Bug 1679702 Comment 0 Edit History

Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.

+++ This bug was initially created as a clone of Bug #854067 +++

Thunderbird (like Firefox, bug 585398) does not honor Windows shortcut or command line options to start up minimized. This would make a nice complement for our new option `When Thunderbird is minimized, move it to the tray`. In fact, some of the numerous duplicates of bug 208923 have requested this already.

STR1 (see Screenshot 1):

1.) Place a Windows link to thunderbird.exe in any folder (typically the Windows startup folder:  `C:\Users\USERNAME\AppData\Roaming\Microsoft\Windows\Start Menu\Programs\Startup`).
2.) Right-click on the link file > `Properties` (or `Alt`+`Enter`)
3.) Activate `Shortcut` tab
4.) Choose Run: `Minimized`, confirm with OK
5.) Double-click or press `Enter` to open the link

STR2:

1.) Windows-Run: cmd
2.) Run this from command line: `start /min thunderbird.exe` (or full path to thunderbird.exe)

For comparison, perform STR1 and STR2 with "notepad.exe".

Actual results:

- Thunderbird does *not* start minimized for either STR1 or STR2
- (Beware of artefacts: The program might start minimized if it was already minimized last time when closed before logging off/shutting down)
- Notepad.exe does start minimized


Expected results:

- Thunderbird should start minimized according to Windows shortcut or command line options (regardless in which window state it was closed before).
+++ This bug was initially created as a clone of Bug #854067 +++

Thunderbird (like Firefox, bug 585398) does not honor Windows shortcut or command line options to start up minimized. This would make a nice complement for our new option `When Thunderbird is minimized, move it to the tray`. In fact, some of the numerous duplicates of bug 208923 have requested this already.

STR1 (see Screenshot 1):

1.) Place a Windows link to thunderbird.exe in any folder (typically the Windows startup folder:  `C:\Users\USERNAME\AppData\Roaming\Microsoft\Windows\Start Menu\Programs\Startup`).
2.) Right-click on the link file > `Properties` (or `Alt`+`Enter`)
3.) Activate `Shortcut` tab
4.) Choose Run: `Minimized`, confirm with OK
5.) Double-click or press `Enter` to open the link

STR2:

1.) Windows-Run: cmd
2.) From command line: `start /min thunderbird.exe` (or full path to thunderbird.exe)

For comparison, perform STR1 and STR2 with "notepad.exe".

Actual results:

- Thunderbird does *not* start minimized for either STR1 or STR2
- (Beware of artefacts: The program might start minimized if it was already minimized last time when closed before logging off/shutting down)
- Notepad.exe does start minimized


Expected results:

- Thunderbird should start minimized according to Windows shortcut or command line options (regardless in which window state it was closed before).
+++ This bug was initially created as a clone of Bug #854067 +++

Thunderbird (like Firefox, bug 585398) does not honor Windows shortcut or command line options to start up minimized. This would make a nice complement for our new option `When Thunderbird is minimized, move it to the tray`. In fact, some of the numerous duplicates of bug 208923 have requested this already.

**STR1 (see Screenshot 1):**

1.) Place a Windows link to thunderbird.exe in any folder (typically the Windows startup folder:  `C:\Users\USERNAME\AppData\Roaming\Microsoft\Windows\Start Menu\Programs\Startup`).
2.) Right-click on the link file > `Properties` (or `Alt`+`Enter`)
3.) Activate `Shortcut` tab
4.) Choose Run: `Minimized`, confirm with OK
5.) Double-click or press `Enter` to open the link

**STR2:**

1.) Windows-Run: cmd
2.) From command line: `start /min thunderbird.exe` (or full path to thunderbird.exe)

For comparison, perform STR1 and STR2 with "notepad.exe".

**Actual results:**

- Thunderbird does *not* start minimized for either STR1 or STR2
- (Beware of artefacts: The program might start minimized if it was already minimized last time when closed before logging off/shutting down)
- Notepad.exe does start minimized

**Expected results:**

- Thunderbird should start minimized according to Windows shortcut or command line options (regardless in which window state it was closed before).

Back to Bug 1679702 Comment 0