131409 - LMB dies after clicking a tootip

Status: RESOLVED DUPLICATE of bug 156764

(Core :: XUL, defect)

Description

[Kunihiko Aizawa]

From Bugzilla Helper:
User-Agent: Mozilla/4.61 [en] (OS/2; U)
BuildID:    2002031508

On browser of OS/2 build, I can easily click a tooltip which appears
by putting mouse cursor on tab or button.
After I click a tooltip by right mouse button at once then mozilla browser
components (buttons/tabs/menus/URL field) no longer respond to right mouse
button.

Reproducible: Always
Steps to Reproduce:
1. Put mouse cursor on tab and a tooltip appears.
2. Move mouse cursor onto the tooltip. (Modern skin is easier to do so...)
3. Click the tooltip by right mouse button.


Actual Results:  Browser components (buttons, tabs, menus, URL field...)
doesn't respond to right mouse button until restart mozilla.


Expected Results:  right mouse button keeps working,


This bug originally reported for Linux build at bugzilla-jp:
http://bugzilla.mozilla.gr.jp/show_bug.cgi?id=1877
Original reporter said that dragging site icon (left of URL field) to Personal
toolbar was a case he can put mouse pointer on a tooltip and click it.
However no other guys can reproduce it on Linux and Win32 because it seems
very hard (almost impossible) to click a tooltip by mouse.
So I report this as OS/2 bug at this time, but I think this is hidden bug
of all platform.
In other words, you will get a problem if you can click a tooltip on your
platform.

Comment 1

[Kunihiko Aizawa]

Attachment: Snapshot - I can click tooltip on OS/2 build.

On OS/2, I can easily put mouse pointer on tooltip and click it.

Comment 2

[Kunihiko Aizawa]

Attachment: Snapshot - I cannot click tooltip on Win32

On Win32, I can place mouse pointer on tooltip by dragging site icon
to Personal toolbar. But I cannot click it. How is on Linux...??

Comment 3

[Mike Kaply [:mkaply]]

I don't understand. The bug in Japanese bugzilla was opened against Linux, and 
you cannot drag and drop on the Os/2 build.

What specifically does the bug say about OS/2?

Comment 4

[Kunihiko Aizawa]

Oops, 
I'm very sorry. Please read RMB in a first report as LMB.

Yes, originally this was posted to bugzilla-jp as Linux bug
but no one (excepr eriginal reporter) can reproduce it on Linux yet.
I can reproduce it very easy on OS/2 then I post it as OS/2 bug to here.
(I don't have Linux.)
Anybody can reproduce this on Linux, This should be "all" as OS.

The key of bug is "click tooltip by LMB". No D&D is needed to do it
on OS/2. D&D is a step for Linux and Win32 and this is an only way
to put mouse pointer on tooltip on Win32/Linux.

Comment 5

[Mike Kaply [:mkaply]]

I see this problem on OS/2 but I can't do it on Win32 - as soon as the mouse 
enters the tooltip, it disappears.

Can someone recreate this on Linux?

Comment 6

[Hideo Oshima]

I cannot repluduce on my Linux box.

Comment 7

[Kunihiko Aizawa]

Attachment: testcase to reproduce

Testcase HTML file from original reporter.
Steps to reproduce is also written in this file.

Comment 8

[Kunihiko Aizawa]

Original reporter could reproduce this bug on 0.9.9/Linux and 2002032021/Linux
by the testcase.
He mentioned that using gnome+sawfish or twm for window manager made
no difference.

I tried the testcase with Win32 but I could not reproduce.
(I could click tooltip by LMB but mozilla components never died.)

Comment 9

[Mike Kaply [:mkaply]]

Very weird. On Windows the tooltip passes the mouse event down.

On OS/2 it gets the clicks and dies.

I'll be checking linux again.

Comment 10

[Jessica Blanco]

Similar to bug 113536?

Comment 11

[Mike Kaply [:mkaply]]

Marking as a forward duplicate because 156764 is getting more traction.

*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of 156764 ***