7508 - Reply to All doesn't build correct list of recipients

Status: VERIFIED FIXED

(MailNews Core :: Backend, defect, P3)

Description

[laurel]

Using 1999060208 NT 4.0
Using 1999060209 Mac OS 8.51
Can't get to my unix build due to another bug

The Reply to All command doesn't build a correct list of mail recipients (I'm
not trying with any newsgroups yet, just mail recipients).  The sender
consistently doesn't get included in the reply addressee list and if the
original message had several to: recipients, many times that list will be
truncated.

1.  Send a message from another user (I used 4.51) to seamonkey user.
    This message has just one recipient, no cc: or bcc: recipients.
2.  From seamonkey, launch messenger, get messages and select message sent.
3.  Message|Reply to All.
Result:  Compose window opens with the seamonkey user (original recipient)
listed as reply recipient -- sender isn't shown.

1.  Send a message from another user (I used 4.51) to seamonkey user and several
other to: recipients.
    This message has no cc: or bcc: recipients.
2.  From seamonkey, launch messenger, get messages and select message sent.
3.  Message|Reply to All.
Result:  Compose window opens with the addressee list showing an incomplete set
of the original recipients. If you use only a couple recipients, it appears okay
except for the omission of sender as noted in the first scenario.

Comment 1

[laurel]

How come this isn't M7 TFV when bug #7575 is?  That's really a duplicate of
this.

Comment 2

[Jean-Francois Ducarroz]

I found the problem id the database, david bienvenu has the fix...

Comment 3

[Jean-Francois Ducarroz]

Fix and checked kin.

Comment 4

[laurel]

This looks to be working OK using jun19 m7 builds on Mac OS 8.51, NT 4.0 and
Linux rh5.2.
I noticed a couple odd cases, but will research them more and log as separate
issue(s).