Open Bug 2055652 Opened 4 months ago Updated 7 hours ago

[HDR/Windows] Add optional tonemapping for HDR video

Categories

(Core :: Graphics: Color Management, enhancement, P1)

enhancement

Tracking

()

People

(Reporter: ahale, Unassigned)

References

(Blocks 1 open bug)

Details

HDR video is shipping for 153.0, but some users have displays that have low ceilings for color component values around 400 nits, and some video is authored so brightly that this clamps main scene detail (particularly on a k-pop video in Bug 2023444), we should add a feature for optional tonemapping and experiment with when we want to use it and with what values - for SDR displays it should be on by default, but for HDR displays we may want to decide what the target luminance should be differently than what the display reports.

Severity: -- → S3
Priority: -- → P1

Sharing some of my findings after trying to get the most out of the less-than-HDR-mastering HDR displays I've tried:

HDR display adaptation, including tone mapping, doesn't seem to be an optional feature if one wants a good experience using an HDR display (where "good" to me seems like: not having clipped highlights in a bright environment, not having HDR content blow your eyes out in a dark environment, and not having to manually disable HDR when an app doesn't properly adapt to the display).

I.e. there seem to be mainly two parts to display adaptation: mapping the highlights outside the display's headroom to fit the current display headroom, and adapting the content brightness to the current SDR white brightness (hence the emphasis on current headroom, as it might change)... unfortunately Windows does neither automatically (at least on external displays; at least some laptop displays are a special case), while e.g. macOS, from looking at their docs, seems to offer both automagical 1.0 = SDR white adaptation and reference modes when working with HDR content...

And there's all the HDR10+/Dolby Vision/SMPTE ST 2094 stuff that exists to help preserve "author intent" while doing the adaptation... so it would be nice to support it as well...

See Also: → 2095060
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.