Bug 1790388 Comment 0 Edit History

Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.

Jason got this as a complaint on Twitter (see screenshot below).

We don't know how often this happens in the wild, but when it does, it's unexpected and annyoing. Magnus once fixed a very similar issue in Bug 525124 - Double Clicking in a Blank Space Opens the Advanced Property Editor.

Incomplete STR extracted from original user report:
- Reply to a message having <o:p>
- Double-click a word to select it for copying

Actual
- `Advanced Property Editor` dialog for <o:p> unexpectedly pops up and gets in the way
- Annoying whenever it happens.

Expected
- no dialog should pop up
- select the word only

I am failing to reproduce this with the above steps.
Here's the only variant STR which has reproduced for me on TB 102.2.2 (64-bit), Win10:

1. Compose new message
2. `Insert > HTML` dialog: Enter this code:
`<p><o:p>test</o:p></p>`
Note: <o:p> is a tag inserted by MS Office, apparently for *Office Namespace* [1]
3. Fast quadruple-click at the very left edge of the word `test` (just on the edge of or just outside the selection)

Actual
- `Advanced Property Editor` dialog pops up

Expected
- I don't think we'd ever want `Advanced Property Editor` dialog to pop up from just clicking about when selecting text.

[1] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/7808968/what-do-op-elements-do-anyway
Jason got this as a complaint on Twitter (see screenshot below).

We don't know how often this happens in the wild, but when it does, it's unexpected and annyoing. Magnus once fixed a very similar issue in Bug 525124 - Double Clicking in a Blank Space Opens the Advanced Property Editor.

Incomplete STR extracted from original user report:
- Reply to a message having <o:p>
- Double-click a word to select it for copying

Actual
- `Advanced Property Editor` dialog for <o:p> unexpectedly pops up and gets in the way
- Annoying whenever it happens.

Expected
- no dialog should pop up
- select the word only

I am failing to reproduce this with the above steps.
Here's the only variant STR which reproduce for me on TB 102.2.2 (64-bit), Win10:

1. Compose new message
2. `Insert > HTML` dialog: Enter this code:
`<p><o:p>test</o:p></p>`
Note: <o:p> is a tag inserted by MS Office, apparently for *Office Namespace* [1]
3. Fast quadruple-click at the very left edge of the word `test` (just on the edge of or just outside the selection)

Actual
- `Advanced Property Editor` dialog pops up

Expected
- I don't think we'd ever want `Advanced Property Editor` dialog to pop up from just clicking about when selecting text.

[1] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/7808968/what-do-op-elements-do-anyway
Jason got this as a complaint on Twitter (see screenshot below).

We don't know how often this happens in the wild, but when it does, it's unexpected and annyoing. Magnus once fixed a very similar issue in Bug 525124 - Double Clicking in a Blank Space Opens the Advanced Property Editor. And we've fixed many such issues before (bugs listed in *see also*).

New STR :
- see testcase 1 by thomas8 in comment 6, attachment 9294414 [details]
- Reply to a message created with Microsoft Office having empty <o:p></o:p> tag in a nested context (see original source in comment 4):
  `<span>double-click HERE<o:p></o:p></span>`
  You can create such message via `Insert > HTML` in composition, or use testcase 1 (attachment 9294414 [details]).
- In the quoted text, double-click on the last word ("HERE") before the <o:p> tag to select it for copying

Actual
- `Advanced Property Editor` dialog for `<o:p>` unexpectedly pops up and gets in the way
- Annoying whenever it happens.

Expected
- no dialog should pop up
- select the word only

-----

~I am failing to reproduce this with the above steps.~
Here's ~the only~ a **variant STR which reproduce for me** on TB 102.2.2 (64-bit), Win10:

1. Compose new message
2. `Insert > HTML` dialog: Enter this code:
`<p><o:p>test</o:p></p>`
Note: <o:p> is a tag inserted by MS Office, apparently for *Office Namespace* [1]
3. Fast quadruple-click at the very left edge of the word `test` (just on the edge of or just outside the selection)

Actual
- `Advanced Property Editor` dialog pops up

Expected
- I don't think we'd ever want `Advanced Property Editor` dialog to pop up from just clicking about when selecting text.

[1] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/7808968/what-do-op-elements-do-anyway
Jason got this as a complaint on Twitter (see screenshot below).

We don't know how often this happens in the wild, but when it does, it's unexpected and annyoing. Magnus once fixed a very similar issue in Bug 525124 - Double Clicking in a Blank Space Opens the Advanced Property Editor. And we've fixed many such issues before (bugs listed in *see also*).

New STR :
- see testcase 1 by thomas8 in comment 6, attachment 9294414 [details]
- Reply to a message created with Microsoft Office having empty `<o:p></o:p>` tag in a nested context (see original source in comment 4):
  `<span>double-click HERE<o:p></o:p></span>`
  You can create such message via `Insert > HTML` in composition, or use testcase 1 (attachment 9294414 [details]).
- In the quoted text, double-click on the last word ("HERE") before the <o:p> tag to select it for copying

Actual
- `Advanced Property Editor` dialog for `<o:p>` unexpectedly pops up and gets in the way
- Annoying whenever it happens.

Expected
- no dialog should pop up
- select the word only

-----

~I am failing to reproduce this with the above steps.~
Here's ~the only~ a **variant STR which reproduce for me** on TB 102.2.2 (64-bit), Win10:

1. Compose new message
2. `Insert > HTML` dialog: Enter this code:
`<p><o:p>test</o:p></p>`
Note: `<o:p>` is a tag inserted by MS Office, apparently for *Office Namespace* [1]
3. Fast quadruple-click at the very left edge of the word `test` (just on the edge of or just outside the selection)

Actual
- `Advanced Property Editor` dialog pops up

Expected
- I don't think we'd ever want `Advanced Property Editor` dialog to pop up from just clicking about when selecting text.

[1] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/7808968/what-do-op-elements-do-anyway

Back to Bug 1790388 Comment 0