Build: B2G 18 4/2/2013 Device: Unagi STR 1. Import a google calendar that contains an event with a 10 minute and 20 minute alarm reminder 2. View that event Expected The calendar event imported should have 2 alarm reminders. Actual The calendar event imported has no alarm reminders.
Does this reproduce with Yahoo or Zimbra?
(In reply to James Lal [:lightsofapollo] from comment #1) > Does this reproduce with Yahoo or Zimbra? This isn't going to be possible on Zimbra, as Zimbra only supports a single alarm. Yahoo doesn't have a 10 min & 20 minut alarm reminder, so this can't happen there either. This bug is only possible with google calendar.
Double checked - still reproducible on 5/12
blocking-b2g: --- → leo?
There is a bug in google's implementation where altering the alarm information does not change the event's etag. This means if you do something like this: -> create event -> sync -> edit alarm -> sync We will not know about changes to this event until some other details are altered.
James, should we fix this on our side or is it on Google side ? Does it occurs on tef version too ?
(In reply to David Scravaglieri [:scravag] from comment #5) > James, should we fix this on our side or is it on Google side ? Does it > occurs on tef version too ? From my experience, Google is tough to get fixes from given that FF OS has low market share. We need to try to get a fix on our side if possible, even if it means implementing a workaround.
I have made an informal request (to their Calendar team) we might get better results when we switch to https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=871302 for sync... Its worth doing some experimenting.
Looks like this reproduces with all-day events too. Specifically, any case with events with two or more alarms for google calendar events.
(In reply to Jason Smith [:jsmith] from comment #8) > Looks like this reproduces with all-day events too. Specifically, any case > with events with two or more alarms for google calendar events. Hi Jason, I was unable to reproduce this. These where the steps I took: 1) on desktop, I added both an all day event and an one hour event to google calendar, each with their respective 10 and 20 alarms 2) on device (unagi) I import the same google calendar 3) check calendar event details view for both events 4) each show the 10 and 20 min alarms Enviroment info: Build: 20130505070205 Gaia: 753e7d6 Hopefully, I'm taking the right steps to test this bug, else I'm convinced my phone is from the future :) Let me know if you any addition info. Thanks, Mark
Hmm...that might good news actually if you can't reproduce. I've reproduced this 3 times over 3 different builds with one google account. Which means this might be a problem specifically at the caldav layer with parsing my calendars for that account. Let me try my other google account if I can reproduce. If I can't, then that confirms my theory above.
QA Contact: jsmith
I can reproduce this with my other google account as well. So yeah, I'm not sure why you can't reproduce.
QA Contact: jsmith
Turns out I found out why this wasn't working for me. Gcal supports two styles of alarms: - Email - Popup We integrate with popup, given those are the type of notifications we fire. Upon further testing, those appear to work in single, 2 alarm, and 5 alarm cases. That explains the issues I hit here. Resolving as invalid as we technically import the popup alarms, not the email alarms (which makes sense).
Status: NEW → RESOLVED
blocking-b2g: leo+ → ---
Last Resolved: 5 years ago
Resolution: --- → INVALID
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.