Closed Bug 2094576 Opened 3 days ago Closed 23 hours ago

'Data synced across devices' selection changes after resetting the password and logging back in on PDS(PerDeviceSync)

Categories

(Firefox :: Sync, defect)

Firefox 162
defect

Tracking

()

RESOLVED INVALID
Tracking Status
firefox162 --- affected

People

(Reporter: rpopovici, Unassigned)

References

(Blocks 1 open bug)

Details

Found in:
Nightly version: 162.0a1(2026-11-17)

Affected versions:
Nightly versions: 162.0a1(2026-11-17)

Tested platforms:
Affected platforms: Windows 11 and Ubuntu 26

Preconditions:
Have the following prefs set to true in about:config:
services.sync.perDeviceEngineChoices = true (PDS profile)
Profile 1 with Legacy1(pref off): is signed into the same sync account.
Profile 2 with Legacy2(pref off): is signed into the same sync account.
Profile 3 with PDS(pref on): is signed into the same sync account.

Steps to reproduce:

  1. Legacy1: set choices to Bookmarks + Tabs only and sync.
  2. Legacy2: sync.
  3. PDS: set choices to History + Payment methods only and sync.
  4. Reset the account password on accounts.firefox.com. Don’t use a recovery key.
  5. PDS: sign in again and sync.
  6. Legacy1, then Legacy-2: sign in again and sync.

Expected result:
PDS keeps History + Payment methods and both legacy devices keep Bookmarks + Tabs.

Actual result:
PDS device: "Bookmarks + Tabs" now appears in 'Data synced across devices' on the PDS device and the preference 'services.sync. perDeviceEngineChoices' is changed to false.

Regression range:
Not a regression as recently implemented.

Blocks: 2072032
Has STR: --- → yes
QA Whiteboard: [QA-5954][qa-found-in-c162][S3]
QA Whiteboard: [QA-5954][qa-found-in-c162][S3] → [QA-5954][qa-found-in-c162][S2]

The preference changing to false is expected as a result of this being default false right now.

In step 5, before signing in again, the preference needs to be changed to true.

In step 5, before signing in again, the preference needs to be changed to true.

That's (theoretically) only correct if you explicitly did a "sign out" / "disconnect". Just entering a "need reauth" state should not change that preference, nor should it change local device choices. The bug as written makes sense if the per-device pref did change, but I can't reproduce that.

If anywhere in the process that PDS profile was explicitly disconnected it would be expected, but I could not reproduce; my PDS profile stayed per-device, kept its choices, legacy profile stayed correct.

I agree with Mark here and couldn't reproduce the pref flipping without either sign out or explicit disconnect. With the pref off the actual result is the expected. Going to close this as invalid!

Status: NEW → RESOLVED
Closed: 23 hours ago
Resolution: --- → INVALID
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.