Closed Bug 72142 Opened 25 years ago Closed 25 years ago

Add XSLT component to installers

Categories

(Core :: XSLT, defect, P2)

defect

Tracking

()

VERIFIED FIXED
mozilla0.9.1

People

(Reporter: hjtoi-bugzilla, Assigned: peterv)

References

Details

(Whiteboard: [fixinhand])

Attachments

(1 file)

Over to Peter. See how I did this for XML Extras: http://bugscape/show_bug.cgi?id=3734 (there is a patch in the comments - it is just a couple of lines per file): mozilla/xpinstall/packager/packages-*
Assignee: kvisco → peterv
Keywords: mozilla0.9
On second thought, XSLT is so big and not everyone will need it, I think it should be configurable in the installer (a la Chatzilla). It should be on by default, however, so that people who do a typical install will get it. I know of only one browser that has support for XSLT, and that is IE, so that is our model and competition here. Almost weekly I read a message from someone complaining that Mozilla/Netscape 6 does not support XML, yet when I read the message it is clear it is the XSLT support that is missing. But for the users it feels like there is no XML support. MS has done a good job in convincing people XML is useless with XSLT. We need to support it.
Target Milestone: --- → mozilla0.9
Sean, could you help Peter here?
Once Peterv has checked in patches to the all the appropriate packages-[platform], I can help with creating the .xpi files for them. Are you *sure* you want to have the XSLT files in their own .xpi files? Please confirm before any work begins. Do we need input from marketing folks as well?
If it's big (> 500K?) we may well want it optional so the "browser only" download size is kept smaller. Easy enough either way, this is more of a marketing type call. We can also do it differently for the Netscape vs. Mozilla release if there are strong feelings in two different directions, but of course it would be easiest if they are the same.
I don't have optmized bits around, but the debug DLL size on Windows is 329kb + 1kb for the typelib. Personally I wouldn't mind if it always gets installed. But it would be nice if ALL of the noncritical parts would be configurable. They are not now, so dunno how important this is.
A few comments: code size may change. We didn't look at codesize yet, and there has been no effort up to now to remove unused code. libtransformiix.so is 1.169kB on sparc solaris, optimized&stripped. i386 code is less, here the stuff from the win32 bins by peterv: 114688 transformiix.dll 397 transformiix.xpt Axel
It looks like it will have to be a seperate .xpi given the indicated size. Peverv, do you need help with patching the packages-[platform] files? (added kmurray so someone in marketing is in the loop)
It would be great to know how pervasive the use of XSLT is today, and what the trend is for tomorrow. Do many sites use this? It probably makes sense to have this *off* by default in the typical config, but checked *on* in the custom config. Is there a compelling reason that we should add download size on typical for something like this? PLease provide examples of sites that currently employ this, and what the long term user benefit will be.
My worry is that no end user would be able to understand what they are getting if we offer them "XSLT" in some, but not all, installation packages. Any progress on determining whether the code size can be reduced?
As I said earlier, the "marketing" reason would be that without XSLT support most users think there is no XML support in Mozilla/Netscape 6. The reason is that IE does that, and Microsoft has convinced most people that they can only use XML if they use XSLT transformation to convert it to HTML (which is totally bogus, but we can't do much about that now). So my take is: either have it installed always, or make it optional but have it on by default (because of the above reasons).
trying to shut down 0.9 so we can open the tree for 0.9.1 development
Target Milestone: mozilla0.9 → mozilla0.9.1
I am attaching a patch. I haven't put it in it's own jar, I think that this is too technical to have as an install option. Zipped sizes of the binaries are 112k on Linux, 108k on Mac and 59k on Windows.
Status: NEW → ASSIGNED
Priority: -- → P2
Assuming no chrome is needed, r=sgehani. If chrome is need, please attach the jar.mn changes.
No chrome.
r=nisheeth
sr=jst
Partially checked in. Due to Linux bustage, we are not in the default build for Linux. (See bug 72141)
Whiteboard: [fixinhand]
I just checked in the patches to enable Transformiix on Linux. For now, OS/2 doesn't build Linux. Once bug 53518 is fixed, we'll enable Transformiix on OS/2 also.
Status: ASSIGNED → RESOLVED
Closed: 25 years ago
Resolution: --- → FIXED
bitching buttons, verfication spam
Status: RESOLVED → VERIFIED
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.

Attachment

General

Created:
Updated:
Size: