56717 - Browser crashes when click [x] to close the 'Page Source' window

Status: VERIFIED DUPLICATE of bug 53953

(SeaMonkey :: General, defect, P3)

Description

[Robert Dettmann]

If only one instance of Mozilla M18 is open and you close the view window for
page source, then the browser is closed, too.

Comment 1

[Fabian Guisset]

worksforme on build 2000101420 win32.
Robert, what OS are you using? Does it give you any message before closing?
Any additional information is welcome.
Fabian.

Comment 2

[Robert Dettmann]

Hi Fabian,
Why you ask me for the OS ? - From the Header at top of the bugzilla report you 
can read, that my using OS is Windows 2000. This descripted bug you can see 
sometimes only. Open an online!!!-page + View the page source + Close the 
source window = Mozilla is closed, too !

Comment 3

[Doron Rosenberg (IBM)]

cannot see this on 2000101604 win98 (post m18)

Comment 4

[kirun]

After trying a few sites, I got M18 (SVG build, windows95) to crash viewing
source of yahoo.com

MOZILLA caused an invalid page fault in
module <unknown> at 0000:01bf700b.
Registers:
EAX=0242be00 CS=014f EIP=01bf700b EFLGS=00010282
EBX=80000000 SS=0157 ESP=c223b2b9 EBP=0070f8b0
ECX=01bf6f5c DS=0157 ESI=0242be28 FS=3277
EDX=00000000 ES=0157 EDI=bf700401 GS=5467
Bytes at CS:EIP:
01 04 70 bf 01 0c 70 bf 01 0c 70 bf 01 14 70 bf
Stack dump:

Comment 5

[Robert Dettmann]

Build ID: 2000091312
From about 10 views was 1 failed and also another day no bad things happens !
You see in Windows 2000 no dump. Only closing without terrible messages !

Comment 6

[Asa Dotzler [:asa]]

unable to reproduce this crash/closing with 101608 mozilla trunk builds on NR4,
MacOS9 or RedHat6.2  Closing the viewsource window does not crash me.

Comment 7

[jorge o. castro]

WFM Linux 2000102009. 

Comment 8

[jorge o. castro]

works for doronr too, marking WFM ...

Comment 9

[Robert Dettmann]

I think it's very arrogant to ignore this maybe simple failure for your mind 
and set the status to 'Resolved'. This is really a hard bug, how you can see 
later. It seems there are more reasons to kill mozilla with its preview 
windows. In one other case i let a frame 'src'-attribute to blank, because i 
want to describe it later dynamic. If you then open the frame-preview window 
over such a blank frame and after closing the preview window each time mozilla 
crashes with an unhandled exception.
Example: http://212.223.75.2/dev/futue/mozilla/bug/default.asp
For reproducing this error you must open the frame-preview window over the 
upper left frame.

Comment 10

[Robert Dettmann]

Sorry for the wrong link !
Here's the right:
http://212.223.75.2/dev/future/mozilla/bug/default.asp

Comment 11

[Doron Rosenberg (IBM)]

did you view source of the frame or how?

Comment 12

[Asa Dotzler [:asa]]

Robert Dettmann, you filed a bug report that said closing the view source window
caused the browser window to also close (I assume you meant that it caused the
browser to crash).  I have tested this with about 15 different URLs on Mac,
win32 and Linux and have not been able to reproduce this problem.  In order to
triage this bug any further we need to be able to reproduce it.  As the reporter
of the bug you have the powerto reopen the bug report.  It would be very helpful
if you could figure out a set of specific steps to reproduce this bug with some
consistency.

Comment 13

[Robert Dettmann]

Maybe cartoons are better than words. Here you can see a mozilla live crash:

http://212.223.75.2/dev/future/mozilla/bug/ViewBug.wmv ( 75k)
http://212.223.75.2/dev/future/mozilla/bug/ViewBug.avi (457k)
http://212.223.75.2/dev/future/mozilla/bug/ViewBug.zip ( 54k - packed avi)

I think mozilla is still very unstable, because daily i have explore more and 
more bugs. Why ? - Windows 2000 will be not accepting slovelny code. You should 
know the negative effects of older Microsoft-OS's. In NT 3.51 i you could make 
memory leaks and nevertheless the program runs at first. And later after many 
side effects it crashes. In NT 4.0 the same program was not running. But you 
could make another mistakes without consequences. And now in Windows 2000 many 
developers get the receipt for theirs unclean code.
Ok, i know that this statement is overload of layout...

Comment 14

[Doron Rosenberg (IBM)]

what buildid are you using? M18 is too old for this bug.

Comment 15

[Asa Dotzler [:asa]]

Robert Dettmann, are the above links meant to demonstrate a crash "after closing
the 'Page Source' window"?  I don't understand.

Comment 16

[timeless]

This was fixed post m18 iirc, close is the wrong word. You meant crash. In the 
future please use talkback builds.  Updating summary and resolving as a 
duplicate of bug 53953

*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of 53953 ***

Comment 17

[timeless]

vrfy dupe