905105 - [Contacts] When merging contacts after updating one, the last name of the original contact is changed

Status: VERIFIED INVALID

(Firefox OS Graveyard :: Gaia::Contacts, defect)

Description

[isabelrios]

Unagi device master 08/14 build:
Gecko-3364547
Gaia-cecd0d7
ref ril

There should be at least two contact in the contact list.
Contact1- Name: Sam, Last Name: South, Phone: 0000
Contact2- Name: Tom, Last Name: Wall, Phone: 1234

STR
1. Tap on Contact2, edit the phone number so it is 0000
2. When the Duplicates found screen is shown, tap on Merge

EXPECTED
The original contact is kept and the info coming from the contact which has been edited is merged correctly. The Name and Last name of the original contact should not change in this case.

ACTUAL
The last name of the original contact, Contact1 is changed with the last name of the Contact being edited.
As a result, there is one contact: Name: Sam, Last Name: Wall, Phone Number: 0000

Comment 1

[Salvador de la Puente González [:salva]]

According to the current specification, the behavior is right since the last name "South" is longer than last name "Wall" so the last is updated. Ayman, please, confirm this is the desired behaviour right now.

Let's mark this as invalid, Next Monday we will have a talk about evolving the merging procedure and then we will open new files to track it.

Comment 2

[rafael.marquez]

Close the bug, the wireframes are clear: 

4.2 Last name
4.1.1 Where the last name that is associated to the contact from where the 'find and merge duplicate contacts' functionality was launched constitutes a shorter string than the last name of a suggested contact from the contact list that is
merging with them, the last name of the suggested contact overwrites the content of the last name field for this contact.