Closed Bug 1104030 Opened 11 years ago Closed 11 years ago

Consider testing alternative Tile for EOY

Categories

(Mozilla Foundation Communications :: Website, task)

x86
macOS
task
Not set
normal

Tracking

(Not tracked)

RESOLVED WONTFIX

People

(Reporter: adam, Assigned: andrea)

Details

(Whiteboard: [EOYFR2014][comms][studiomofo][assets])

Attachments

(1 file)

Looking at the initial data coming in, Tiles looks like an area to explore / test further for EOY. We're getting a good number of visitors from the EOY donation Tile (~2k/day) but the conversion rate is very low compared to other channels (0.4% vs 12.4% for the Snippet right now). Can we review the Tile design and messaging in relation to our current best performing snippet? (Snippet screenshot attached). Two hypotheses: (1) Our new donation form is so minimal, it doesn't actually have a donation 'ask' on it (i.e. we rely on donations to...) and the tile doesn't do this either. So we're not yet giving these people the info/motivation to donate. (2) Tiles are only shown to users without a browsing history (ie new FF users) so this is not an audience who already knows as much about Mozilla. -- I think our quickest opportunity is to work on the tile messaging, but another option is to test adding the 'ask' onto the donation page, and see what impact that has for this audience. -- @Andrea, I'm assigning the ticket to you as a starting point, but please CC people and prioritize as required in the overall scheme.
Flags: needinfo?(andrea)
I am adding Paul to this bug since he works with the Tiles team on our tiles. Tile is experimental so it is possible this simply is not a promising audience for donations -- that said... I think we can try both 1 and 2 without too much effort. 1. I think we should have a variant of the winning donation form that includes a very short 2-3 sentence "pitch"; and 2. I think we should possibly switch the order of the current donation tiles so that the static tile says "donate before Dec 31" and on-hover it says "Your gift protects the open Web" or something like this. Right now it's reversed, so people don't know that they're being asked for a donation until they click (unlikely to attract the right audience in the first place). Paul can you ask the Tiles team if they'd be willing to swap different tile configurations in for testing? Also, I heard a rumor that Tiles allow animations... mind double checking all that is possible in that Tile space that we might consider?
Flags: needinfo?(andrea) → needinfo?(paulj)
Asking the Tiles team now and will get back to you shortly on all of these questions.
Flags: needinfo?(paulj)
Here's what the tile team's response: Currently the product cannot do A/B testing in a single market. We could run Tile A for 3 days, Tile B for 3 days, etc. The answer to your second question is YES but we only allow one animated tile per market per New Tab at a time. I will check with Aaron on the specs for an animated tile and see when the firefox 10th anniversary tile is due to be retired. Psyched to hear we are driving traffic.
pinging Adam to see if we want to do this or not given time / ROI
Status: ASSIGNED → NEW
Flags: needinfo?(adam)
I'd still love to push this tiles work a little harder, as it is decent traffic. @Paul, would you have time to guide this by any chance? I don't think there are many hours needed here, just someone to keep it in focus. If we can write / artwork say 3 further variations of the EOY appeal then ask the Tiles team to swap them out intermittently (whatever sequencing works best for them). Then so long as we tag each tile variant with different ID using the campaign URL builder we can see if any of these messages impact final conversion.
Flags: needinfo?(adam) → needinfo?(paulj)
Sorry for the delayed response - I can totally guide. If you give me the creative assets I can see what the tiles team can do. They haven't had any heads up that this is coming so I'd not sure what there turnaround time will be like over the holidays. When do we think we'd have new tiles for them? As soon as I know that I'll initiate the conversation with them.
Flags: needinfo?(paulj)
Let's save this for next year :)
Status: NEW → RESOLVED
Closed: 11 years ago
Resolution: --- → WONTFIX
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.

Attachment

General

Created:
Updated:
Size: