Bug 1592258 Comment 136 Edit History

Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.

I think I can resolve at least one core opinion question you posed:

Alex wrote:
> Opinion 1 - Don't offer Exchange preselected ...
> Opinion 2 - Offer Exchange preselected ...

This question has been discussed by the TB Council, and the Council has ruled on it. We *will* offer Exchange preselected.

The password wrong question is an edge case, but Magnus' patch puts everything on its head.

Note what Magnus wrote in comment 14:
> if Exchange was available, AND the normal IMAP/POP auth failed: that would be the appropriate place to advertise this alternative.

That's exactly what I implemented.

I've also fixed bug 1600954 based on Magnus' feedback here. I've honestly tried.
I think I can resolve at least one core opinion question you posed:

Alex wrote:
> Opinion 1 - Don't offer Exchange preselected ...
> Opinion 2 - Offer Exchange preselected ...

This question has been discussed by the TB Council, and the Council has ruled on it. We *will* offer Exchange preselected, where appropriate.

Note what Magnus wrote in comment 14:
> if Exchange was available, AND the normal IMAP/POP auth failed: that would be the appropriate place to advertise this alternative.

That's exactly what I implemented.

I've also fixed bug 1600954 based on Magnus' feedback here. I've honestly tried.
I think I can resolve at least one core opinion question you posed:

Alex wrote:
> Opinion 1 - Don't offer Exchange preselected ...
> Opinion 2 - Offer Exchange preselected ...

This question has been discussed by the TB Council, and the Council has ruled on it. We *will* offer Exchange preselected, where appropriate.

Note what Magnus wrote in comment 14:
> if Exchange was available, AND the normal IMAP/POP auth failed: that would be the appropriate place to advertise this alternative.

That's exactly what I implemented. *Precisely* that.

I've also fixed bug 1600954 based on Magnus' feedback here. I've honestly tried.
I think I can resolve at least one core opinion question you posed:

Alex wrote:
> Opinion 1 - Don't offer Exchange preselected ...
> Opinion 2 - Offer Exchange preselected ...

This question has been discussed by the TB Council, and the Council has ruled on it. We *will* offer Exchange preselected, where appropriate.

Note what Magnus wrote in comment 14:
> if Exchange was available, AND the normal IMAP/POP auth failed: that would be the appropriate place to advertise this alternative.

That's exactly what I implemented.

I've also fixed bug 1600954 based on Magnus' feedback here. I've honestly tried.

Back to Bug 1592258 Comment 136