Closed Bug 85048 Opened 24 years ago Closed 24 years ago

[osx]While URL popupmenu is displayed, attempting to quit(Command-Q) will cause a crash

Categories

(SeaMonkey :: Location Bar, defect, P2)

Product:
SeaMonkey
Component:
Location Bar
Platform:
PowerPC
macOS
Type:
defect

Tracking

(Not tracked)

Status:
VERIFIED FIXED
Milestone:
mozilla0.9.6

People

(Reporter: chrispetersen, Assigned: paulkchen)

Details

(Keywords: crash, platform-parity)

Build : 5/30 Platform: Mac OS X Expected results: When url popup menu has focus, quitting the application should not function. What I got: Application will crash while quiting. Steps to reproduce: 1) Launch App 2) Open the url popup menu by clicking on url arrow icon. 3) While popup is displayed, press command-Q keys. 4) Application attempts to quit but a crash occurs. 5) Notice when the application is quiting , the browser window is closed but not the popup menu.
Here's a stack trace from crashreporter: Date/Time: 2001-06-10 10:38:07 -0700 PID: 248 Command: Mozilla Exception: EXC_BAD_ACCESS (0x0001) Codes: KERN_PROTECTION_FAILURE (0x0002) at 0x00000000 Thread 0: #0 0x01fb4708 in ActivateMenu__11nsMenuFrameFi () #1 0x01fb46fc in ActivateMenu__11nsMenuFrameFi () #2 0x01fb1bb0 in HideChain__16nsMenuPopupFrameFv () #3 0x01fd1ce8 in Rollup__23nsMenuDismissalListenerFv () #4 0x014a1204 in Destroy__8nsWindowFv () #5 0x021b81ac in __dt__6nsViewFv () #6 0x021b85e4 in Destroy__6nsViewFv () #7 0x01e9bdd4 in Destroy__7nsFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #8 0x01e9920c in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #9 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #10 0x01fb265c in Destroy__16nsMenuPopupFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #11 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #12 0x01fb3890 in Destroy__11nsMenuFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #13 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #14 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #15 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #16 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #17 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #18 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #19 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #20 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #21 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #22 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #23 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #24 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #25 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #26 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #27 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #28 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #29 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #30 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #31 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #32 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #33 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #34 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #35 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #36 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #37 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #38 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #39 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #40 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #41 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #42 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #43 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #44 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #45 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #46 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #47 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #48 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #49 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #50 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #51 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #52 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #53 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #54 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #55 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #56 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #57 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #58 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #59 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #60 0x01f98418 in Destroy__10nsBoxFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #61 0x01f92f9c in DestroyFrames__11nsFrameListFP14nsIPresContext () #62 0x01e991fc in Destroy__16nsContainerFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #63 0x01f69e18 in Destroy__13ViewportFrameFP14nsIPresContext () #64 0x01fc0b5c in Destroy__12FrameManagerFv () #65 0x01eae6f8 in __dt__9PresShellFv () #66 0x01eadfe0 in Release__9PresShellFv () #67 0x001482e4 in __dt__13nsCOMPtr_baseFv () #68 0x01978e5c in __dt__18DocumentViewerImplFv () #69 0x01978864 in Release__18DocumentViewerImplFv () #70 0x0014838c in assign_with_AddRef__13nsCOMPtr_baseFP11nsISupports () #71 0x017655c0 in __as__28nsCOMPtr<16nsIContentViewer>FP16nsIContentViewer () #72 0x0176500c in Destroy__10nsDocShellFv () #73 0x01785ec0 in Destroy__10nsWebShellFv () #74 0x01489dcc in Destroy__11nsXULWindowFv () #75 0x0147952c in Destroy__16nsWebShellWindowFv () #76 0x014846a8 in Destroy__17nsChromeTreeOwnerFv () #77 0x01c9899c in ReallyCloseWindow__16GlobalWindowImplFv () #78 0x01c988c0 in Close__16GlobalWindowImplFv () #79 0x0147c3c0 in Quit__17nsAppShellServiceFv () #80 0x00095620 in Quit__16nsMacCommandLineF8TAskSave () #81 0x0009e380 in HandleQuit__18AEApplicationClassFP6AEDescPC6AEDescP6AEDesc () #82 0x000a26dc in DispatchEvent__14AEGenericClassFP6AEDescPC6AEDescP6AEDesc () #83 0x0009bf7c in DispatchEvent__17AEDispatchHandlerFP6AEDescPC6AEDescP6AEDesc () #84 0x0009a784 in HandleRequiredSuiteEvent__11AECoreClassFPC6AEDescP6AEDesc () #85 0x0009ad04 in RequiredSuiteHandler__11AECoreClassFPC6AEDescP6AEDescUl () #86 0x73f2452c in _InvokeAEEventHandlerUPP () #87 0x73f24744 in _TryEventTable () #88 0x73f24578 in _AEMDispatcher () #89 0x73f2452c in _InvokeAEEventHandlerUPP () #90 0x73f241c0 in _aeResumeTheCurrentEvent () #91 0x73f25cb8 in _aeSend () #92 0x7389324c in _AESend () #93 0x73a54604 in _SendAEToSelf () #94 0x737eb820 in _HandleCompatibilityCommandEvent () #95 0x737e443c in _CompatibilityEventHandler () #96 0x737e13c0 in _InvokeEventHandlerUPP () #97 0x737e1100 in _DispatchEventToHandlers () #98 0x737e0da4 in _SendEventToEventTargetInternal () #99 0x737e0cc4 in _SendEventToEventTarget () #100 0x737eb348 in _SendHICommandEvent () #101 0x73a276d0 in _ProcessHICommandWithModifiers () #102 0x73a5a3b0 in _SendMenuItemSelectedEvent () #103 0x739afdac in _HandleKeyboardEvent () #104 0x738db008 in _CompatibilityMenuBarEventHandler () #105 0x737e13c0 in _InvokeEventHandlerUPP () #106 0x737e1100 in _DispatchEventToHandlers () #107 0x737e0da4 in _SendEventToEventTargetInternal () #108 0x737e1814 in _SendEventToEventTargetWithOptions () #109 0x739afb0c in _HandleKeyboardEvent () #110 0x737e15dc in _ToolboxEventDispatcherHandler () #111 0x737e13c0 in _InvokeEventHandlerUPP () #112 0x737e12b0 in _DispatchEventToHandlers () #113 0x737e0da4 in _SendEventToEventTargetInternal () #114 0x737e0cc4 in _SendEventToEventTarget () #115 0x737e0ae0 in _ToolboxEventDispatcher () #116 0x73840384 in _CallEventDispatchHook () #117 0x7383ff80 in _GetOrPeekEvent () #118 0x7383aea4 in _GetNextEventMatchingMask () #119 0x7383ab3c in _WNEInternal () #120 0x7383a9f8 in _WaitNextEvent () #121 0x014b9ea8 in GetEvent__16nsMacMessagePumpFR11EventRecord () #122 0x014b99b8 in DoMessagePump__16nsMacMessagePumpFv () #123 0x014b92c4 in Run__10nsAppShellFv () #124 0x0147c1c4 in Run__17nsAppShellServiceFv () #125 0x00092c78 in main1__FiPPcP11nsISupports () #126 0x000938d0 in main () Thread 1: #0 0x7000427c in _syscall () #1 0x70658478 in _ProcessReadyEvent () #2 0x70658270 in _CarbonSelectThreadFunc () #3 0x70014f34 in __pthread_body () Thread 2: #0 0x70059b98 in _semaphore_wait_signal_trap () #1 0x70016140 in _semaphore_wait_signal () #2 0x70015fa8 in __pthread_cond_wait () #3 0x70015d48 in _pthread_cond_wait () #4 0x70653b80 in _BSD_pthread_cond_wait () #5 0x70653b60 in _CarbonConditionWait () #6 0x7065552c in _CarbonOperationThreadFunc () #7 0x70014f34 in __pthread_body () Thread 3: #0 0x70059b78 in _semaphore_timedwait_signal_trap () #1 0x7003f828 in _semaphore_timedwait_signal () #2 0x70015f98 in __pthread_cond_wait () #3 0x7003f7f4 in _pthread_cond_timedwait_relative_np () #4 0x7029b590 in _TSWaitOnConditionTimedRelative () #5 0x7029cdac in _TSWaitOnSemaphoreCommon () #6 0x702e5f98 in _TSWaitOnSemaphoreRelative () #7 0x702e7208 in _TimerThread () #8 0x70014f34 in __pthread_body () Thread 4: #0 0x70059b98 in _semaphore_wait_signal_trap () #1 0x70016140 in _semaphore_wait_signal () #2 0x70015fa8 in __pthread_cond_wait () #3 0x70015d48 in _pthread_cond_wait () #4 0x7029b550 in _TSWaitOnCondition () #5 0x7029cd94 in _TSWaitOnSemaphoreCommon () #6 0x7029cce4 in _TSWaitOnSemaphore () #7 0x7029cba8 in _AsyncFileThread () #8 0x70014f34 in __pthread_body () Thread 5: #0 0x70059b98 in _semaphore_wait_signal_trap () #1 0x70016140 in _semaphore_wait_signal () #2 0x70015fa8 in __pthread_cond_wait () #3 0x70015d48 in _pthread_cond_wait () #4 0x70653b80 in _BSD_pthread_cond_wait () #5 0x70653b60 in _CarbonConditionWait () #6 0x70653a54 in _CarbonInetOperThreadFunc () #7 0x70014f34 in __pthread_body () PPC Thread State: srr0: 0x01fb4708 srr1: 0x0000f030 vrsave: 0x00000000 xer: 0x00000020 lr: 0x01fb46fc ctr: 0x001484b8 mq: 0x00000000 r0: 0x01fb46fc r1: 0xbfffbf10 r2: 0x020a2000 r3: 0x00000000 r4: 0xbfffbfb4 r5: 0x00000000 r6: 0xbfffbef0 r7: 0x00000008 r8: 0x00000001 r9: 0x020c776c r10: 0x00000001 r11: 0x00000001 r12: 0x00296698 r13: 0x00000000 r14: 0x00000000 r15: 0x00000000 r16: 0x00000000 r17: 0x00000000 r18: 0xbfffe1c8 r19: 0x00000000 r20: 0x00000000 r21: 0x00000000 r22: 0x00000000 r23: 0x00000001 r24: 0x00000000 r25: 0xbfffdd24 r26: 0x013679cc r27: 0xbfffda28 r28: 0x002a233c r29: 0xbfffbfb4 r30: 0x00000000 r31: 0x02824768 **********
This problem is a Mac OS X issue. In the current Mac OS 9 build, the user can't quit the application when this popup has focus.
Adding crash and pp keywords.
Severity: normal → critical
Keywords: crash, pp
In the 6/5 (or whatever) build, this doesn't occur for me. The behavior is the same as on Mac OS 9 (can't quit while the popup is open). No crash. (10.0.3)
http://lxr.mozilla.org/seamonkey/source/layout/xul/base/src/nsMenuFrame.cpp 539 menuPopup->GetView(mPresContext, &view); 540 nsCOMPtr<nsIViewManager> viewManager; i'm guessing view is null here [#6 0x021b85e4 in Destroy__6nsViewFv ()]: 541 view->GetViewManager(*getter_AddRefs(viewManager)); the real problem is probably that we make this call at all: http://lxr.mozilla.org/seamonkey/source/layout/xul/base/src/nsMenuPopupFrame.cp p#1370 menuFrame->ActivateMenu(PR_FALSE);
Actually, I deleted the older 5/30 build and used the 6/5 build. I have Mac OS X 10.0.3 on this iBook SE. I can reproduce this problem very easily using the steps provided. I also have branch build running under "Classic" mode on this same machine. Can't reproduce the problem with that build.
Summary: While URL popupmenu is displayed, attempting to quit(Command-Q) will cause a crash → [osx]While URL popupmenu is displayed, attempting to quit(Command-Q) will cause a crash
nav triage team: Marking nsbeta1+, p2, and mozilla0.9.3. Reassigning to pchen
Assignee: alecf → pchen
Keywords: nsbeta1+
Priority: -- → P2
Target Milestone: --- → mozilla0.9.3
nav triage team: Moving to mozilla1.0
Target Milestone: mozilla0.9.3 → mozilla1.0
crash -> moving up to mozilla0.9.5
Target Milestone: mozilla1.0 → mozilla0.9.5
any update on this?
with a 2001090408 MacOSX build the app quits gracefully- but it's not supposed to quit at all right? aren't we just asking for trouble if we let it?
nominating bug via nsBranch keyword
Keywords: nsbranch
I don't see why quitting in response to a Cmd-Q is all that bad, even if a popup should prevent it. Since that appears to be the remaining extent of the problem, nsbranch-/096
Keywords: nsbranch → nsbranch-
Target Milestone: mozilla0.9.5 → mozilla0.9.6
This bug was fixed and we don't crash any more. As for should you be able to quit with a popup menu up? When the user sez quit, we quit.
Status: NEW → RESOLVED
Closed: 24 years ago
Resolution: --- → FIXED
Verified in the Mac OS X Oct 4th branch build.
Keywords: vtrunk
Verified in Oct 3 OS X trunk (2001-10-03-21)
Really..
Status: RESOLVED → VERIFIED
Removing vtrunk
Keywords: vtrunk
Product: Core → SeaMonkey
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.