Closed Bug 324899 Opened 20 years ago Closed 19 years ago

Edit Message As New - is NOT sent properly under certain conditions

Categories

(Thunderbird :: General, defect)

x86
Windows XP
defect
Not set
normal

Tracking

(Not tracked)

RESOLVED DUPLICATE of bug 180997

People

(Reporter: fwsfws, Assigned: mscott)

Details

User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:1.8) Gecko/20051111 Firefox/1.5 Build Identifier: Thunderbird 1.5 (Windows/20051201) When a message is created using -- Edit Message As New AND this received message appears to be a "Reply" message, the images and formatting are lost. The images are deleted and the formating is set to fixed format. When the message is sent, it appears to be processed as a REPLY instead of forward or send. This conclusion is reached because forward and send will reain attachments. Reply deletes them. Reproducible: Always Steps to Reproduce: 1. Take a message that contains images that also contain the blue vertical lines that are used to indicate this was a reply. 2. Either save the message in drafts or send the message. Saving it will allow you to look at it and VERIFY that is is what you want. 3. Send the messge. Include a copy to yourself so that you can see what was sent. 4. Review what you receive and also the "sent" folder and you will see that the message has been reformatted AND the images have been deleted. Actual Results: The results from the send AND the results from REPLY are very similar. The significant difference -- the > used to identify the portion of the message that is the body of the reply is not indicated when "send" is used for the message created with Edit Message As New. Expected Results: The message sent should be identical to the one in the DRAFT folder, including the same formating and images. Contact me and I'll be happy to FORWARD the message causing the problem as well as the result. I created a message, sent it to myself, then used Edit Message As New to send it. It worked as expected. The difference was that my message DID NOT contain the blue lines indicating it had been a reply. If Ctrl-U was used to open the message, Ctrl-A (select all), Ctrl-C (copy) and then go to a new blank message to be sent and Ctrl-V (past) be used, Tbird would take the computer to 50% CPU utilization. After a few minutes, it would be stopped because the indication was "not responding" The original messge being pasted is a little over 700Kb.
I just discovered I could save the message and then send it as an attachment. This message contains the "reply" markers I've talked about. A message can be sent with this as an attachment and the body remains intact. However, it should NOT be necessary to save this and then put make it as an attachment. Because of size, the file can be found -- http://www.gofws.com/mozilla/gnboat.eml
(In reply to comment #0) > When a message is created using -- Edit Message As New AND this received > message appears to be a "Reply" message, the images and formatting are lost. > The images are deleted and the formating is set to fixed format. This sounds like the same basic issue as bug 180997. > When the message is sent, it appears to be processed as a REPLY instead of > forward or send. This conclusion is reached because forward and send will > reain attachments. Reply deletes them. Important difference: in the message you supply as a sample, those images are not "attachments" -- they are embedded in the HTML body. In that case, reply (as HTML) will maintain the images. Here's what's behind bug 180997: When you Edit As New, the message compose window is initialized as HTML if the original message was HTML, and as plain text if the original message. If you're set up to use HTML by default, Edit as New of an HTML message and Forward Inline of an HTML message are very similar (and neither adds an additional quote bar [blue line]). When you send an HTML message, Mozilla looks for a reason to send it as plain text. It will automatically convert the message to plain text, without notification, if: the message body contains no formatting AND the recipient of the message is not listed in your address book as "prefers to receive HTML." The bug is: an image is not considered "formatting" when the decision is made, so the message gets sent as plain text; and since there is no plain-text equivalent of the image, the image gets discarded. (In reply to comment #1) > However, it should NOT be necessary to save this and then put make it as an > attachment. You can acheive the same result by using Forward As Attachment.
No response from reporter, duping.
Status: UNCONFIRMED → RESOLVED
Closed: 19 years ago
Resolution: --- → DUPLICATE
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.