Closed Bug 2025131 Opened 8 months ago Closed 7 months ago

Firefox translation fails to translate website that declares the wrong language

Categories

(Firefox :: Translations, defect)

Firefox 150
defect

Tracking

()

RESOLVED DUPLICATE of bug 2026738

People

(Reporter: danweiss, Unassigned)

References

Details

I encountered an issue with the Firefox translation feature on this website:

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/archive/blogs/technet/itasupport/sendsas-step-by-step

The language on the page is Italian, but the <html>, <body>, and <main> elements all contain the attribute lang="en-us" Because of this, the Firefox translation feature skips over those elements, believing the text is not in Italian.

If I use the Inspector (F12), search for lang="en-us", then manually edit every element to change the attribute into lang="it-it", then the translation feature will successfully translate the page from Italian into English.


Steps to reproduce:

Should happen:

  • Page should be translated from Italian to English

Actually happens:

  • Page remains in Italian

Workaround:

  • Load the page
  • Press F12 to open dev tools, and pick the Inspector tab
  • In "Search HTML", look for lang="en-us"
  • Double click on "en-us" on the <html> tag, replace it with "it-it"
  • Next result
  • Double click on "en-us" on the <body> tag, replace it with "it-it"
  • Next result
  • Double click on "en-us" on the <main> tag, replace it with "it-it"
  • Press F12 to close dev tools
  • Press Menu button -> Translate page
  • Select "Italian" to "English" and click Translate
  • Page now translates from Italian to English
See Also: → 2026738

Hi Dan, thank you for filing this bug.

At the time of writing, the current behavior is expected in Firefox, so this isn't necessarily a defect as filed.

The website itself is configured incorrectly: a node with text content that is truly in Italian should not have a lang="en-us" attribute on it. Right now Firefox is configured to trust those lang attributes since they are placed on nodes explicitly by the website author.

However, I do think that we could probably improve upon this, and change the expected behavior in Firefox to double check with the language detector. As such, I've filed Bug 2026738, which I will now mark this bug as a duplicate of.

I've filed Bug 2026738 as a "Good First Bug" and assigned myself as a mentor. It should be a fairly self-contained improvement for a new contributor. If you are a developer, then you are more than welcome to try it out yourself.

Thanks again!

Status: UNCONFIRMED → RESOLVED
Closed: 7 months ago
Duplicate of bug: 2026738
Resolution: --- → DUPLICATE
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.