46605 - lower frame not loaded at mp3.com.hk (absolute/relative path?)

Status: VERIFIED DUPLICATE of bug 43464

(Core :: Layout: Images, Video, and HTML Frames, defect, P3)

Description

[namos]

From Bugzilla Helper:
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; U; SunOS 5.8 sun4u; en-US; m17) Gecko/20000725
BuildID:    2000072522

the lower frame at mp3.com.hk is not loaded.  the frameset loads the upper frame
as an absolute path (/top.shtml), the lower frame as relative (home.shtml).

Reproducible: Always
Steps to Reproduce:
1.go to http://mp3.com.hk
2.notice the lower frame does not show, clicking links referencing that frame
creates a new window

Comment 1

[jlarsen]

Ok the way they did their frameset is all messed up. It highly bothers me that 
it even works in the first place, if you will send them the following code to 
replace it.
<FRAMESET ROWS="108,*" FRAMEBORDER=NO FRAMESPACING=0 FRAMEPADDING=0 BORDER="0">
                
                        <FRAME SRC="top.shtml" NAME="header"
                        MARGINHEIGHT=0
                        MARGINWIDTH=0 
                        SCROLLING=NO 
                        NORESIZE>
                        <FRAME SRC="home.shtml" 
                        NAME="body" 
                        MARGINHEIGHT=0 
                        MARGINWIDTH=0 
                        SCROLLING=AUTO 
                        NORESIZE>
        </FRAMESET>

I'm not quite sure how perfect that code is either (I just took their code and 
sliced it back together) But it works right, and follows the basic specs.

Anyhow.. marking as wontfix. If you disagree, feel free to reopen.

Comment 2

[jlarsen]

Got the following e-mail from [e-mail]
"john,
i agree that it's all messed up, but all the other browsers load it
properly.  i just don't want this to turn into another reason for people
to not use mozilla.  i'm sure there are countless other imperfections and
bending the standards we've been forced into overlooking and working with
anyways.  what if pages without </html> refused to show?  we're not trying
to change the world, just making a good product.  and i'm of the opinion
that if it already works in other browsers, it's a bit too late to change.
if this has convinced you to share my opinion, pls re-open.  if not, i ask
that you share this with others and get their opinion too.
thanks!"

While I don't nessesarly agree with him I agree that I should get other 
opinions. leaving closed for now.

Comment 3

[jlarsen]

Reopening as to Asa's comments. Marking 4xp for navquirks. Fun fun fun. Going to 
attach a testcase so we have a backup of this bug incase mp3.com.hk fixes their 
page, which they still should do honestly.

Comment 4

[jlarsen]

Attachment: testcase

Comment 5

[jlarsen]

opps forgot to confirm :)

Comment 6

[Eric Pollmann]

Is this a cut and paste?  ;)

This bug is already reported (and marked future) as bug 43464.

*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of 43464 ***

Comment 7

[Chris Petersen]

Marking verified dup of 43464.