fixed on a 4/12
optimized WinNT Viewer and 4/11 optimized Apprunner. Reassigning to Ramiro,
since it sounds like it might be a Linux only problem.

Comment 9

[ramiro]

Attachment: sample html

Comment 10

[ramiro]

just tried it on unix, looks fine.

marking worksforme.