Bugzilla

(In reply to Nick Rishel [:nrishel] from comment #24)
> This issue is tracking two distinct bugs which happened to coincide; one of which has since been resolved.
>
> :atrif could you spin off a new ticket for the Win11 Insider Preview specific issue and observations?

Sorry, I was on PTO. Is this still needed? 

I have also taken a look at this today and here are the results:

Installed a fresh install for Windows 11x64 22H2 without insider preview on a VM. First, it was updated to 22621.2283 where I could not reproduce the issue (one click default worked as expected on all the latest Firefox versions). The only thing worth mentioning on this build is that on Firefox 118.0.1 and 115.3.1esr when the Make default button was clicked for the first time it opened the default apps window. Clicking it the second time will make Firefox as default browser. On the latest nightly and 119.0b3, the Firefox browser was set as default on the first click.

Updated the Windows 11 installation again to 22621.2361 and I still cannot reproduce the issue on the VM. Clicking the `Make default` button will make the Firefox browser as default on one click without opening the Default Apps window. Tested with (latest nightly, 119.0b3, 118.0.1, 115.3.1esr)

I can still reproduce the one-click issue with all Firefox versions on my other PC with 22521.2361 (where I initially encountered bug 1851596) which is enrolled in Insider Release Preview. Clicking the `Make Default` button will open the Default Apps window each time when clicked. This is strange because they are both on the same version and the only difference I know off is that now is enrolled on Insider Release channel and one is not enrolled at all.

(In reply to Nick Rishel [:nrishel] from comment #24)
> This issue is tracking two distinct bugs which happened to coincide; one of which has since been resolved.
>
> :atrif could you spin off a new ticket for the Win11 Insider Preview specific issue and observations?

Sorry, I was on PTO. Is this still needed? 

I have also taken a look at this today and here are the results:

Installed a fresh install for Windows 11x64 22H2 without insider preview on a VM. First, it was updated to 22621.2283 where I could not reproduce the issue (one click default worked as expected on all the latest Firefox versions). The only thing worth mentioning on this build is that on Firefox 118.0.1 and 115.3.1esr when the Make default button was clicked for the first time it opened the default apps window. Clicking it the second time will make Firefox as default browser. On the latest nightly and 119.0b3, the Firefox browser was set as default on the first click.

Updated the Windows 11 installation again to 22621.2361 (manual update) and I still cannot reproduce the issue on the VM. Clicking the `Make default` button will make the Firefox browser as default on one click without opening the Default Apps window. Tested with (latest nightly, 119.0b3, 118.0.1, 115.3.1esr)

I can still reproduce the one-click issue with all Firefox versions on my other PC with 22521.2361 (where I initially encountered bug 1851596) which is enrolled in Insider Release Preview. Clicking the `Make Default` button will open the Default Apps window each time when clicked. This is strange because they are both on the same version and the only difference I know off is that now is enrolled on Insider Release channel and one is not enrolled at all.

(In reply to Nick Rishel [:nrishel] from comment #24)
> This issue is tracking two distinct bugs which happened to coincide; one of which has since been resolved.
>
> :atrif could you spin off a new ticket for the Win11 Insider Preview specific issue and observations?

Sorry, I was on PTO. Is this still needed? 

I have also taken a look at this today and here are the results:

Installed a fresh install for Windows 11x64 22H2 without insider preview on a VM. First, it was updated to 22621.2283 where I could not reproduce the issue (one click default worked as expected on all the latest Firefox versions). The only thing worth mentioning on this build is that on Firefox 118.0.1 and 115.3.1esr when the Make default button was clicked for the first time it opened the default apps window. Clicking it the second time will make Firefox as default browser. On the latest nightly and 119.0b3, the Firefox browser was set as default on the first click.

Updated the Windows 11 installation again to 22621.2361 (manual update) and I still cannot reproduce the issue on the VM. Clicking the `Make default` button will make the Firefox browser as default on one click without opening the Default Apps window. Tested with (latest nightly, 119.0b3, 118.0.1, 115.3.1esr)

I can still reproduce the one-click issue with all Firefox versions on my other PC with 22621.2361 (where I initially encountered bug 1851596) which is enrolled in Insider Release Preview. Clicking the `Make Default` button will open the Default Apps window each time when clicked. This is strange because they are both on the same version and the only difference I know off is that now is enrolled on Insider Release channel and one is not enrolled at all.

(In reply to Nick Rishel [:nrishel] from comment #24)
> This issue is tracking two distinct bugs which happened to coincide; one of which has since been resolved.
>
> :atrif could you spin off a new ticket for the Win11 Insider Preview specific issue and observations?

Sorry, I was on PTO. Is this still needed? 

I have also taken a look at this today and here are the results:

Installed a fresh install for Windows 11x64 22H2 without insider preview on a VM. First, it was updated to 22621.2283 where I could not reproduce the issue (one click default worked as expected on all the latest Firefox versions). The only thing worth mentioning on this build is that on Firefox 118.0.1 and 115.3.1esr when the Make default button was clicked for the first time it opened the default apps window. Clicking it the second time will make Firefox as default browser. On the latest nightly and 119.0b3, the Firefox browser was set as default on the first click.

Updated the Windows 11 installation again to 22621.2361 (manual update) and I still cannot reproduce the issue on the VM. Clicking the `Make default` button will make the Firefox browser as default on one click without opening the Default Apps window. Tested with (latest nightly, 119.0b3, 118.0.1, 115.3.1esr)

I can still reproduce the one-click issue with all Firefox versions on my other PC with 22621.2361 (where I initially encountered bug 1851596) which is enrolled in Insider Release Preview. Clicking the `Make Default` button will open the Default Apps window each time when clicked. This is strange because they are both on the same version and the only difference I know of is that one is enrolled on the Insider Release channel and one is not enrolled at all.

(In reply to Nick Rishel [:nrishel] from comment #24)
> This issue is tracking two distinct bugs which happened to coincide; one of which has since been resolved.
>
> :atrif could you spin off a new ticket for the Win11 Insider Preview specific issue and observations?

Sorry, I was on PTO. Is this still needed? 

I have also taken a look at this today and here are the results:

Installed a fresh install for Windows 11x64 22H2 without insider preview on a VM. First, it was updated to 22621.2283 where I could not reproduce the issue (one click default worked as expected on all the latest Firefox versions). The only thing worth mentioning on this build is that on Firefox 118.0.1 and 115.3.1esr when the Make default button was clicked for the first time it opened the default apps window. Clicking it the second time will make Firefox as default browser. On the latest nightly and 119.0b3, the Firefox browser was set as default on the first click.

Updated the Windows 11 installation again to 22621.2361 (manual update) and I still cannot reproduce the issue on the VM. Clicking the `Make default` button will make the Firefox browser as default on one click without opening the Default Apps window. Tested with (latest nightly, 119.0b3, 118.0.1, 115.3.1esr)

I can still reproduce the one-click issue with all Firefox versions on my other PC with 22621.2361 (where I initially encountered bug 1851596) which is enrolled in Insider Release Preview. Clicking the `Make Default` button will open the Default Apps window each time when clicked. This is strange because they are both on the same version and the only difference I know of is that one is enrolled on the Insider Release channel and one is not enrolled at all. If more information is needed please let us know. Thank you!