Closed Bug 4122 Opened 26 years ago Closed 25 years ago

RFE: Display source XML when no stylesheet is available for an XML document

Categories

(Core :: XML, defect, P3)

Product:
Core
Component:
XML
Type:
defect

Tracking

()

Status:
VERIFIED FIXED

People

(Reporter: roland.mainz, Assigned: nisheeth_mozilla)

Details

Both apprunner and viewer are NOT able to view plane XML (e.g. XML not assicioated with a CSS etc.). Today I've heared the xxxx-time that the most advantage of IE 5 during XML application development is this feature (e.g. view plane XML structured and colored)... No more comment... Simply DO IT (please) quickly !!!!
Assignee: don → nisheeth
Component: Apprunner → XML
QA Contact: 3853 → 3849
This is actually a feature request. Marking as such. CCing Vidur for comments.
Status: NEW → ASSIGNED
Summary: Apprunner/viewer does not display plane XML !!! → RFE: Display source XML when no stylesheet is available for an XML document
A good idea. Should be simple to do. CCing RickG.
Did someone wrote the feature request, or would this be my work ? ---- I'd like to make a XML workshop including XUL etc. in three weeks. Is it possible that someone has implemented this feature in that time ?
Setting target milestone to M7 for now...
Target Milestone: M7
Target Milestone: M7 → M9
Moving out to M9...
Sorry for the following flame, but... ...WHY moving this feature from one milestone to a higher one each time it reaches it's target milestone ? You are LOOSING developers (which are currently much more important than future customers) !! ---- Please try a simple solution first, single-node hiding/unhiding can be implemented later by someone else (maybe by me if you give me a stone to build my house on...)
A question: what defines no stylesheet being available? With namespaces, the UA may have some knowledge (in the form of a UA stylesheet) about how to display parts of the document, or maybe even all of it. What says that it should go into a source view instead? (The UA stylesheet could even be changed by the user or by a third party upgrade to recognize something you don't yet know it will recognize.) I tend to think something like this would be better off as an extension of view-source. Right now XML with no stylesheet is displayed as the CSS spec describes. In the interests of extensibility this may be a good thing.
MicroOffs's IE5 displays XML documents without stylesheets in a tree view; each tree node representsa XML/DOM tree node. The request here is to make something simmilar. Add a menu boolean item which enabled/disabled this feature. But simply ADD this ASAP because this is a very usefull feature. In fact, this is (mainly) the ONLY reason we installed IE5 on our PC boxes - simple handling of XML documents/data.
Doesn't alecf's DOM viewer do this? ("DOM Viewer" on n.p.m.rdf and n.p.m.xpfe). It's not by default on a page w/o a stylesheet, but if the spec says it shouldn't and the functionality is there at your choice, this might be the way to go. I think he said it only works for XUL and HTML at the moment, but I guess that could be changed. Then, all that is needed is to hook it up onto the menu.
Alec, please tell us more about this "DOM viewer" mentioned by matty in his earlier post. Thanks.
Sorry for the delay - I was on vacation. Anyway, I put the dom viewer in mozilla/rdf/tests/domds - it consists of a datasource which you point at a DOM, and some XUL which points a tree at the DOMDS... when waterson adds RDF resource factories again, then I have a less memory-intensive way of doing the viewer.
Can you add a menu item for the DOM viewer, please (e.g. below the "View Source..." menu item ?
The dom viewer is by no means a scheduled feature, it was more of a fun hack I was hoping someone might like to use and extend. If the editor or layout teams want to pick up some of the slack (like adding it to the windows/mac build) I'm more than willing to pitch in a whole bunch of my time to improving this thing.
The DOM viewer would be a great feature for all people which do some XML development... Please make it a scheduled feature !
Severity: critical → normal
Target Milestone: M9 → M11
Alec, lets work together during M10 to get the DOM viewer callable from an apprunner menu item. I can help you with enabling the DOM viewer on windows and mac. I've opened bug 11369 to track that effort and assigned it to you. I'm moving this bug to M11.
ok, great!
Status: ASSIGNED → RESOLVED
Closed: 25 years ago
Resolution: --- → FIXED
Alecf has checked in the DOM viewer, so I'm marking this bug fixed.
We are still missing a prefs-option which switches from correct CSS behaviour (blank page if no stylesheet) to - view source (colored) OR - start DOM tree viewer e.g. a three-choice widget: Title: View XML documents without stylesheet - as is (e.g. blank page) *default - as DOM tree - as source Should I file a RFE for this ?
Yes, please file a separate bug for that and assign it to me.
QA Contact: beppe → chrisd
Status: RESOLVED → VERIFIED
Based on 9/22 comments from reporter and the fact that he will write new bug up for remaining issues, verifying this bug fixed.
As far as I can remeber I filed this bug, right !?
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.