Open Bug 129407 Opened 24 years ago Updated 4 years ago

Japanese ascii characters are not converted to standard ascii even though they look the same

Categories

(MailNews Core :: Internationalization, defect)

defect

Tracking

(Not tracked)

Future

People

(Reporter: u32858, Unassigned)

Details

(Keywords: intl)

Attachments

(2 files)

From Bugzilla Helper: User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; U; Linux i686; en-US; rv:0.9.8+) Gecko/20020227 BuildID: 2002022700 Hello Today I found out that as well as Japanese duplications of !! ?? .。 ,、 There is one that affects more than all the others. The japanese '@' does not work if I add it as I acidentally did today. Some one emailed me with emailaddress@hotmail.com so i added it the addres book but it did not find it when i typed in the nick name. Could a check be made when importing and adding new email addresses that if the Japanese '@' is used it is replaced with the standard '@' This also applys to all the input fields on mozilla, and composer Reproducible: Always Steps to Reproduce: 1.try to email emailaddress@hotmail.com 2.try to add it to your address book Actual Results: 3.see that the emailaddress@hotmail.com requires '@' instead Expected Results: should convert japanese AT to standard '@' AT
set browser to utf-8 as headers were missing for this email and site
Since with the current build, email address area only supports ascii, so typing Japanese @ is not considered a right action. But we need to convert it to English @ for address collecting. JG, could you attach a testing mail to this report? Thanks.
Status: UNCONFIRMED → NEW
Ever confirmed: true
Keywords: intl
make sure you use ISO-2022-JP to view it on the charset menu in mozilla
Status: NEW → ASSIGNED
Target Milestone: --- → Future
Hello I have changed the topic to "Japanese ascii characters are not converted to standard ascii even though they look the same" I hope this is ok for me to change,it but it affects all letters not just @ japanese ascii: 123456789@12345.com standard ascii: 123456789@12345.com Also the alphabet has the same problems, not just numbers. the address book allows them to be input, but does not convert them messenger can not find the name if i add it then
Summary: Japanese @ is not supported even though it looks identical → Japanese ascii characters are not converted to standard ascii even though they look the same
This is to do with "double width characters" which CJK typically use on computers for some stuff since CJK characters are usually twice as wide as most Roman characters. Often things look nicer when both types of characters line up perfectly. So they came up with these double width characters. Unicode begrudgingly supports these as well as the normal width characters but they generally lead to problems or at least misunderstandings such as here. Double width characters are *not* ASCII characters.
OK, I have seen them called J-ASCII, but how they can be Japanese and American in the same acronim I don't quite follow. The problem is more too do with the lack of checking for valid email addresses in the address book though. Another test case, 1. enter an name in your address book, test: test@blue.com, <- make sure the comma is there 2. type test in compose 3. see test <"test"@blue.com,> pops up, another problem Perhaps I should rename this bug "Improve validation of email address characters and convert double space Japanese latin characters to the permitted ASCII for email" ? JG
I don't think "Japanese ascii" should be converted to "standard ascii". Many people use "Japanese ascii" to avoid auto-collecting.
Hello Kazhik, I think the email protocol only works with US-ASCII for email addresses, i dont think Japense ascii should be converted for email body, only the email address fields. Perpahs this is covered by an RFC JG
jg, what's your point? do you mean "Japanese ascii" characters should be converted to ascii when editing the address field in the mail compose window? Can you quote RFC?
Hello kazhik, Currently, i can enter "tom" "04@423.com" in the address book and the address book will accept it. Then when i try and email "tom" it does not work. I think it would be useful if when i enter "04@423.com" in the address book it was conveted to "04@423.com" <- US-ASCII. JG ps i use utf-8 for this message.
text/plain; charset=utf-8
utf8 does not seem to be forced, i created an attachement but no diffence, does anyone know how to set it? This is an example J-ASCII email address in utf8 rental@open.net This might look normal, but all characters are wrong, they will not work in standard ASCII it is: rental@open.net but unfortunalty some people have this as there email address, or email me like this, it is easy to make the mistake if the font used to display is very similar There is NO checking for valid emails in the adress book, this is a major problem, i could even enter $"£$"$£ as the email adress and it would be accepted. My point is that these rental@open.net email addresses can be detected and converted to standard email addresses. The adddress book allows me to add them, but the message composition window never finds them if you search by email adress. Ji: can this be upgraded and set a milestone? Regards JG
bug 150946 is for e-mail address validation
Product: MailNews → Core
Product: Core → MailNews Core
QA Contact: ji → i18n
On Thunderbird 3.1 with full-width test case, It causes error "xxx is not a valid e-mail address" when sending mail. It is feature request issue.
Assignee: nhottanscp → nobody
Status: ASSIGNED → NEW
OS: Linux → All
Hardware: x86 → All
Severity: minor → S4
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.

Attachment

General

Creator:
Created:
Updated:
Size: