56715 - wrong frames are loaded with 2 different framesets

Status: VERIFIED DUPLICATE of bug 53708

(Core :: Layout: Images, Video, and HTML Frames, defect, P3)

Description

[arador]

From Bugzilla Helper:
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; U; Linux 2.2.17 i686; en-US; m18) Gecko/20001010
BuildID:    2000101015

this site has a basic frameset with a naviagtion frame (top) and the content
frame. the content frame displays two other framesets if you go to "Fotoalbum"
and "Gaestebuch". the first framesets one selects shows the correct frame
sources but afterwards the other one loads the same sources, which is not correct
the source html (see below) surely is not 100% correct, but IE 4.x (win98), NS
4.x(win98 / linux)  and Opera 4.01 (linux) display it correctly

Reproducible: Always
Steps to Reproduce:
go to http://home.nordwest.net/abi98
select either "Fotoalbum" or "Gaestebuch"
mozilla loads the frameset correctly
afterwards, select the other frameset.


Actual Results:  mozilla loads the new frameset with correct spacing but with
the src's from the other frameset.

Expected Results:  mozilla should have loaded the correct src's (obviously <g>)

the only way to load the correct src's that i found is to delete the cache an
reload the complete site. after that, the first frame selected is displayed
correctly, the following are wrong again

as I am the author of that page, here the html structure:

the homepage (/index.html) loads the base frameset:
---/---
<FRAMESET rows="70px,*" border="0">
	<FRAME src="top.html" name="left" scrolling="no" noresize frameborder="0">
	<FRAME src="abi98.html" name="right" frameborder="0">
	<noframes>
			<p>bla bla</p>
	</noframes>
</FRAMESET>
---/---

the links of the navigation bar to the frames are the following:
---/---
<a href="gaeste/index.html" target="right">
<img src="abipic/buttons/guest-inactive.gif" border="0" alt="G&auml;stebuch"></a>

<a href="foto.html" target="right">
<img src="abipic/buttons/foto-inactive.gif" border="0" alt="Fotoalbum"></a>

---/---
(note: loads of onMouseXX deleted)

the linked pages are the following framesets:
(note: headers stripped)

gaeste/index.html:
---/---

<FRAMESET cols="130px,*" border="0">
	<FRAME src="links.html" name="glinks" noresize scrolling="no" frameborder="0">
	<FRAME src="http://gaeste3.parsimony.net/gaeste17457/" name="grechts" noresize
frameborder="0">
</FRAMESET>

---/---

foto.html:
---/---
<FRAMESET cols="165px,*" border="0">
	<FRAME src="fotolinks.html" name="flinks" noresize scrolling="no">
	<FRAME src="fotoseite.html" name="frechts" noresize>
</FRAMESET>
---/---


Ok, the html is not 100% valid, but I don't see why mozilla act's this
way. I tested the page with MS IE 4.x, NS 4.x and Opera 4.01 - it
works fine...

Comment 1

[Eric Pollmann]

This bug is reported as bug 53708.  I checked in a fix to both the branch and
trunk builds on 10/12, so it did not show up in your build, but is in daily
builds after 10/12.

*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of 53708 ***

Comment 2

[Scott Brodmerkle]

Verified dupe.