Open Bug 1295770 Opened 10 years ago Updated 2 years ago

Feature Request: A "safe view" option for examining suspicious emails

Categories

(Thunderbird :: Security, enhancement)

enhancement

Tracking

(Not tracked)

UNCONFIRMED

People

(Reporter: hmwamboldt, Unassigned)

Details

(Keywords: dupeme)

User Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; WOW64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/52.0.2743.116 Safari/537.36 Steps to reproduce: When a suspicious email arrives (almost always a phish) it is properly marked as junk. I can right click on the email listed in the thread pane and delete the email, but there is no option for "safe viewing". Expected results: For unsophisticated users, there should only be four options for junk email: Delete - without processing the email in any way. Safe Viewing - shows only the text content of the email. Save to a file - so the email can be safely forwarded to an expert. Defer - to deal with later. The current system is Ok for sophisticated users (but the ability to send the email *directly* to a safe viewer would be appreciated); so a switch to disable the above "novice mode" would be useful; but the current system is confusing, unhelpful, and problematic for unsophisticated users who could not tell you what half of the right click menu items do. What they do do is panic and click on things. This is a problem. We have seen severe security problems in graphics libraries, JavaScript processing and elsewhere. It would be wonderful if Thunderbird could default to only allowing unsophisticated users to do safe things with suspicious "junk" emails.
Severity: normal → enhancement

what is unsafe about opening the email. I think that needs to be discussed so we can work out what risk is to be addressed.

Flags: needinfo?(hmwamboldt)

I think most of the issues regarding what is and isn't safe about opening malicious emails has been well documented elsewhere.
But to summarize:
(1) Unsafe libraries*;
(2) Unsafe browsers and other components activated through MIME and HTML links;
(3) Unsafe attachments;
(4) Unsafe HTML links directing to phishing sites and sites delivering malware.

In my mind, once an unsafe (or junk) email is identified**, a safe mode render of the questionable email would:
(1) Only pass a minimal number of external libraries email content.*
(2) Images and other media would not be rendered and displayed.*
(3) All active content would be disabled.***
(4) All links would be disabled.****
(5) Text would not be (HTML) formatted and would be only display basic ASCII content and perhaps a known safe subset of UTF-8.
(6) Attachments could not be clicked on or opened. At most they could be dropped into a sandbox.

The only safe mail handling operations would be to save as an *.eml.spam file or forward as an attachment.

To easily convert false positives, clicking on "Not Junk/Malware/Suspicious" would disable/toggle this "Safe Viewing" mode and revert the email to normal status. Perhaps a popup confirmation with a warning might be warranted.

To provide the user with sufficient information to identify a false positive, I would like to see the path the email took and all link domains. I've found that NA emails passing through Brazil, Argentina, Russia etc are generally suspect. On some emails only a single link leading to a suspect domain is the tip-off.

False positives are usually easily identifiable from a plain ASCII render of the message content.

Of course this is all a wish list based on the pain of unwinding problems caused by naive and careless sophisticated users thoughtlessly or accidentally clicking on suspect emails.

And as for why would anyone click on a malicious email to view it? I've found that most users can't help themselves.

Best Rgds,
-H-

  • To mitigate zero-day vulnerabilities in components such as graphics libraries, network stacks, UTF-8 libraries and others.
    ** At a minimum an unsafe email would be any email with a header marking it so (SpamAssassin etc) or any email found in a folder named Junk (Microsoft), Spam (most everyone else), etc.
    *** JavaScript, Java, etc.
    **** External HTML resources would not be pulled down off the Internet.
Flags: needinfo?(hmwamboldt)
Severity: normal → S3
Component: Untriaged → Security
Keywords: dupeme
Summary: Feature Request: A "safe view" option for examining suspecious emails → Feature Request: A "safe view" option for examining suspicious emails

It has taken me 4 years to reply here, but that elapsed time has not changed my views.

Thunderbird simply does not execute any scripting in an email body. Ever. We can simply ignore all of your concerns about scripts and loading external modules from them.

The HTML in the spam folder for mail marked as junk/spam is sanitised as simple HTML and graphics are not displayed.

So as far as I can see, there is already a safe viewing mode, and it is in use and is enabled and disabled by toggling the spam flag on the email.

There is an addon mail hops https://addons.thunderbird.net/en-US/thunderbird/addon/mailhops/?src=ss
It, as far as I can see offers your desired route for the email from the mail header. I just installed it and tried in on the first five spam mails in my spam folder. Four from the USA and one from Paris. Nothing very informative but I might keep it a while and see if it is useful.

As Thunderbirds main focus is on the home user, I really don't see corporate level controls getting much traction.

Personally, I see this request for;
A request to extend the simplified HTML view to all mail in the spam folder, not just those marked as junk.
A feature to disable parsing of links in email to a helper application or the operating system (Windows).
A feature to prevent opening attachments
A feature to limit the users ability to save an email as a file.

I think the other requested items are already extant or available through add-ons, but each of those other four items would need their own bugs if something has not already been filed..

You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.