Bug 1568170 Comment 0 Edit History

Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.

When clicking on the **File bug** button from an alert summary, Perfherder redirects the sheriff to a Bugzilla URL ([example](https://bugzilla.mozilla.org//enter_bug.cgi?cc=dave.hunt%40gmail.com%2C+rwood%40mozilla.com%2C+igoldan%40mozilla.com%2C+fstrugariu%40mozilla.com&comment=Raptor+has+detected+a+Firefox+performance+regression+from+push%3A%0A%0Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fhg.mozilla.org%2Fintegration%2Fautoland%2Fpushloghtml%3Fchangeset%3Dad5e0980c2731978f159e17622d6ba0aa1c05ea5%0A%0AAs+author+of+one+of+the+patches+included+in+that+push%2C+we+need+your+help+to+address+this+regression.%0A%0ARegressions%3A%0A%0A++53%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+windows7-32-shippable+opt+++++++++++++++++++540.49+-%3E+827.83%0A++52%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+loadtime+windows7-32-shippable+opt++++++++++548.12+-%3E+834.75%0A++52%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+fcp+windows7-32-shippable+opt+++++++++++++++548.50+-%3E+833.88%0A++51%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+windows10-64-shippable+opt++++++++++++++++++528.76+-%3E+795.97%0A++50%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+loadtime+windows10-64-shippable+opt+++++++++532.50+-%3E+799.33%0A++50%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+loadtime+windows10-64-shippable-qr+opt++++++539.67+-%3E+808.33%0A++50%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+fcp+windows10-64-shippable+opt++++++++++++++536.00+-%3E+801.79%0A++50%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+windows10-64-shippable-qr+opt+++++++++++++++538.22+-%3E+805.13%0A++48%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+fcp+windows10-64-shippable-qr+opt+++++++++++547.17+-%3E+811.83%0A%0AImprovements%3A%0A%0A++35%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+loadtime+linux64-shippable+opt+++++++++631.42+-%3E+407.62%0A++35%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+linux64-shippable+opt++++++++++++++++++620.77+-%3E+403.27%0A++34%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+fcp+linux64-shippable+opt++++++++++++++626.46+-%3E+410.88%0A++34%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+fcp+linux64-shippable-qr+opt+++++++++++665.75+-%3E+438.04%0A++34%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+linux64-shippable-qr+opt+++++++++++++++657.35+-%3E+432.67%0A++33%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+loadtime+linux64-shippable-qr+opt++++++665.75+-%3E+446.21%0A%0A%0AYou+can+find+links+to+graphs+and+comparison+views+for+each+of+the+above+tests+at%3A+https%3A%2F%2Ftreeherder.mozilla.org%2Fperf.html%23%2Falerts%3Fid%3D22039%0A%0AOn+the+page+above+you+can+see+an+alert+for+each+affected+platform+as+well+as+a+link+to+a+graph+showing+the+history+of+scores+for+this+test.+There+is+also+a+link+to+a+Treeherder+page+showing+the+Raptor+jobs+in+a+pushlog+format.%0A%0ATo+learn+more+about+the+regressing+test%28s%29+or+reproducing+them%2C+please+see%3A+https%3A%2F%2Fwiki.mozilla.org%2FPerformance_sheriffing%2FRaptor%0A%0A+Please+let+us+know+your+plans+within+3+business+days%2C+or+the+offending+patch%28es%29+will+be+backed+out%21+%0A%0AOur+wiki+page+outlines+the+common+responses+and+expectations%3A+https%3A%2F%2Fwiki.mozilla.org%2FPerformance_sheriffing%2FTalos%2FRegressionBugsHandling%0A&component=General&product=Testing&keywords=perf%2C+regression&short_desc=48.37+-+53.16%25+raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+%2F+raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+fcp+%2F+raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+loadtime+%28windows10-64-shippable%2C+windows10-64-shippable-qr%2C+windows7-32-shippable%29+regression+on+push+ad5e0980c2731978f159e17622d6ba0aa1c05ea5+%28Sun+July+21+2019%29&status_whiteboard=)), which contains query params that prefill the form we're about to submit.

It looks like this no longer works, as Bugzilla seems to automatically remove some of these query params & recommends us to use [Bugzilla Helper](https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/enter_bug.cgi?format=guided#h=dupes|Testing|) instead.
If Bugzilla recently adopted a new way of submitting prefilled forms then Perfherder will need to integrate it in its flow.
When clicking on the **File bug** button from an alert summary (such as [this one](https://treeherder.mozilla.org/perf.html#/alerts?id=22039)), Perfherder redirects the sheriff to a Bugzilla URL ([example](https://bugzilla.mozilla.org//enter_bug.cgi?cc=dave.hunt%40gmail.com%2C+rwood%40mozilla.com%2C+igoldan%40mozilla.com%2C+fstrugariu%40mozilla.com&comment=Raptor+has+detected+a+Firefox+performance+regression+from+push%3A%0A%0Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fhg.mozilla.org%2Fintegration%2Fautoland%2Fpushloghtml%3Fchangeset%3Dad5e0980c2731978f159e17622d6ba0aa1c05ea5%0A%0AAs+author+of+one+of+the+patches+included+in+that+push%2C+we+need+your+help+to+address+this+regression.%0A%0ARegressions%3A%0A%0A++53%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+windows7-32-shippable+opt+++++++++++++++++++540.49+-%3E+827.83%0A++52%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+loadtime+windows7-32-shippable+opt++++++++++548.12+-%3E+834.75%0A++52%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+fcp+windows7-32-shippable+opt+++++++++++++++548.50+-%3E+833.88%0A++51%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+windows10-64-shippable+opt++++++++++++++++++528.76+-%3E+795.97%0A++50%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+loadtime+windows10-64-shippable+opt+++++++++532.50+-%3E+799.33%0A++50%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+loadtime+windows10-64-shippable-qr+opt++++++539.67+-%3E+808.33%0A++50%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+fcp+windows10-64-shippable+opt++++++++++++++536.00+-%3E+801.79%0A++50%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+windows10-64-shippable-qr+opt+++++++++++++++538.22+-%3E+805.13%0A++48%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+fcp+windows10-64-shippable-qr+opt+++++++++++547.17+-%3E+811.83%0A%0AImprovements%3A%0A%0A++35%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+loadtime+linux64-shippable+opt+++++++++631.42+-%3E+407.62%0A++35%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+linux64-shippable+opt++++++++++++++++++620.77+-%3E+403.27%0A++34%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+fcp+linux64-shippable+opt++++++++++++++626.46+-%3E+410.88%0A++34%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+fcp+linux64-shippable-qr+opt+++++++++++665.75+-%3E+438.04%0A++34%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+linux64-shippable-qr+opt+++++++++++++++657.35+-%3E+432.67%0A++33%25++raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+loadtime+linux64-shippable-qr+opt++++++665.75+-%3E+446.21%0A%0A%0AYou+can+find+links+to+graphs+and+comparison+views+for+each+of+the+above+tests+at%3A+https%3A%2F%2Ftreeherder.mozilla.org%2Fperf.html%23%2Falerts%3Fid%3D22039%0A%0AOn+the+page+above+you+can+see+an+alert+for+each+affected+platform+as+well+as+a+link+to+a+graph+showing+the+history+of+scores+for+this+test.+There+is+also+a+link+to+a+Treeherder+page+showing+the+Raptor+jobs+in+a+pushlog+format.%0A%0ATo+learn+more+about+the+regressing+test%28s%29+or+reproducing+them%2C+please+see%3A+https%3A%2F%2Fwiki.mozilla.org%2FPerformance_sheriffing%2FRaptor%0A%0A+Please+let+us+know+your+plans+within+3+business+days%2C+or+the+offending+patch%28es%29+will+be+backed+out%21+%0A%0AOur+wiki+page+outlines+the+common+responses+and+expectations%3A+https%3A%2F%2Fwiki.mozilla.org%2FPerformance_sheriffing%2FTalos%2FRegressionBugsHandling%0A&component=General&product=Testing&keywords=perf%2C+regression&short_desc=48.37+-+53.16%25+raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+%2F+raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+fcp+%2F+raptor-tp6-wikipedia-firefox+loadtime+%28windows10-64-shippable%2C+windows10-64-shippable-qr%2C+windows7-32-shippable%29+regression+on+push+ad5e0980c2731978f159e17622d6ba0aa1c05ea5+%28Sun+July+21+2019%29&status_whiteboard=)), which contains query params that prefill the form we're about to submit.

It looks like this no longer works, as Bugzilla seems to automatically remove some of these query params & recommends us to use [Bugzilla Helper](https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/enter_bug.cgi?format=guided#h=dupes|Testing|) instead.
If Bugzilla recently adopted a new way of submitting prefilled forms then Perfherder will need to integrate it in its flow.

Back to Bug 1568170 Comment 0