15260 - need test case for imap uid validity changing

Status: RESOLVED WORKSFORME

(MailNews Core :: Networking, defect, P3)

Description

[Phil Peterson]

[e-mail] wrote:

> I'm not sure who the correct person to talk to is, but I figured you might
> know.  CompuServe reported a bug where the Netscape Messenger client crashes
> if a session sits idle, times out and then clicks the Get Msg button.  I
> suspect that the problem in this case is caused by my IMAP server
> invalidating the message cache by sending a new UIDVALIDITY value on the new
> connection, but the client trying to redisplay the message that was
displayed
> from the previous session.
>
> I was able to cause the same problem using the standard UW IMAP server with
> my Unix mailbox.  The step to recreate are:
>
>     1.  Make sure that Netscape is NOT configure to automatically check for
> mail
>     2.  Login to IMAP server
>     3.  Click on a msg to display it.
>     4.  Do nothing until IMAP session is auto-logged out due to being idle
>     5.  Use some other IMAP client to access the same mailbox and delete the
>         message that was being viewed.
>     6.  In the Messenger client, click the "Get Msg" button to force it to
> re-connect
>         and update mail list.
>     7.  Messenger crashes.
>
> I've tried this with the 4.61 version, as well as a 4.7 that I downloaded
> yesterday with the same results.  Having the message you have open deleted
> after a session has timed ouy, but the same symptom will occur with my IMAP
> server , since it currently doesn't have persistent UIDVALIDITY values and
> each time a new session is established, the old message information is
> invalidated.
>
> The crash information from the 4.61 version is:
> NETSCAPE caused an invalid page fault in
> module NETSCAPE.EXE at 0157:00509a32.
> Registers:
> EAX=00000014 CS=0157 EIP=00509a32 EFLGS=00010246
> EBX=00b4f974 SS=015f ESP=00b4f890 EBP=00b4f8e8
> ECX=00000000 DS=015f ESI=00000000 FS=45cf
> EDX=00000000 ES=015f EDI=00d889f0 GS=0000
> Bytes at CS:EIP:
> 8b 41 68 85 c0 74 0b 83 78 08 00 b8 01 00 00 00
> Stack dump:
> 00509a4f 00b4f970 0050dba6 00d889f0 00b4f970 0050e474 00b4f974 00d3e160
> 00000000 00d889f0 0b8f11d8 89080b38 018f0028 bff72866 bff72866 00000035

Comment 1

[David :Bienvenu]

Phil, isn't this a 4.5 bug? Why is it in bugzilla?

Comment 2

[Phil Peterson]

I did't know if this bug is in code that we kept or not. Do you think we
couldn't possibly have the same bug in mozilla?

Comment 3

[David :Bienvenu]

well, it's possible but highly speculative and unlikely, actually. Historically,
the uid validity type crashes have not been in the imap protocol code, but in
the libmsg code, and that code, as you know, is all rewritten.

Comment 4

[David :Bienvenu]

Perhaps we can change this bug to something like "need a test case for uid
validity" and reassign to QA. Unless there's some disagreement, that's what I'd
like to do.

Comment 5

[lchiang]

We'll just try these steps in 5.0 against the UW server.  Karen was going to
test against different types of servers in the next few weeks.

Comment 6

[David :Bienvenu]

You'd have to make sure that the UW server was rolling uid validity for some
reason (accessing an imap mailbox with pine's pop3 client can cause this, I
believe). Rolling UID Validity is an evil thing that most servers do only very
rarely. The compuserve server does it for every connection.

Comment 7

[Karen Huang]

I will try to reproduce this problem and create testcase for 5.0.

Comment 8

[lchiang]

Karen - we may have a test account for the CompuServer IMAP server.  I'll have
to find that info though.

Comment 9

[Phil Peterson]

Craig Haft ([e-mail]) may be able to give you network access to his IMAP
server, especially if we use the va.netscape.com mechanism to get into AOL's
internal network in Dulles.

Comment 10

[Karen Huang]

Since I didn't get the response from Craig([e-mail]), so I tried this test
scenario from the Netscape internal UW server.
I set up one IMAP client/Linux for idle over than 2 hours and deleted same msg
from the same mailbox on the other IMAP client/Win98... There is no crash on the
IMAP client/Linux. I am not able to recreate this problem.
May try AOL network later after I got response from Craig.

Comment 11

[Karen Huang]

I am able to use the va.netscape.com mechanism to get into AOL's internal
networknow now. I will retest it again......

Comment 12

[Karen Huang]

I tried to recreate this problem with the 4.61 and 4.7 versions
by following the exactly setup & steps based on Craig's description.
(The idle time that I tested were: 45 minutes)

But, I still cannot reproduce this problem - No Crash!
And, it seemed that it was working fine for the IMAP uid validity.

I am still waiting for Craig's give me more H/W & OS for clients' information
for recreating this problem again.

But,I will go ahead to create the test cases for IMAP in 5.0

The mapio.txt I got from today's testing is as following:

mozilla IMAP stdout:    URL: Loading
IMAP://hpdev04.office.aol.com?select>|INBOX>       [mkimap4.cpp:10673]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.cache_fetch_responses = TRUE
[mkimap4.cpp:508]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.allow_multiple_folder_connections =
FALSE      [mkimap4.cpp:508]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.expunge_threshold = 20
[mkimap4.cpp:520]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.auto_subscribe = TRUE
[mkimap4.cpp:508]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.auto_unsubscribe = TRUE
[mkimap4.cpp:508]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.auto_subscribe_on_open = TRUE
[mkimap4.cpp:508]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.new_mail_get_headers = FALSE
[mkimap4.cpp:508]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.fetch_by_chunks = TRUE
[mkimap4.cpp:508]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.chunk_fast = 2 [mkimap4.cpp:520]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.chunk_ideal = 4
[mkimap4.cpp:520]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.chunk_add = 2048
[mkimap4.cpp:520]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.chunk_size = 6144
[mkimap4.cpp:520]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.min_chunk_size_threshold = 8192
[mkimap4.cpp:520]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.max_chunk_size = 81920
[mkimap4.cpp:520]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.mime_parts_on_demand = TRUE
[mkimap4.cpp:508]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.mime_parts_on_demand_threshold = 30000
[mkimap4.cpp:520]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.optimize_header_dl = TRUE
[mkimap4.cpp:508]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.io_tunnelling = FALSE
[mkimap4.cpp:508]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.tunnelling_threshold = 400
[mkimap4.cpp:520]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.hide_unused_namespaces = TRUE
[mkimap4.cpp:508]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.hide_other_users = FALSE
[mkimap4.cpp:508]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    PREFS: mail.imap.noop_check_count = 5
[mkimap4.cpp:520]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:NA:NET:RD: * OK hpdev04
IMAP 4.1 server ready    [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:NA:NET:WR: 1 capability

        [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:NA:NET:RD: * CAPABILITY
IMAP4rev1 XAOL-ENVELOPE XAOL-NETMAIL XAOL-OPTION [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:NA:NET:RD: 1 OK
CAPABILITY completed     [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:NA:NET:WR: 2 login
"maildev1" "mail3141"

        [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:NA:NET:RD: 2 OK LOGIN
completed  [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:WR: 3 lsub "" "*"

        [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: * LSUB
(\Noinferiors) NIL INBOX        [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: * LSUB
(\Noinferiors) NIL "Sent Items" [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: 3 OK LSUB
completed    [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:WR: 4 list ""
"INBOX"

        [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: * LIST
(\Noinferiors) NIL INBOX        [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: 4 OK LIST
completed    [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:WR: 5 select
"INBOX"

        [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: * 1 EXISTS
[mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: * OK
[UIDVALIDITY 4550172] UID validity status [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: * OK [UIDNEXT
2] predicted next UID    [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: * FLAGS
(\Deleted \Seen)       [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: * OK
[PERMANENTFLAGS (\Seen)]  [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: 5 OK
[READ-WRITE] SELECT completed     [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:WR: 6 UID
fetch 1:* (FLAGS)

        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: * 1 FETCH
(UID 1 FLAGS (\Seen))  [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: 6 OK UID
FETCH completed [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:WR: 7 UID
fetch 1 (UID RFC822.SIZE FLAGS BODY.PEEK[HEADER.FIELDS (From To Cc Subject Date
Priority X-Priority Message-ID References Newsgroups Return-Receipt-To
Disposition-Notification-To)])

        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: * 1 FETCH
(UID 1 RFC822.SIZE 563 BODY[HEADER.FIELDS ("FROM" "TO" "CC" "SUBJECT" "DATE"
"PRIORITY" "X-PRIORITY" "MESSAGE-ID" "REFERENCES" "NEWSGROUPS"
"RETURN-RECEIPT-TO" "DISPOSITION-NOTIFICATION-TO")] {306}  [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:STREAM:OPEN Size:
563: Begin Message Download Stream     [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    STREAM: Begin Message Download Stream Event
[mkimap4.cpp:948]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: From:
[e-mail]      [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
Message-ID: <[e-mail]>  [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: Date:
Fri, 3 Sep 1999 14:33:40 EDT       [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: Subject:
hi ho ho hi     [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: To:
[e-mail], [e-mail], [e-mail], [e-mail],
[mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
[e-mail], [e-mail], [e-mail],    [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
[e-mail], [e-mail], [e-mail]   [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
[mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:  FLAGS
(\Seen))  [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:STREAM:CLOSE:
Normal Message End Download Stream [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    STREAM: Normal End Message Download Stream Event
[mkimap4.cpp:1280]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: 7 OK UID
FETCH completed [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    URL: Loading
IMAP://hpdev04.office.aol.com?fetch>UID>|INBOX>1   [mkimap4.cpp:10673]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:WR: 8 UID
fetch 1 (UID RFC822.SIZE BODY[])

        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: * 1 FETCH
(UID 1 RFC822.SIZE 563 BODY[] {563}    [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:STREAM:OPEN Size:
563: Begin Message Download Stream     [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    STREAM: Begin Message Download Stream Event
[mkimap4.cpp:948]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
Return-path: [e-mail]       [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: From:
[e-mail]      [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
Message-ID: <[e-mail]>  [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: Date:
Fri, 3 Sep 1999 14:33:40 EDT       [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: Subject:
hi ho ho hi     [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: To:
[e-mail], [e-mail], [e-mail], [e-mail],
[mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
[e-mail], [e-mail], [e-mail],    [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
[e-mail], [e-mail], [e-mail]   [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
MIME-Version: 1.0        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
Content-Type: text/html; charset="us-ascii"      [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit  [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: X-Mailer:
AOL 4.0 for Windows 95 sub 14  [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
[mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
<HTML><PRE><FONT  SIZE=3 FAMILY="SANSSERIF" FACE="Verdana" LANG="0">hi
there</PRE></HTML>        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: )
[mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:STREAM:CLOSE:
Normal Message End Download Stream [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    STREAM: Normal End Message Download Stream Event
[mkimap4.cpp:1280]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: 8 OK UID
FETCH completed [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    URL: Loading
IMAP://hpdev04.office.aol.com?select>|INBOX>       [mkimap4.cpp:10673]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    HOST?:S-INBOX:NET:WR: xxxx logout

        [mkimap4.cpp:9987]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    HOST?:S-INBOX:CONTROL:From TellThreadToDie: LOGOUT
[mkimap4.cpp:9987]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:NA:NET:RD: * OK hpdev04
IMAP 4.1 server ready    [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:NA:NET:WR: 1 login
"maildev1" "mail3141"

        [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:NA:NET:RD: 1 OK LOGIN
completed  [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:WR: 2 select
"INBOX"

        [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: * 1 EXISTS
[mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: * OK
[UIDVALIDITY 4553077] UID validity status [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: * OK [UIDNEXT
2] predicted next UID    [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: * FLAGS
(\Deleted \Seen)       [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: * OK
[PERMANENTFLAGS (\Seen)]  [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:A:NET:RD: 2 OK
[READ-WRITE] SELECT completed     [mkimap4.cpp:10014]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:WR: 3 UID
fetch 1:* (FLAGS)

        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: * 1 FETCH
(UID 1 FLAGS (\Seen))  [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: 3 OK UID
FETCH completed [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:WR: 4 UID
fetch 1 (UID RFC822.SIZE FLAGS BODY.PEEK[HEADER.FIELDS (From To Cc Subject Date
Priority X-Priority Message-ID References Newsgroups Return-Receipt-To
Disposition-Notification-To)])

        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: * 1 FETCH
(UID 1 RFC822.SIZE 563 BODY[HEADER.FIELDS ("FROM" "TO" "CC" "SUBJECT" "DATE"
"PRIORITY" "X-PRIORITY" "MESSAGE-ID" "REFERENCES" "NEWSGROUPS"
"RETURN-RECEIPT-TO" "DISPOSITION-NOTIFICATION-TO")] {306}  [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:STREAM:OPEN Size:
563: Begin Message Download Stream     [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    STREAM: Begin Message Download Stream Event
[mkimap4.cpp:948]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: From:
[e-mail]      [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
Message-ID: <[e-mail]>  [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: Date:
Fri, 3 Sep 1999 14:33:40 EDT       [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: Subject:
hi ho ho hi     [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: To:
[e-mail], [e-mail], [e-mail], [e-mail],
[mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
[e-mail], [e-mail], [e-mail],    [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
[e-mail], [e-mail], [e-mail]   [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:
[mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD:  FLAGS
(\Seen))  [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:STREAM:CLOSE:
Normal Message End Download Stream [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    STREAM: Normal End Message Download Stream Event
[mkimap4.cpp:1280]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: 4 OK UID
FETCH completed [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    URL: Loading
IMAP://hpdev04.office.aol.com?select>|INBOX>       [mkimap4.cpp:10673]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:WR: 5 noop

        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: 5 OK NOOP
completed      [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:WR: 6 UID
fetch 2:* (FLAGS)

        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: * 1 FETCH
(UID 1 FLAGS (\Seen))  [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: 6 OK UID
FETCH completed [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    URL: Loading
IMAP://hpdev04.office.aol.com?select>|INBOX>       [mkimap4.cpp:10673]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:WR: 7 noop

        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: 7 OK NOOP
completed      [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:WR: 8 UID
fetch 2:* (FLAGS)

        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: * 1 FETCH
(UID 1 FLAGS (\Seen))  [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: 8 OK UID
FETCH completed [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    URL: Loading
IMAP://hpdev04.office.aol.com?select>|INBOX>       [mkimap4.cpp:10673]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:WR: 9 noop

        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: 9 OK NOOP
completed      [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:WR: 10 UID
fetch 2:* (FLAGS)

        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: * 1 FETCH
(UID 1 FLAGS (\Seen))  [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: 10 OK UID
FETCH completed        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
mozilla IMAP stdout:    URL: Loading
IMAP://hpdev04.office.aol.com?select>|INBOX>       [mkimap4.cpp:10673]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:WR: 11 noop

        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: 11 OK
NOOP completed     [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:WR: 12 UID
fetch 2:* (FLAGS)

        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: * 1 FETCH
(UID 1 FLAGS (\Seen))  [mkimap4.cpp:9982]
imapIOthread IMAP stdout:       hpdev04.office.aol.com:S-INBOX:NET:RD: 12 OK UID
FETCH completed        [mkimap4.cpp:9982]

Comment 13

[Karen Huang]

Accept.

Comment 14

[Karen Huang]

Already updated on the IMAP Test Spec of Netscape Messaging Server.
(This is first draft, not the final....will keep updating for more enhancement)
Will also update to reflect for the other IMAP servers' Test Specs as well.

Comment 15

[Karen Huang]

Attachment: IMAP Test Spec

Comment 16

[cwilkes]

In Netscape 4.7, 4.72, and Mozilla have a problem with using "courier" IMAP 
which is a version of IMAP that supports Qmail's Maildir structure.
According to http://www.inter7.com/courierimap/BUGS.txt the problem is with 
Netscape's IMAP implementation.
What happens is that you can get mail when you first start up the client, and 
you can send it.  However, if you try and get mail again it will say that the 
server responsed with an error.  Closing down the client and restarting fixes 
it.

Comment 17

[lchiang]

karen - can this be closed?  Is your test case updated?

Comment 18

[Karen Huang]

I created another new IMAP test spec for next release.
Above Test Spec was old.
I need to double check again to ensure this has been covered in my new test spec 
and close this bug afterwards. Change QA Contact to me.

Comment 19

[Matthias Versen [:Matti]]

[e-mail]: can this closed ? (old bug...)

Comment 20

[Andrew Hagen]

--> IMAP.

Comment 21

[David :Bienvenu]

yes, we handle uid validity rolling...