User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.2; en-US; rv:1.9.2) Gecko/20100115 Firefox/3.6 Build Identifier: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.2; en-US; rv:1.9.2) Gecko/20100115 Firefox/3.6 If I right click an image and save it to disk, under windows the SERVER date is put into the date modified field, but under linux the PC date is put into date modified field. ALL other browser including firefox3.6 put the PC date into the date modified field on the PC. This only happens on the WINDOWS build and is OK on the linux build Reproducible: Always Steps to Reproduce: 1.right click and save an image 2.check the modified date and its WRONG, it's the server date instead of the PC 3. Actual Results: 1.right click and save an image 2.check the modified date and its WRONG, it's the server date instead of the PC Expected Results: 1.right click and save an image 2.check the modified date and it should be the PC's local time and date and NOT the servers date this always used to be the case until the last few builds of minefield. This is OK under linux but under windows the server date get put into the modified date field unstead of the PC's local time/date.
I thought it was just me setting something wrong, I too have this problem. In windows XP SP3.
The behavior change is now correct in Windows and it is now the way FTP software has always worked when downloading files from the internet or moving/copying files around on the OS. So the change that was put into to place to make it correctly use the same behavior as the OS and FTP software which has been around longer than browsers. Browsers have always gotten the copy/move download behavior wrong, even if we don't like it that way :) FWIW, I heard that someone could make an extension for firefox to change the behavior back to the incorrect browser behavior we've had for years. I believe it is because when you download, your actually creating a copy of the original server file, not modifying it.
This is not a bug as the behaviour was changed (as Dale pointed out) here: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=178506 The platform should be linux - if the modification time/date bug really does reside there at all - not Windows.
Ok Thanks for that, then the Linux version is wrong, although people running linux in the mozillazine said it was correct so I just assumed that the windows version was broke and not the linux version, as EVERY other browser also acts the same as the linux version of mozilla. I REALLY hope that somebody write an extension then as I would like to continue to do things the same way I have for the past 15+ years.
I too would like to go back to the way other browsers do things, as firefox or minefield is a browser with built in ftp and not a dedicated ftp client. I use firefox 3.6 also with minefield and firefox also saves differently to minefield. So does that mean that firefox is broke and if so is it too going to get fixed. I too run XP service pack 3 and would like to arrange my files like i have all my computing life by arranging my document by date modified and not having to go searching through my documents for a file that has just been downloaded. I agree with steve in the hope that some bright spark write an addon to bring it inline with other browsers.
Can't you just do a sort on date created instead of modified?
Non-windows systems (i.e. Linux, and AFAIK Max OSX) don't support file creation date. They only support accessed and modified dates. IMHO preserving the file metadata from the server is the correct thing to do, but I think that it should be optional (enabled by default) as it does change a long-standing behavior. (In reply to comment #4) > Ok Thanks for that, then the Linux version is wrong, although people running > linux in the mozillazine said it was correct In the context of Bug 178506, Linux is functioning correctly. It is preserving the modified date from the server. This is the intended behavior.
If you look at this picture http://i49.tinypic.com/1zdaxyt.jpg Obviosly LINUX or WINDOWS build is WRONG, as they both do something DIFFERENT.
they BOTH can't be OK if they BOTH builds are saving the SAME file with DIFFERENT dates.
http://files.bluefang-logic.com/images/ff_mod_date.png I ran a test. There is a 3 hour difference, but I think that is just the differences in timezone between my computer (EST) and the server (probably PST). So it looks correct to me.
NO, this works OK for FILES downloaded, it's when you right click and image and select SAVE IMAGE, like I said in the bug report to reproduce you load and image and then right click it and save it. On windows it gets the server time/date on the linux build it get the local time, just like in this picture. http://i49.tinypic.com/1zdaxyt.jpg Thats Linux, IE, and minefield in that order. As Far as I know saving files is correct on both builds as I use a download manager for files.
Ok, I did some more tests. Top row is right-click -> save image as on the previous image I posted Bottom row is right-click -> save image as on the text logo (top-left) from MozillaZine Forums Left is Minefield on Linux Center is Minefield on Win7 RC1 Right is IE8 on Win7 RC1 http://files.bluefang-logic.com/images/ff_mod_date_2.png Comments: - IE8 is using the system time - Minefield times match on my image. They are off by 1 hour on the MozillaZine logo image. Don't really have an explanation for the discrepancy, but it seems like a minor bug.
There are two other bugs open, one for the download manager code and one deeper than that. One is an edge case, the other is off by an hour I think.
(In reply to comment #12) > Ok, I did some more tests. > > Top row is right-click -> save image as on the previous image I posted > Bottom row is right-click -> save image as on the text logo (top-left) from > MozillaZine Forums > > Left is Minefield on Linux > Center is Minefield on Win7 RC1 > Right is IE8 on Win7 RC1 > > http://files.bluefang-logic.com/images/ff_mod_date_2.png > > Comments: > - IE8 is using the system time > > - Minefield times match on my image. They are off by 1 hour on the MozillaZine > logo image. Don't really have an explanation for the discrepancy, but it seems > like a minor bug. as you can see on your ENTIRE top row the date modified for all programs the modified date is indeed you PC's clock.
(In reply to comment #4) > > I REALLY hope that somebody write an extension then as I would like to continue > to do things the same way I have for the past 15+ years. see https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/93121/
This should be resolved INVALID by Bug 178506