(In reply to Nicole Weber [:topotropic] from comment #7) > (In reply to Ania from comment #4) > Where in the toolbar would the icon live? Something to consider is that everything right of the toolbar is clickable today and depending on placement the privacy icon could look like an extension or some other functional element. > Hi Nicole, I posted a screenshot from Kelly's patch - as you can see it keeps the private browsing icon in the same location but removes the text. > Did we explore other options like adding it at the top of the vertical tabs? This could be even more helpful and reassuring to have the private tabs and the icon close to each other Yes, but that was more in the context of a future forward solution AIUI (I'll add you to the slack thread so you have more context on last weeks discussion). Since we're in the last week of Nightly and we need to get this fix in for 133 we don't have time for anything other than treating this as a bug fix however we can consider further changes for rolling vertical tabs out to all users.
Bug 1923052 Comment 9 Edit History
Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.
(In reply to Nicole Weber [:topotropic] from comment #7) > (In reply to Ania from comment #4) > Where in the toolbar would the icon live? Something to consider is that everything right of the toolbar is clickable today and depending on placement the privacy icon could look like an extension or some other functional element. > Hi Nicole, I posted a screenshot from Kelly's patch - as you can see it keeps the private browsing icon in the same location but removes the text. > Did we explore other options like adding it at the top of the vertical tabs? This could be even more helpful and reassuring to have the private tabs and the icon close to each other Yes, but that was more in the context of a future forward solution AIUI (I'll share the slack thread so you have more context on last weeks discussion or you can reach out to Yulia and Ania directly). Since we're in the last week of Nightly and we need to get this fix in for 133 we don't have time for anything other than treating this as a bug fix however we can consider further changes for rolling vertical tabs out to all users.