Closed Bug 527559 Opened 16 years ago Closed 14 years ago

Crash [@ npCoralIETab.dll@0x202e1 ]

Categories

(Firefox :: Extension Compatibility, defect)

Product:
Firefox
Component:
Extension Compatibility
Version:
3.6 Branch
Platform:
x86
Windows XP
Type:
defect
Priority:
Not set
Severity:
critical

Tracking

()

Status:
RESOLVED WORKSFORME

People

(Reporter: cbook, Unassigned)

Details

(Keywords: crash, topcrash, Whiteboard: [crashkill])

Crash Data

currently crash #24 on the TopCrashList for Firefox 3.6 Beta 1 http://crash-stats.mozilla.com/report/list?product=Firefox&version=Firefox%3A3.6b1&query_search=signature&query_type=exact&query=&date=&range_value=1&range_unit=weeks&do_query=1&signature=npCoralIETab.dll%400x202e1 not sure if this is malware or belong to ietab in general, but will find out :)
Flags: blocking-firefox3.6?
Whiteboard: [crashkill]
That Add-on has a total number of downloads of 300k users, which makes me suspect why it's in our topcrash lits. We should get it put back in the sandbox and tell the author
Flags: blocking-firefox3.6? → blocking-firefox3.6-
The Add-on in question is https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/10909 Jorge: can we get its compatibility marked down to not include 3.6 and contact the author?
getting https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/10909 back in the sandbox might reduce the crashes but not eliminate. is the "Works with Firefox: 3.0 – 3.7a1pre" just too aggressive, and needs to be dialed back to 3.0.x? This signature is almost invisible on 3.0.15. distribution of all versions where the npCoralIETab.dll@0x202e1 crash was found on 20091109-crashdata.csv 81 Firefox 3.5.5 79 Firefox 3.6b1 7 Firefox 3.5.4 6 Firefox 3.5.3 5 Firefox 3.7a1pre 4 Firefox 3.6b2pre 3 Firefox 3.5 2 Firefox 3.0.15 1 Firefox 3.6b3pre 1 Firefox 3.6b2 1 Firefox 3.5.2
How old are the crashes? Can we identify which version of the add-on began causing these?
correlations to version numbers are here. http://people.mozilla.com/crash_analysis/20091110/20091110_Firefox_3.5.5-interesting-addons-with-versions.txt.gz that says its 100% (82/82) vs. 0% (269/83529) version -- 1.60.20090901 --- npCoralIETab.dll@0x202e1|EXCEPTION_ACCESS_VIOLATION (82 crashes) 100% (82/82) vs. 0% (279/83529) ietab@ip.cn (Coral IE Tab, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/10909) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (2/83529) 1.00.20090531 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 1.11.20090717 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 1.50.20090807 100% (82/82) vs. 0% (269/83529) 1.60.20090901 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (2/83529) 1.61.20091007 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (4/83529) 1.63.20091024 but there are lots of other addons installed in the crash report data for this crash as well. a closer look a this data might be helpful too. 35% (29/82) vs. 10% (8289/83529) {d10d0bf8-f5b5-c8b4-a8b2-2b9879e08c5d} (Adblock Plus, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/1865) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 0.7.5.1 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (3/83529) 0.7.5.5 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 1.0 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (39/83529) 1.0.1 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (117/83529) 1.0.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (143/83529) 1.1 35% (29/82) vs. 10% (7984/83529) 1.1.1 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 1.1.1+.2009110507 17% (14/82) vs. 3% (2852/83529) {D4DD63FA-01E4-46a7-B6B1-EDAB7D6AD389} (Download Statusbar, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/26) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (17/83529) 0.9.6.4 17% (14/82) vs. 3% (2835/83529) 0.9.6.5 15% (12/82) vs. 1% (1157/83529) {dc572301-7619-498c-a57d-39143191b318} (Tab Mix Plus, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/1122) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 0.3.6.1.080416 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (3/83529) 0.3.7.3 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (3/83529) 0.3.7.4pre.090404 2% (2/82) vs. 0% (107/83529) 0.3.7.4pre.090516 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (12/83529) 0.3.7.4pre.090726 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 0.3.8 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (57/83529) 0.3.8.1 12% (10/82) vs. 1% (928/83529) 0.3.8.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (3/83529) 0.3.8.2pre.090802 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 0.3.8.2pre.090808 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (2/83529) 0.3.8.2pre.090919 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (39/83529) 0.3.8.2pre.091012 15% (12/82) vs. 2% (1915/83529) foxmarks@kei.com (Xmarks (formerly Foxmarks), https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/2410) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 2.6.0 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 2.7.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 3.0.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (43/83529) 3.1.0 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (5/83529) 3.1.1 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (3/83529) 3.2.6 12% (10/82) vs. 2% (1503/83529) 3.3.2 2% (2/82) vs. 0% (358/83529) 3.3.3 15% (12/82) vs. 3% (2126/83529) {19503e42-ca3c-4c27-b1e2-9cdb2170ee34} (FlashGot, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/220) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 1.1.8 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 1.1.8.5 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (9/83529) 1.1.8.6 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (2/83529) 1.1.8.7 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (14/83529) 1.1.9 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (6/83529) 1.1.9.4 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (11/83529) 1.1.9.6 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (41/83529) 1.1.9.8 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (49/83529) 1.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (35/83529) 1.2.0.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (21/83529) 1.2.0.3 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (73/83529) 1.2.0.4 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (134/83529) 1.2.0.6 7% (6/82) vs. 1% (1120/83529) 1.2.0.7 7% (6/82) vs. 1% (609/83529) 1.2.0.8 18% (15/82) vs. 7% (5639/83529) {b9db16a4-6edc-47ec-a1f4-b86292ed211d} (Video DownloadHelper, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/3006) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 3.3 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 3.5.1 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 4.0.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (14/83529) 4.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (24/83529) 4.3 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (9/83529) 4.4 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (30/83529) 4.4.1 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (32/83529) 4.5 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (114/83529) 4.6 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (32/83529) 4.6.1 0% (0/82) vs. 1% (425/83529) 4.6.2 18% (15/82) vs. 6% (4956/83529) 4.6.4 11% (9/82) vs. 0% (189/83529) {21cfaec0-dbb3-11dc-95ff-0800200c9a66} (Easy DragToGo, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/6639) (1.1.2.4) 15% (12/82) vs. 7% (5966/83529) {3112ca9c-de6d-4884-a869-9855de68056c} (Google Toolbar, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/6249) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 2.1.20060719W 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (5/83529) 3.0.20070525W 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 3.1.20080605W 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (14/83529) 3.1.20080730W 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (2/83529) 3.1.20081010W 1% (1/82) vs. 2% (1842/83529) 3.1.20081127W 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (191/83529) 3.1.20090119W 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 5.0.20080919Wb1 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (142/83529) 5.0.20090122Wb2 1% (1/82) vs. 0% (228/83529) 5.0.20090324 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (338/83529) 5.0.20090324W 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (10/83529) 5.0.20090805W 7% (6/82) vs. 3% (2147/83529) 5.0.20090813W 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (206/83529) 6.1.20090917Wb1 5% (4/82) vs. 1% (599/83529) 6.1.20091007W 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (235/83529) 6.1.20091019W 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (4/83529) 6.1.20091020W 50% (41/82) vs. 43% (35819/83529) {20a82645-c095-46ed-80e3-08825760534b} (Microsoft .NET Framework Assistant, http://www.windowsclient.net/) 6% (5/82) vs. 4% (3270/83529) 0.0.0 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (33/83529) 1.0 44% (36/82) vs. 39% (32516/83529) 1.1 9% (7/82) vs. 2% (1409/83529) {ef4e370e-d9f0-4e00-b93e-a4f274cfdd5a} (FoxTab, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/8879) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (14/83529) 1.1.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (35/83529) 1.2 9% (7/82) vs. 2% (1360/83529) 1.2.1 10% (8/82) vs. 4% (2955/83529) personas@christopher.beard (Personas, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/10900) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (27/83529) 1.0 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (18/83529) 1.1 4% (3/82) vs. 0% (196/83529) 1.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (42/83529) 1.2.1 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (96/83529) 1.2.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (58/83529) 1.2.3 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (65/83529) 1.2.4 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (268/83529) 1.3 6% (5/82) vs. 3% (2185/83529) 1.3.1 7% (6/82) vs. 1% (1124/83529) smarterwiki@wikiatic.com (FastestFox - Browse Faster, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/9825) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 1.3.9 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (3/83529) 1.3.9.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (4/83529) 2.0.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (24/83529) 2.1.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (106/83529) 2.1.4 7% (6/82) vs. 1% (986/83529) 3.0.0 6% (5/82) vs. 0% (145/83529) {22870005-adef-4c9d-ae36-d0e1f2f27e5a} (新同文堂 (New Tong Wen Tang), https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/6113) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 0.3.9 6% (5/82) vs. 0% (144/83529) 0.3.9.8.3 6% (5/82) vs. 0% (264/83529) {1B33E42F-EF14-4cd3-B6DC-174571C4349C} (3.5) 6% (5/82) vs. 0% (358/83529) chromifox@altmusictv.com (Chromifox Basic, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/8782) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (4/83529) 1.1.1 6% (5/82) vs. 0% (350/83529) 1.1.3 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (4/83529) 1.1b4 6% (5/82) vs. 0% (406/83529) {53A03D43-5363-4669-8190-99061B2DEBA5} (ScrapBook, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/427) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (3/83529) 1.3.3.11 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (2/83529) 1.3.3.12 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (2/83529) 1.3.3.13 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (4/83529) 1.3.3.14 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (7/83529) 1.3.4 6% (5/82) vs. 0% (388/83529) 1.3.5 6% (5/82) vs. 1% (564/83529) firegestures@xuldev.org (FireGestures, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/6366) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 1.1.6 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 1.5 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (18/83529) 1.5.1 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (60/83529) 1.5.4 6% (5/82) vs. 1% (484/83529) 1.5.5.1 6% (5/82) vs. 1% (623/83529) {097d3191-e6fa-4728-9826-b533d755359d} (All-in-One Sidebar, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/1027) 6% (5/82) vs. 1% (621/83529) 0.7.10 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (2/83529) 0.7.6 6% (5/82) vs. 1% (692/83529) {3d7eb24f-2740-49df-8937-200b1cc08f8a} (Flashblock, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/433) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (5/83529) 1.5.10 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 1.5.11.1 6% (5/82) vs. 1% (682/83529) 1.5.11.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 1.5.12a2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 1.5.6 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 1.5.8 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 1.5.9 6% (5/82) vs. 1% (707/83529) {9f08cb5a-76b1-4bcf-aff9-90e1a5d60b1e} (Noia 2.0 (eXtreme), https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/72) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (5/83529) 3.64 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (10/83529) 3.65 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (23/83529) 3.66 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (20/83529) 3.68 6% (5/82) vs. 1% (649/83529) 3.69 9% (7/82) vs. 4% (2937/83529) {e4a8a97b-f2ed-450b-b12d-ee082ba24781} (Greasemonkey, https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/748) 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 0.7.20080121.0 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (2/83529) 0.8.20080609.0 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (283/83529) 0.8.20090123.1 9% (7/82) vs. 3% (2650/83529) 0.8.20090920.2 0% (0/82) vs. 0% (1/83529) 0.9.20090701.0
I sandboxed version 1.60.20090901, which seems to be the most likely offender. I have contacted the author with a link to this bug. Let's wait a little and see if he responds.
An update to the add-on has been pushed to the public (v1.63.20091024). Let me know if this is still causing this problem.
Summary: Crash [@npCoralIETab.dll@0x202e1 ] → Crash [@ npCoralIETab.dll@0x202e1 ]
FWIW: I'm using Coral IE Tab v1.63.20091024 on Fx 3.6 final. I have been using it since Fx 3.6 RC 1. So far no crashes from Coral.
Coral IE Tab's current version is 1.80.20100224. Well past 1.60.x and 1.63.x. 1.81.20100304 for the self-hosted version - https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/52809
Crash Signature: [@ npCoralIETab.dll@0x202e1 ]
I don't see this signature anymore. Resolving as works for me. Probably got resolved with some plugin update.
Status: NEW → RESOLVED
Closed: 14 years ago
Resolution: --- → WORKSFORME
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.