Closed Bug 877024 Opened 7 years ago Closed 6 years ago

[Tracking bug] Issues with the youtube preinstalled app

Categories

(Firefox OS Graveyard :: General, defect)

ARM
Gonk (Firefox OS)
defect
Not set

Tracking

(Not tracked)

RESOLVED WONTFIX

People

(Reporter: marcia, Unassigned)

References

Details

Attachments

(1 file)

Per Roc's request, this bug will be used to track issues with the youtube certified app.

https://mozqa.etherpad.mozilla.org/YouTubeCertifiedApp has a rollup of the current issues found.
FYI - bug 871910 already exists for tracking tech evangelism issues in relation to the youtube preinstalled app. We could use this for tracking the client-side (e.g. gecko) changes required.
See Also: → b2g-youtube
Do we have a bug for the whitelist-youtube-for-open-fullscreen patch?
Depends on: 876380, 876426, 876962
Alias: b2g-youtube
Fabrice, could you attach your latest version of the app here?
Depends on: 876843
No longer depends on: 876843
Depends on: 877461
How can I get the YouTubeCertifiedApp?
(In reply to Sotaro Ikeda [:sotaro] from comment #4)
> How can I get the YouTubeCertifiedApp?

Fabrice should have the latest copy. Ping him over IRC or email to get a copy.
Attached file youtube app package
Here's my latest version. I changed the way we reload the last page when coming back to foreground. It seems better in my tests.
I removed the dependencies on bug 877032 and bug 877049. One didn't seem bad enough to block, the other seemed unrelated to the youtube app itself.
No longer depends on: 876843
Depends on: 878060
Depends on: 780821
No longer depends on: 780821
Depends on: b2g-youtube
See Also: b2g-youtube
1.01 is out for YouTube due to too many fundamental issues. We're retargeting getting this working for 1.1.
Summary: [Tracking bug] Issues with the youtube certified app → [Tracking bug] Issues with the youtube preinstalled app
Depends on: 878183
No longer depends on: 878060
(In reply to Jason Smith [:jsmith] from comment #8)
> 1.01 is out for YouTube due to too many fundamental issues. We're
> retargeting getting this working for 1.1.

That doesn't match what I've heard from Karen. My understanding is that we'll try to fix as many platform issues we can, and then hope that that is good enough to get us through certification.

Can you clarify where you heard that we're bailing on v1.0.1?
(In reply to Jonas Sicking (:sicking) from comment #9)
> (In reply to Jason Smith [:jsmith] from comment #8)
> > 1.01 is out for YouTube due to too many fundamental issues. We're
> > retargeting getting this working for 1.1.
> 
> That doesn't match what I've heard from Karen. My understanding is that
> we'll try to fix as many platform issues we can, and then hope that that is
> good enough to get us through certification.
> 
> Can you clarify where you heard that we're bailing on v1.0.1?

Read farther down the email. It's near the bottom.

OUTCOME: Decision on Path Forward. 

At this point in time Mozilla will cease work on the packaged app for YT for v1.0.1 (and all supporting fixes for v1.0.1);       

Donovan is working to validate YouTube’s own app against the YT certification criteria so we can assess how soon MOZ can submit a device with their YT app and FOS v1.1 for certification.  Ideally this will be June 4 …. But we will need to see the results of Donovan’s work.
Depends on: 878977
Depends on: 879297
No longer depends on: 878033
Depends on: 873631
Depends on: 879529
Bug 878977 is not related to this bug.
No longer depends on: 878977
Depends on: 880601
Depends on: 880608
Depends on: 880743
No longer depends on: 880743
Depends on: 881584
Depends on: 881388
I want to add one more dependent bug.
If you think is not related to this meta bug, please remove it.
Depends on: 883814
No longer depends on: 883814
Depends on: 880902
Depends on: 884188
Depends on: 885434
No longer depends on: 881611
Depends on: 887454
Depends on: 884678
No longer depends on: 884678
Depends on: 884678
No longer depends on: 884678
Depends on: 883814
Depends on: 893000
No longer depends on: 893000
Depends on: 889138
No longer depends on: 889138
Depends on: 874754
Depends on: 894249
Depends on: 894435
Depends on: 896089
Depends on: 896663
Depends on: 896952
No longer depends on: 881388
No longer depends on: 896089
Depends on: 900041
No longer depends on: 900041
Depends on: 900041
No longer depends on: 900041
Depends on: 900093
No longer depends on: 900093
Depends on: 900359
No longer depends on: 900359
Depends on: 906612
Depends on: 908061
Depends on: 909851
No longer depends on: 909851
Depends on: 912194
No longer depends on: 912194
Depends on: 912210
No longer depends on: 912210
No longer depends on: 908061
Depends on: 908061
Depends on: 919405
No longer depends on: 906612
No longer depends on: 908061
Depends on: 932695
Depends on: 933348
Depends on: 933376
Depends on: 944132
Depends on: 944167
No longer depends on: 944167
Depends on: 966077
No longer depends on: 966077
Depends on: 977907
Depends on: 978181
We no longer need this bug for tracking, so closing this out.
Status: NEW → RESOLVED
Closed: 6 years ago
No longer depends on: b2g-youtube, 873631, 884188, 896952, 919405
Resolution: --- → WONTFIX
Alias: b2g-youtube
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.