435526 - When 2 different filters apply to 1 message, one copies and the other moves the message, the copied message is blank and with date of 1969

Status: RESOLVED DUPLICATE of bug 398498

(Thunderbird :: General, defect)

Description

[Gonzalo]

User-Agent:       Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; es-ES; rv:1.8.1.7) Gecko/20070914 Firefox/2.0.0.7
Build Identifier: version 2.0.0.14 (20080421)

When the user receives a message (to the Inbox), which meets the criteria of 2 different filters, the first of them should make a copy of the message in a folder different than Inbox and the second one should move the message to another folder, the second filter works fine (moving) but the first one creates an empty message with date 31/12/1969 21:00. This message is completely empty, it has no sender, no receipt, no subject and no body. If the user rebuilds the index for that folder, then this "empty" message is correctly displayed, but still the first filter had not been properly respected.
This might be a minor issue, but if the user really needs a filter for those kind of messages, is because he receives lots of them every day, and it's annoying to rebuild the index of a huge folder with lots of messages every day.

Reproducible: Always

Steps to Reproduce:
1. Create a new folder named "A".
2. Create a new folder named "B".
3. Create a new filter (named qwerty) with this criteria "Subject contains "qwerty", which must perform the action "Copy message to 'A' folder".
4. Create a new filter (named asdf) with this criteria "Subject contains "asdf", which must perform the action "Move message to 'B' folder".
5. Make sure that the filter named 'qwerty' is above in the filter list than the filter named 'asdf' (this is to make sure that first the message is copied and then is moved, otherwise the second filter will not act).
6. Receive an e-mail (or send it to yourself) with the subject "qwerty asdf".

Actual Results:  
If the user goes to the "A" folder, he will find an empty new message, with no sender, no receipt, no subject and no body. The user can still read this mail if he rebuilds the index for that folder (Right click on the folder, Properties, 'Rebuild Index' button).

Expected Results:  
There should be 2 exactly equal messages, one in folder "A" and one in folder "B".

Some information that might add some information is that in my office we used to have another mail client and server (Microsoft) and a mail migration was performed.
No matter how simple or complex the filter's criteria is, it will behave the same way.

Any additional information you need, please don't hesitate to ask.

Comment 1

[Gonzalo]

Attachment: Shows the empty message