27.81 KB, text/plain
22.24 KB, text/plain
9.34 KB, text/plain
Imap log(Gmail IMAP). If non-deleted mail exists in the folder("N EXISTS" where N>0 in IDLE/SELECT response), "deleted-by-other" mail disappers.
64.55 KB, text/plain
178.83 KB, text/plain
117.35 KB, text/plain
7.39 KB, patch
|Details | Diff | Splinter Review|
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; U; Intel Mac OS X 10.5; en-US; rv:126.96.36.199) Gecko/2008092414 Firefox/3.0.3 Build Identifier: 3.0b1 pre Using the 11/3 nightly build. Using Web Gmail, delete mail from the inbox. Goto Shredder, the mail is still in the box. If you try to delete again, you get the error: "The current command did not succeed. The mail server responded: No messages match. (Failure).". Same error if you hit send/receive to update the folder. Once you delete the mail, no error messages. Reproducible: Always Steps to Reproduce: 1. 2. 3.
Not seeing problem using on Windows with this build. Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:1.9.1b2pre) Gecko/20081031 Shredder/3.0b1pre Message deleted 1-2 seconds thereafter I delete from web.
I can reproduce the same thing in the Linux installation. Thunderbird 3b2 and nightly build from 23/4/2009. Exactly the same way. 1. Receive mails with TB (inbox) 2. Go to webmail and move messages away from inbox. 3. Go to the inbox and message is still there. TB tries to get the message but never finish. thanks :)
MaTias BarleTTa : could you reproduce while you are logging imap (as described at : https://wiki.mozilla.org/MailNews:Logging ) and attach the imap log to this bug ?
Created attachment 374571 [details] Thunderbird Imap.log I did the process stated before. Same result... attaching the log .. hope it helps..
(In reply to comment #4) > 2. Go to webmail and move messages away from inbox. What is your "move messages away from inbox" operation? "Delete" button of Gmail's Web Interface? Or "Move to" button? (In reply to comment #6) > Thunderbird Imap.log I assume "Delete" button at Gmail Web Interface. What is UID of mail which you expected to disappear from Inbox folder of Tb? (Show "Order Received" column. Value in it is UID of mail if IMAP folder) Where is flow which corresponds to next in the log log file? > 3. Go to the inbox and message is still there. > TB tries to get the message but never finish.
Created attachment 374586 [details] IMAP log (Add Gmail Label then delete the Gmail label, via Gmail Web Interface) (A) Gmail IMAP notifies about delete(remove of Gmail Label) via IDLE, but Tb doesn't care for it. (if notify of new mail, Tb issues fetch) (B) Although Gmail IMAP notifies delete(remove of Gmail Label) of mail via IDLE, (B-1) Gmail IMAP returns OK to uid xxx fetch with no mail data. (B-2) Gmail IMAP returns OK to uid xxx copy Trash, uid xxx store \Deleted. And, nothing is copied to Trash.
Created attachment 374717 [details] IMAP log. Remove of Gmail Lable=>never deleted mails on TB => Add Gmail Label(==new mail arrives) After (A) in Comment #8, (C) Add a Gmail Label(Test-003/A-00 in this case) to a mail at Gmail Web Interface. => New mails is notified via ILDE. * 1 EXISTS DONE => Tb execute re-sync. 31 UID fetch 1:* (FLAGS) * 1 FETCH (UID 8 FLAGS (\Seen)) 31 OK Success => Tb knows "UID=5,6,7, doesn't exist". => 3 mails disappaer.
I think problem of (A) in Comment #8 and (C) in Comment #9 can be said. (1) If delete notification via IDLE is "0 EXISTS", or if select(by initial folder open) response is "0 EXISTS", Tb doesn't issue "fetch N:* (flags)". Then "all mails are alredy deleted by other" situation is not reflected to MailDB and thread pane display. It's not Gmail IMAP particular issue. It can occur on any IMAP server if mail is deleted&expunged by other IMAP client. And I guess one of next. If "fetch N:* (flags)" issued but no response lines(already "no mail in folder" status at Gmail IMAP/Gmail), (2) Tb possibly waits forever even after OK response. (3) Gmail IMAP doesn't return OK, then Tb waits forever. I guess (3), because I saw "never ending folder open" several times and I saw error message of "System Failure" upon folder open after "remove of Gmail Lable at Gmail Web Interface". I think (B) in comment #8 and above is still remainig Gmail IMAP issue of next, which I pointed in Bug 402793 Comment #12. > http://mail.google.com/support/bin/answer.py?answer=96926&topic=12922 > Updates not reflected in multiple clients Confirming my test result of (A) in comment #8 and (C) in comment #9.
Created attachment 374742 [details] Imap log(Gmail IMAP). If non-deleted mail exists in the folder("N EXISTS" where N>0 in IDLE/SELECT response), "deleted-by-other" mail disappers.
(In addition to comment #11) Following is log for "Removal of Gmail Label from mail-1(UID=1)" when UID=1/2/3 exist in folder. In this case, mail of UID=1(mail-1) was removed from thread pane. How Tb determined that UID=1 was deleted from Gmail IMAP response of "* 2 FETCH (UID 3 FLAGS (\Seen))" only? Gmail's response to "33 UID fetch 4:* (FLAGS)" is proper? >  Remove Gmail Lable of Test-003/A-00 from mail-1(UID=1), notifiled via ILDE > => mail-1(UID=1) disappeared > 00000294 * 1 EXPUNGE > 00000296 * 2 EXISTS > 00000297 DONE > 00000299 30 OK IDLE terminated (Success) > 00000312 33 UID fetch 4:* (FLAGS) > 00000314 * 2 FETCH (UID 3 FLAGS (\Seen)) > 00000316 33 OK Success
(In addition to comment #11) Number of n in "* n FETCH (UID 3 FLAGS (\Seen))" seems "Message Sequence Number". > http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc3501#section-188.8.131.52 > 184.108.40.206. Message Sequence Number Message Attribute Possibly following algorithm. (1) "* 2 FETCH (UID 3 FLAGS (\Seen))" to "33 UID fetch 4:* (FLAGS)" => UID=3 == second mail(Message Sequence Number==2) (2) * 1 EXPUNGE / * 2 EXISTS => 1 mail is deleted/expunged (Tb knew 3 mails of UID=1/2/3 existed) (3) By (1) && (2), Tb can know one of UID=1 & UID=2 is deleted/expunged. But how can Tb know deleted/expunged mail is UID=1 instead of UID=2?
(In reply to comment #4) > 3. Go to the inbox (snip) ... . TB tries to get the message but never finish. It's independent/different problem from main issue of this bug(==never removed mail even though deleted/expunged at server). Phenomenon that looks "never ending folder open" is probably problem of bug 490556(see bug 490556 comment #5). MaTias BarleTTa(poster of comment #4), watch that bug, please.
Created attachment 377831 [details] IMAP Log - Marked for deletion, followed by move to separate folder I've also go this problem, using Shredder 3.0b3. Either deleting from Gmail web interface or separate client, or marking as deleted and expunging, emails still stay in the folder they were in. Deletion only updates when an email is moved into that folder (either by new incoming email or being moved in there). Emails delete properly in TB when set to move to Trash rather than simply marking, but if emails are deleted from another client or Gmail web interface this doesn't update. Only seems to happen with Gmail, not with my other IMAP account.
(In reply to comment #15) > IMAP Log - Marked for deletion, followed by move to separate folder As seen in log, Gmail IMAP automatically expunges mail flag as "\Deleted", and returns "* 0 EXISTS" if there is no active mail any more in the folder. > S-INBOX:SendData: 20 uid store 7078 +Flags (\Seen \Deleted) > S-INBOX:CreateNewLineFromSocket: * 1 FETCH (FLAGS (\Seen \Deleted) UID 7078) > S-INBOX:CreateNewLineFromSocket: * 1 EXPUNGE > S-INBOX:CreateNewLineFromSocket: * 0 EXISTS > S-INBOX:CreateNewLineFromSocket: 20 OK Success (Q1) Can you reproduce problem even when active mails exists in folder after "delete/expunge by other IMAP client or Gmail Web"? (Q2) Can you reproduce problem even when "automatic expunge" is disabled by "Advanced IMAP Controls" in Gmail's "Labs"? > Only seems to happen with Gmail, not with my other IMAP account. (Q3) I think you can see phenomenon with your other ordinal IMAP accounts by; (a) Disable IDLE, in order to avoid notification of "* n EXPUNGE" etc. (b) Delete all mails & Expunge by other IMAP client or Web Interface. Is it wrong? 1. Tb knows mails in a folder. Shutdown Tb. 2. Delete all mails in folder & Expunge by other IMAP client or Web Interface. 3. Restart Tb, and click the folder. => * 0 EXISTS, because no mails anymore in the folder.
Shredder beta3pre is working correctly. I no longer have a problem with deleted messages in GMAIL not being removed from thunderbird. thanks!!
(In reply to comment #17) > Shredder beta3pre is working correctly. I no longer have a problem with deleted > messages in GMAIL not being removed from thunderbird. > Dypark @ gmail . com can you confirm that too ?
(In reply to comment #17) > Shredder beta3pre is working correctly. I no longer have a problem with deleted > messages in GMAIL not being removed from thunderbird. MaTias BarleTTa, with which build? Really no problem even when "* 0 EXISTS" response to Tb"(no mail exists in folder any more) after "delete of mails which Tb already knew & expunge by other client(or Web Interface of Web mail)"?
Bug 486477 is opened for ordinal IMAP server. Setting dependency to it, because "* 0 EXISTS" itself is not Gmail particularity.
I still could see problem with Tb trunk 2009/6/21 build. - Delete model: Just mark it as deleted - Shift+Delete of all mail in a folder => All are marked with red cross - These deleted & already expunged mails won't disappear until new mail is copied to the folder(*N EXISTS response where N>0).
Created attachment 401666 [details] log according to https://wiki.mozilla.org/MailNews:Logging I can reproduce this very well with mail.messagingengine.com (the IMAP server of fastmail.fm service). The other email server in this log (mail.corp.redhat.com, which is a Zimbra server) works just fine.
Forgot to add ... this log has been generated with the binary from ftp://ftp.mozilla.org/pub/thunderbird/nightly/3.0b4-candidates/build4/linux-i686/en-US/thunderbird-3.0b4.tar.bz2
Bug 509902 has been closed as a duplicate of this bug, but I am really not sure whether this isn't (or shouldn't be) GMail IMAP specific. I guess their implementation of IMAP is unfortunately quite special to deserve it.
Does this problem also happen with Thunderbird 2?
not blocking, wanted.
This problem does not happen in Thunderbird 2 as far as to the version before the official 3.0 one.
Created attachment 421692 [details] [diff] [review] proposed fix this will fix the problem. now to attempt a unit test.
Created attachment 421702 [details] [diff] [review] fix with unit test
forgot to mention, this cleans up a couple things in the test_flagChanges test as well, which I cloned this test from...Neil, if you don't want to review the test, you can leave that for standard8's sr.
Comment on attachment 421702 [details] [diff] [review] fix with unit test I take it this only affects CONDSTORE servers, as otherwise the flag state is never partial?
(In reply to comment #34) > (From update of attachment 421702 [details] [diff] [review]) > I take it this only affects CONDSTORE servers, as otherwise the flag state is > never partial? No, sadly, both kinds of servers are affected. The issue is that ResetFlagInfo sets the flag state to partial, because that's a safer assumption in general, at least for condstore servers. But in this case, we're resetting the flag info because we know there are zero messages, but because we know there are zero messages, we need to clear the partial flag.
also TB 3.0.1 suffers from this bug. I can reproduce it on gmail and also dovecot imap server. steps: 1. sent mail to an account. 2. mail appears in Inbox folder. 3. Close TB. 4. delete mail from other client (TB, web ui gmail). 5. start TB, and already deleted mail still seen in Inbox. important settings TB settings: account setting: synchronization of messages -> leave messages from account on this computer !OFF! global setting: global search and indexing: !DISABLED! this is only one serious bug which I find on new 3.0 TB release.
(In reply to comment #37) > also TB 3.0.1 suffers from this bug. Yes, this bug has not been fixed yet. The patch is waiting for review. It will be fixed in nightly trunk builds soon, and in 3.02.
ping on the sr - we've had several dupes of this...
fixed on trunk and 3.0x branch
I'm seeing this symptom as of a couple weeks ago -- haven't seen *0 EXISTS (don't know where to look), but deleting email from my Android phone does not result in the e-mail disappearing from my Thunderbird inbox. TB 24.1.0 Win7, IMAP to Gmail. I haven't noticed whether it's always or sometimes. Using Get Mail / Get All New Messages button does nothing.
(In reply to Tom Guyette from comment #45) > I'm seeing this symptom as of a couple weeks ago -- haven't seen *0 EXISTS > (don't know where to look), but deleting email from my Android phone does > not result in the e-mail disappearing from my Thunderbird inbox. TB 24.1.0 > Win7, IMAP to Gmail. I haven't noticed whether it's always or sometimes. > Using Get Mail / Get All New Messages button does nothing. Tom, If you can still reproduce in version 31 beta, please file a new bug if there is not a bug already covering this issue. beta at http://www.mozilla.org/en-US/thunderbird/channel/