Closed Bug 55079 Opened 26 years ago Closed 25 years ago

can't Discontinue a link inside a list (in context menu)

Categories

(Core :: DOM: Editor, defect, P3)

defect

Tracking

()

VERIFIED INVALID
mozilla0.9.1

People

(Reporter: sujay, Assigned: cmanske)

Details

using 9/29 build of netscape 1) launch netscape 2) launch composer 3) click on bullet list 4) insert some text 5) make that text a link to something 6) click right after the link 7) right mouse click to bring up context menu 8) notice Discontinue Link is not in the list, it should be there. it works if you don't have that link inside a list...
removing Joe, adding Brade
adding myself back on. I bet I at least have to review this, assuming I don't have to fix it, which I'm not yet assuming.... :-)
future (per discussion with sujay)
Summary: can't Discontinue a link inside a list → can't Discontinue a link inside a list (in context menu)
Target Milestone: --- → Future
may be related to bug 55921
setting to assigned to get off the new radar
Status: NEW → ASSIGNED
Still present in M8. Nominating nsbeta1 and mozilla1.0 to try to get this bug escalated. Folks -- this is a huge usability blocker for Composer on editing very basic HTML pages. Bullet lists are extremely common in web pages, as are links within text. But because of this bug, once I create a link in a bullet, I'm unable to terminate it and add more text! Nav4 composer had a similar problem, but you could work around it by pasting a space or other text after the link and continuing typing. But this workaround doesn't work in Mozilla M8 Composer! Will file related bug on that. This problem renders Composer unusable for editing any web pages that have a bullet with a link at the end if you want to add more text after the link. (A very common case!) Only workaround is to open Nav4 Composer and use it to do that operation. Let's please unFuture this bug and assign it to a milestone.
Keywords: mozilla1.0, nsbeta1
Filed bug 75035, can't paste flat text after a link which is at the end of a bullet, on the possibly-related issue.
well, there are at least 3 ways to get out of the link element, if the link is at the end of a line -- just hit the end key and you will get out of the link, or select Format|Discontinue Link. In addition, if you select the Remove LInk from the Context menu, the link will also be teminated.
[ Eric finally has a bright idea. ] After several hours of feeling frustrated that I couldn't edit my page with M8 Composer, it *FINALLY* dawned on me that the wording of this bug report implied that perhaps there was another way besides the context menu to discontinue the link, and sure enough, I finally found the wonderful Discontinue Link feature on the pulldown menu. So it's not the case after all that this link renders Composer unable to edit such docs; you just have to be smart enough to find the option on the pulldown menu. Sorry for missing that; I'm now once again editing happily with Composer. However, from a usability standpoint, there's still reason for concern about whether ordinary users (and even longtime Nav4 Composer users) will find that menu option if it takes this long for a 4-year Netscape veteran who actually searched & read mozilla bug reports to figure it out. [Or maybe I'm just dumb. ;->] I'm withdrawing by mozilla1.0 and nsbeta1 nominations as I expect you have more urgent issues to address, but I hope we can add Discontinue Link to the context menu as enhancement relatively soon thereafter to increase the discoverability of this powerful new Composer feature for dumb users like me. Keep up the great work--M8's really shaping up nicely!!!
Keywords: mozilla1.0, nsbeta1
let me move this forward to mozilla1.0, maybe cmanske can get this in for that milestone, however, we need to inform i18n on the possible menu change. Charley/Joe -- could we get this into the context menu? The Discontinue Link option?
Assignee: beppe → cmanske
Status: ASSIGNED → NEW
Target Milestone: Future → mozilla1.0
This should be fairly easy to do and should be done in 9.1.
Status: NEW → ASSIGNED
Target Milestone: mozilla1.0 → mozilla0.9.1
The issue is enabling the already-existing context menu item. There are no i18n issues.
When I create the list item first, type text, and then select text and make a link, it is true that "Discontinue Link" does not show up in the context popup menu. The reason is that a <br> is inserted after the new link (<a> tag). So the menu item isn't actually needed: simply clicking left mouse button past the end and typing adds text that is *not* part of the link. If you make a link with some text, then click on a List button to make it a list item, this <br> is not there. Under those circumstances, "Discontinue Link" *does* appear in the context menu and can be use to stop the link. Thus "Discontinue Link" appears only when it is needed and I conclude there is no bug here. As far as the accessibility issue, many have asked for the button we have in 4.x toolbar which killed both links and all other text styles. In current product, we decided it was better to separate these into 2 commands: Remove/ Discontinue Text Style, and Remove/Discontinue Link. We got lots of feedback that users couldn't figure out what the old button did, so we didn't include it in mozilla. Note that there is are "hotkey" bindings Ctrl+Shift+K for text styles and Ctrl+Shift+L for links. I'll leave open for some discussion, but intend to resolve as "invalid" if there's no strong dissent.
No response on this issue, so I believe it is solved.
Status: ASSIGNED → RESOLVED
Closed: 25 years ago
Resolution: --- → INVALID
verified in 4/16 build.
Status: RESOLVED → VERIFIED
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.