44740 - Window repaint problem for the Customize Sidebar window

Status: VERIFIED DUPLICATE of bug 28244

(Core :: XUL, defect, P3)

Description

[Margaret Chan]

Overview Description:  In the Customize Sidebar window, there is a repaint
problem.  Visible in the 2 attached screenshot (one is taken from Netscape6
PR1 on the Windows platform and the other one is taken from mozilla M16 download
for the Solaris platform.  Both screenshots show that some of the icons stay
outside of the white text box on the left side of the window.

Steps to Reproduce:

On the Windows platform:

1)  Get to the "Customize Sidebar" window.
2)  Open some folders on the left side up to a point that you need to use the
    scroll bar to scroll down.
3)  Scroll down for a while
4)  Close some of the folders
5)  Some of the icons will stay outside of the text box.

On the Solaris platform:

1)  Get to the "Customize Sidebar" window.
2)  Open the folders under the International folder.
3)  Continue to open as many folders as you can.  Up to some point, you will
    see that some of the icons will stay outside of the text box.

Actual Results:

Icons stay outside of the text box sometimes

Expected Results:

Icons should stay inside of the text area all the time

Reproducibility:

Easily reproducible

Build Date & Platform Bug Found:

As mentioned above, it can be reproduced on Windows platform (Netscape 6 PR1)
and Solaris platform (M16 download).  

Additional Builds and Platforms Tested On:

None

Additional Information:

2 screen shots attached.

Comment 1

[Margaret Chan]

Attachment: Customize Sidebar Window Repaint Problem (screenshot 1)

Comment 2

[Margaret Chan]

Attachment: Customize Sizebar window repaint problem (screenshot 2)

Comment 3

[Brendan Donohoe]

Not sure exactly which group is responsible for this, but I've seen this 
happen on Mac and a similar result when the sidebar gets vertically 
cramped.  Is it a Tree issue?  A layout issue?  Something else?

Reassigning to XP Toolkit/Widgets.

Comment 4

[John Morrison]

This was fixed with the landing of the new tree code (post M16). 
Please reopen, though, if this can be reproduced in a current build.
Thanks.



*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of 28244 ***

Comment 5

[John Morrison]

verified duplicate