80815 - Reloading an IMAP attachment on browser window causes crash

Status: VERIFIED WORKSFORME

(SeaMonkey :: MailNews: Message Display, defect)

Description

[ji]

*****Observed with linux and win32 05/14 trunk build*****

After an IMAP attachment is opened on a browser window, selecting charset menu 
on that window causes a crash.

Steps to reproduce:
1. Launch Mail.
2. Send yourself a mail with an attachment, it doesn't matter it's ASCII 
attachment or non-ASCII attachment.
3. After the mail is received, clicking on the attachment from the envelope to 
open it on the browser window.
4. On the browser windor for that attachment, select Edit | Character Encoding.. 
| <any encoding, like Wester (ISO-8859-1)
The browser crashes.

Comment 1

[nhottanscp]

There is a bug 72012 - IMAP: Charset menu on browser is not working when opening
an attachment from envelope
So this is not working but I have not seen it crashes.

Comment 2

[ji]

Selecting View | Reload on that window causes crash as well. Will attach the 
call stack later when talkback server is accessible.

Comment 3

[marina]

i have comments on my bug report ( bug # 80804) about changing encoding crash, 
if the stack is the same then it is a dup

Comment 4

[ji]

Naoki, does selecting charset menu reload the attachment now? ( it didn't reload 
before, so we have bug 72012, right?)

Comment 5

[ji]

The call stack is same as bug 80804.

*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of 80804 ***

Comment 6

[ji]

Verified as such.

Comment 7

[nhottanscp]

Reopen, because this is a generic problem which bug 80804 is non ASCII specific.
I think bug 80804 is caused by this since charset menu change causes a reload.

Comment 8

[ji]

Below is the call stack: (It's different with the one for bug 80804. Please
ignore my previous comments on 2001-05-14 16:16, I looked into a different
incident):


 Call Stack:    (Signature = docshell.dll + 0xa144 (0x6012a144) 0456c152) 
   docshell.dll + 0xa144 (0x6012a144) 
   docshell.dll + 0x9dfe (0x60129dfe) 
   docshell.dll + 0xba59 (0x6012ba59) 
   docshell.dll + 0x509b (0x6012509b) 
   shistory.dll + 0x28ab (0x609528ab) 
   shistory.dll + 0x255c (0x6095255c) 
   xpcom.dll + 0x2c5c1 (0x60e7c5c1) 
   xpc3250.dll + 0xfd7a (0x60b7fd7a) 
   xpc3250.dll + 0x12e28 (0x60b82e28) 
   js3250.dll + 0x181f0 (0x60c881f0) 
   js3250.dll + 0x1cf68 (0x60c8cf68) 
   js3250.dll + 0x1822e (0x60c8822e) 
   js3250.dll + 0x184b5 (0x60c884b5) 
   js3250.dll + 0x475a (0x60c7475a) 
   jsdom.dll + 0x3184 (0x60543184) 
   jsdom.dll + 0x15b14 (0x60555b14) 
   gkcontent.dll + 0xb6aaa (0x60296aaa) 
   gkcontent.dll + 0xb7aee (0x60297aee) 
   gkcontent.dll + 0xe00d8 (0x602c00d8) 
   gklayout.dll + 0x1fe0d (0x6032fe0d) 
   gklayout.dll + 0x75591 (0x60385591) 
   gklayout.dll + 0x736c1 (0x603836c1) 
   gklayout.dll + 0x1fd83 (0x6032fd83) 
   gklayout.dll + 0x1fbd0 (0x6032fbd0) 
   gkview.dll + 0x143a (0x6045143a) 
   gkview.dll + 0x13fb (0x604513fb) 
   gkview.dll + 0x13fb (0x604513fb) 
   gkview.dll + 0x13fb (0x604513fb) 
   gkview.dll + 0x72b7 (0x604572b7) 
   gkview.dll + 0x1d64 (0x60451d64) 
   gkwidget.dll + 0x524a (0x60c2524a) 
   gkwidget.dll + 0x7ec3 (0x60c27ec3) 
   gkwidget.dll + 0x8292 (0x60c28292) 
   gkwidget.dll + 0x56db (0x60c256db) 
   USER32.dll + 0x1186 (0x77e41186)

Comment 9

[Jaime Rodriguez, Jr.]

Marking as nsbeta1. We should review this crasher before we release.

Comment 10

[ji]

Retested with 05/21 trunk builds. It doesn't crash anymore on all the three 
platforms. Resolved it as wfm.

Comment 11

[fenella]

Linux(2001-06-20-08 trunk)
Mac (2001-06-20-08 trunk)
Win32 (2001-06-20-06 trunk)
Fixed.